Tunable long range forces mediated by self-propelled colloidal hard spheres

Tunable long range forces mediated by self-propelled colloidal hard spheres

Ran Ni rannimail@gmail.com Van t Hoff Institute for Molecular Sciences, Universiteit van Amsterdam, Science Park 904, 1098 XH Amsterdam, The Netherlands Laboratory of Physical Chemistry and Colloid Science, Wageningen University, Dreijenplein 6, 6703 HB Wageningen, The Netherlands    Martien A. Cohen Stuart Laboratory of Physical Chemistry and Colloid Science, Wageningen University, Dreijenplein 6, 6703 HB Wageningen, The Netherlands    Peter G. Bolhuis Van t Hoff Institute for Molecular Sciences, Universiteit van Amsterdam, Science Park 904, 1098 XH Amsterdam, The Netherlands

Using Brownian dynamics simulations, we systematically study the effective interaction between two parallel hard walls in a 2D suspension of self-propelled (active) colloidal hard spheres, and we find that the effective force between two hard walls can be tuned from a long range repulsion into a long range attraction by changing the density of active particles. At relatively high densities, the active hard spheres can form a dynamic crystalline bridge, which induces a strong oscillating long range dynamic wetting repulsion between the walls. With decreasing density, the dynamic bridge gradually breaks, and an intriguing long range dynamic depletion attraction arises. A similar effect occurs in a quasi-2D suspension of self-propelled colloidal hard spheres by changing the height of the confinement. Our results open up new possibilities to manipulate the motion and assembly of microscopic objects by using active matter.

In past decades, the non-equilibrium dynamics of self-propelled particles has attracted an increasing amount of interest, which originates from the aim to understand the intriguing self-organization phenomena in nature like bird flocks, bacteria colonies, tissue repair, and cell cytoskeleton Gonzalez-Rodriguez et al. (2012). Very recently, breakthroughs in particle synthesis have enabled the fabrication of artificial colloidal microswimmers that show a high potential for applications in biosensing, drug delivery, etc Ebbens and Howse (2010). A number of different active colloidal systems have been realized in experiments, such as colloids with magnetic beads acting as artificial flagella Dreyfus et al. (2005), catalytic Janus particles Howse et al. (2007); Erbe et al. (2008); Palacci et al. (2010); Baraban et al. (2012), laser-heated metal-capped particles Volpe et al. (2011), light-activated catalytic colloidal surfers Palacci et al. (2013), and platinum-loaded stomatocytes Wilson et al. (2012). In contrast to passive colloids undergoing Brownian motion due to random thermal fluctuations of the solvent, active self-propelled colloids experience an additional force due to internal energy conversion. Although the long time dynamics of self-propelled particles is still Brownian, with a mean square displacement proportional to time ten Hagen et al. (2011), the random self-propulsion has produced a variety of strikingly new phenomena, which were never observed in corresponding systems of passive particles Mallory et al. (2014), e.g. bacteria ratchet motors Leonardo et al. (2010), meso-scale turbulence  Wensink et al. (2012), living crystals Palacci et al. (2013) etc. In this work, we address the question whether active matter can serve as a medium to generate unexpectedly large effective interactions between large immersed objects to direct their motion and assembly Angelani et al. (2011). To this purpose, we employ a simple, yet representative model system, in which we study the effective interaction between two parallel hard walls immersed in suspensions of self-propelled colloidal hard spheres. We find that when the density of particles is relatively high, a dynamic crystalline bridge forms between the two walls, which induces a strongly oscillating repulsive dynamic wetting force, with a range depending on the size of the dynamic clusters. With decreasing density of particles, this dynamic crystalline bridge becomes smaller, and the effective force between the two walls develops a long attractive tail. Intriguingly, in the limit of zero density, i.e. non-interacting ideal self-propelled particles, the effective interaction turns into a long range dynamic depletion force, with a range depending on the persistence length of the mean free path of the particles, which can be tuned by varying the self-propulsion on the particle. Therefore, our results suggest a novel way to tune the interaction between large objects by immersing them in suspensions of small self-propelled colloids. The sign of interaction can be tuned from long range repulsive to long range attractive by changing the density of particles, and the range of interaction can be controlled by varying the magnitude of self-propulsion on the particles.

Figure 1: (color online) (a) Effective forces as a function of wall-to-wall distance at density with various activity . (b) and the average density inside the confinement as function of with and . (c) as a function of at with various Gaussian size polydispersity . (d) Reduced density distribution of active particles with at , with a wall-to-wall distance and . (e) Typical snapshots of systems for density distributions in (d), respectively. (f) for as function of wall-to-wall distance for various particle densities. (g) for a self-propelled ideal particle system with and for various wall sizes . The lines are fits with . (h) for ideal particles with density for various self-propulsion and a wall size . (i) Reduced density distribution for ideal particle systems with and and 20, where the wall size is , and .

We consider a 2D suspension of (between 10,000 and 100,000) self-propelled colloidal hard spheres. The interaction between particles is modeled with a steep Weeks-Chandler-Andersen (WCA) potential, which is a good approximation of the interaction of colloidal hard spheres sup (); Filion et al. (2011); Kawasaki and Tanaka (2010). Even though the particles are driven and energy is continuously supplied to the system, we assume the solvent to be at an equilibrium temperature . The motion of particle with position and orientation can be described via the overdamped Langevin equation where the potential energy is the sum of interactions between all particle pairs, and the short-time self diffusion coefficient of particle is proportional to its inverse diameter . A stochastic force with zero mean, , describes the collisions with the solvent molecules, and satisfies with the identity matrix. In addition, the self-propulsion of particle is described by a constant force in the direction at time , which undergoes free Brownian rotation Bialké et al. (2012) with a rotational diffusion coefficient assumed according to the Stokes-Einstein relation Ni et al. (2013).

We first perform Brownian dynamics simulations of this 2D colloidal hard-sphere system at density , which is much lower than the equilibrium crystallization density of hard disks Bernard and Krauth (2011), for hundreds of Brownian times . In equilibrium, i.e. , the system stays in a homogeneous fluid state (Ref. (sup, ) Fig. S1a). It has been found that with increasing self-propulsion, the system undergoes a dynamic phase separation via nucleation and growth above a “binodal” point, and spinodal decomposition near a “spinodal” Tailleur and Cates (2008); Thompson et al. (2011); Bialké et al. (2013); Stenhammar et al. (2013); Wittkowski et al. (2014); Speck et al. (2014); Takatori et al. (2014); Buttinoni et al. (2013); Redner et al. (2013); Fily and Marchetti (2012); Cates and Tailleur (2013); Fily et al. (2014); Stenhammar et al. (2014); Theurkauff et al. (2012); Palacci et al. (2013); Buttinoni et al. (2013). At density , the binodal and spinodal of the dynamic phase separation are very close to each other Speck et al. (2014). Therefore, with increasing self-propulsion from to 60, the average dynamic cluster size increases when approaching the spinodal of the dynamic phase separation, and at , a full dynamic phase separation occurs (Ref. (sup, ) Fig. S1b-e).

Next, we put two parallel hard walls into the system, modelled as line segments with length perpendicular to the horizontal () axis, and fixed at and , where is the center-to-center distance between the two hard walls. The interaction between particle and wall is given by the WCA interaction using the minimal distance between the center of particle and the line segment sup (). A hard wall thus appears as a hard 2D spherocylinder with width and cylindrical length . We measured the effective force between walls with size immersed in the self-propelled hard sphere suspension at bulk density with various random self-propulsion (Fig. 1a). We ensure that our system is large enough to neglect the effect of the walls on the bulk phase. When , the two walls only feel a short range depletion force ( ) due to the colloidal particles, which terminates at around , where the particles start to fill the confinement area. When the random self-propulsion increases to and 40, a strong oscillating force appears between the two walls, and with increasing , both the strength and range of the force dramatically increase. The magnitude of the force reaches for . To understand the origin of this giant force, we plot the reduced density distribution of particles with for various wall-wall separations in Fig. 1d. When the wall-to-wall distance , the confined area is filled by a layer of particles (see Fig. 1e). For , a bridge of several dense layers of particles forms between the walls, visible as peaks in Fig. 1d. Typical configurations of the dynamic bridge in Fig. 1e show that it has crystalline order, in which most of the particles are on a hexagonal crystalline lattice. When the wall-wall separation further increases to , the dynamic bridge breaks (Fig. 1e), and the interaction between the two walls vanishes. To further investigate the relationship between the effective force and the dynamic crystal layering between the two walls, we plot the average particle density inside the confinement, , as a function of wall-wall separation in Fig. 1b. For , no particles are within the confinement, and the strong forces on the outside push the two walls together. For , first increases and then starts oscillating as a function of . Interestingly, the oscillation of strongly correlates with the oscillation of effective force between the two walls. Repulsive force, , is always coupled with an increase of , i.e. , while attraction, , is always coupled with the decrease of , i.e. . This strongly suggests that the effective force between the walls is induced by dynamic wetting of the living crystalline clusters in the system. However, different from the attractive wetting force in equilibrium Gnan et al. (2012), the dynamic wetting force we observed here appears to be overall repulsive, as the repulsive part is larger than the attractive part in the effective interaction. We also investigated the effect of polydispersity on the dynamic wetting force. As shown in Fig. 1c, with increasing the size polydispersity, the dynamic wetting force becomes weaker, due to the suppressed wetting by the polydispsersity. This is similar to the equilibrium wetting of hard-sphere crystals on a hard wall depending on the symmetry of the crystal and surface properties Heni and Löwen (2000); Dijkstra (2004). We also confirm that polydispersity in the magnitude of the active force does not influence the dynamic wetting force significantly sup ().

Furthermore, we study the influence of the bulk phase density of the particles on the effective wall-wall interaction. The measured reduced forces for various are shown in Fig. 1f. Decreasing the bulk density from to 0.2, reduces both the force amplitude of oscillation and its range, because the size of dynamic clusters decreases with lower density Buttinoni et al. (2013); Redner et al. (2013); Fily and Marchetti (2012). Surprisingly, an attractive tail starts to appear in the effective force, which becomes (relatively) more dominant with decreasing . In dilute systems, i.e. , except for a repulsive peak at , the force between the walls has become almost entirely attractive, with a contact value of and a range of . To understand this intriguing attraction, we study the wall-wall interaction in systems containing non-interacting ideal self-propelled particles, in which the particles do not interact with each other, but only with the two hard walls. The density distribution for various in Fig. 1i shows a strong peak when due to dynamic wetting of the self-propelled particles Elgeti and Gompper (2013); Costanzo et al. (2014). Increasing the wall-wall separation to , the dynamically wetted layers of ideal particles on the walls persist, while inside the confinement the density of particles is much lower than . Therefore, the inside surface of the walls is in contact with a lower density fluid than the outside, yielding a net attractive force pushing the two walls towards each other. As shown in Fig. 1i, further increasing eliminates the density difference between the outside and inside of the confinement, and at sufficiently large the attraction vanishes. We also plot the reduced pressure on the two walls as a function of for various wall sizes in Fig. 1g. With larger wall size , the magnitude of pressure increases, but when , the effect of the wall edges has become negligible. Moreover, the reduced pressure between walls can be well fitted with an exponential form , where can be regarded as the range of the force. With increasing random self-propulsion, both the strength and range of the effective attraction increase.

To understand the physics of the intriguing attraction mediated by self-propelled ideal particles, we studied an even simpler active particle model in which a single particle moves on a 2D () square lattice with a constant speed of lattice site per step in the or direction (see Fig. 2a). The particle has a probability to rotate by degrees. In this model, the only controlling parameter is . When , at each step the particle has a probability of to keep its current direction. Therefore, characterizes the persistence length in the random walk ; this is the expected path length before the particle turns, . Placing two parallel hard walls of 10 sites each, with the rule that if the particle hits a wall it remains at its lattice position, we perform Monte Carlo simulations long enough to reach a steady state ( steps).

Figure 2: (color online) (a) Simple model with one ideal particle (grey square) moving in a 2D square lattice, with two parallel impenetrable walls (dark squares). (b-d) Reduced density distributions for and 1, respectively. (e) Effective force between two walls for various as a function of . The solid lines are the fits with . (f) Fitted interaction range in (e) as a function of .

Figure 2b-d shows, for a fixed wall-wall separation the reduced probability distributions of the particle on the square lattice with various . When , this distribution is homogeneous, as expected. However, at or 0.5, the distribution becomes spatially heterogeneous, and the probability density inside the confinement is lower than outside. The force on the walls follows from the average probability of finding particles colliding with the wall (see Fig. 2e). The decay constant (obtained from fitting to ) depends on as (see Fig. 2f), as the range of the non-equilibrium dynamic depletion force is close to the persistence length, which is . For active Brownian hard spheres, this persistence length, signifing the loss of correlation of the direction of active motion, is not a well-defined single quantity due to the thermal fluctuations. However, one can still define a persistence length as the displacement at time at which the orientation correlation of the active force decays by a factor . This yields and 10.14 for and 40, respectively ten Hagen et al. (2011). By fitting the force with in Fig. 1h, we obtain and 16.774 for and 40, respectively. Thus, and are both on the same scale, and increase with increasing the self-propulsion. This suggests that our model of a single active lattice particle can capture the essential physics of the active Brownian particle. Nevertheless, we stress that the quantitative physics of the novel dynamic depletion induced by active particles, even in the simple lattice model requires further studies.

Finally, to make our findings relevant for micro-fluidic experiments, we study self-propelled colloidal hard spheres confined in a quasi-2D confinement (see inset Fig. 3a). The confinement height between two horizontal hard walls is  sup (). Figure 3a shows the effective interaction between two parallel finite vertical walls with , for a random self-propulsion , and a fixed 2D bulk number density , where is the area in the plane. With increasing confinement height , both the range and strength of the oscillating force mediated by confining dynamic clusters between the two vertical walls decrease, as these clusters shrink with larger . A long range attraction starts to dominate the effective interaction similar to the case of 2D active hard spheres. When , this long range attraction has a contact value around . Thus, by changing the confinement height, one can tune the effective interaction mediated by active hard spheres from a long rang repulsion into a long range attraction. Figure 3b shows that for a fixed 3D number density , with increasing the confinement height, the oscillating repulsion in the effective interaction decreases, and the attraction tail gradually increases. This is similar to decreasing the density of the particles, as in a quasi-2D system of constant volume fraction, a larger confinement height produces more free volume for particles, which effectively decreases the “density” of the particles.

Figure 3: (color online) (a) Main: as function of wall-wall separation for in quasi-2D confinement with varying height , at fixed 2D number density . Inset: a typical system snapshot with two walls as yellow bricks. (b) as function of for and varying , where the 3D number density is fixed at .

We stress that the activity studied here lies in realizable range in recent experiments. For instance, the light-activated colloids Palacci et al. (2013), the catalytic Janus particles Baraban et al. (2012), and the particles with an artificial magnetic flagella Dreyfus et al. (2005) are capable of producing self-propulsions as high as , 50, 80, respectively, which should be able to produce giant effective force to drive the self-assembly of passive particle systems. While we fix the two parallel walls during the simulation, in reality, all objects including the passive objects in the suspensions may move, so that the effect induced by active particles might be different Leonardo et al. (2010). However, it is known that the diffusivity of passive objects in solution drops dramatically with increasing sizes. Therefore, our results suggest a novel way of producing tunable long range effective interactions between colloidal particles, whose size is of orders of magnitude larger than that of the active colloidal particles, and direct their self-assembly, which was difficult to achieve by using passive particles. In this work we focus on the effective interaction produced by the general non-equilibrium feature of active matter, and neglected hydrodynamic effects that would be interesting for future experimental and theoretical studies  Molina et al. (2013). Finally, in the previous experiment studying the effective interaction between colloidal spheres mediated by active matter, i.e. bacteria, different from this work, only a short range repulsion instead of any long range forces was observed Angelani et al. (2011). The reason is that the shape of the active and passive colloids also plays an important role Harder et al. (2014).

After completing this work, we became aware of a very recent work by Ray et al. showing that in another model of run-and-tumble active particles, a similar dynamic depletion force was also observed, which suggests that the dynamic depletion force may generally appear in many active matter systems Ray et al. (2014). R.N. and M.A.C.S acknowledge financial support from the European Research Council through Advanced Grant 267254 (BioMate). This work is part of the research programme VICI 700.58.442, which is financed by the Netherlands Organization for Scientific Research (NWO). R.N. has been supported by an NWO VENI grant.


  • Gonzalez-Rodriguez et al. (2012) D. Gonzalez-Rodriguez, K. Guevorkian, S. Douezan, and F. Brochard-Wyart, Science 338, 910 (2012).
  • Ebbens and Howse (2010) S. Ebbens and J. Howse, Soft Matter 6, 726 (2010).
  • Dreyfus et al. (2005) R. Dreyfus, J. Baudry, M. Roper, M. Fermigier, H. Stone, and J. Bibette, Nature 437, 862 (2005).
  • Howse et al. (2007) J. R. Howse, R. A. L. Jones, A. J. Ryan, T. Gough, R. Vafabakhsh, and R. Golestanian, Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 048102 (2007).
  • Erbe et al. (2008) A. Erbe, M. Zientara, L. Baraban, C. Kreidler, and P. Leiderer, J. Phys.: Condens. Matter 20, 404215 (2008).
  • Palacci et al. (2010) J. Palacci, C. Cottin-Bizonne, C. Ybert, and L. Bocquet, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105, 088304 (2010).
  • Baraban et al. (2012) L. Baraban, M. Tasinkevych, M. Popescu, S. Sanchez, S. Dietrich, and O. Schmidt, Soft Matter 8, 48 (2012).
  • Volpe et al. (2011) G. Volpe, I. Buttinoni, D. Vogt, H. Kümmerer, and C. Bechinger, Soft Matter 7, 8810 (2011).
  • Palacci et al. (2013) J. Palacci, S. Sacanna, A. P. Steinberg, D. J. Pine, and P. M. Chaikin, Science 339, 936 (2013).
  • Wilson et al. (2012) D. A. Wilson, R. J. M. Nolte, and J. C. M. van Hest, Nature Chemistry 4, 268 (2012).
  • ten Hagen et al. (2011) B. ten Hagen, S. van Teeffelen, and H. Löwen, J. Phys.: Condensed Matter 23, 194119 (2011).
  • Mallory et al. (2014) S. A. Mallory, A. Saric, C. Valeriani, and A. Cacciuto, Phys. Rev. E 89, 052303 (2014).
  • Leonardo et al. (2010) R. D. Leonardo, L. Angelani, D. DellArciprete, G. Ruocco, V. Iebba, S. Schippa, M. Conte, F. Mecarini, F. D. Angelis, and E. D. Fabrizio, Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 107, 9541 (2010).
  • Wensink et al. (2012) H. Wensink, J. Dunkel, S. Heidenreich, K. Drescher, R. Goldstein, H. Löwen, and J. Yeomans, Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 109, 14308 (2012).
  • Angelani et al. (2011) L. Angelani, C. Maggi, M. L. Bernardini, A. Rizzo, and R. Di Leonardo, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 138302 (2011).
  • (16) Supplimentary materials of the model, the typical snapshots of the bulk 2D self-propelled hard-sphere systems, and the effect of polydispersity of active force on the dynamic wetting force mediated by active hard spheres.
  • Filion et al. (2011) L. Filion, R. Ni, D. Frenkel, and M. Dijkstra, J. Chem. Phys. 134, 134901 (2011).
  • Kawasaki and Tanaka (2010) T. Kawasaki and H. Tanaka, Proc. Natl Acad. Sci. USA 107, 14036 (2010).
  • Bialké et al. (2012) J. Bialké, T. Speck, and H. Löwen, Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 168301 (2012).
  • Ni et al. (2013) R. Ni, M. Cohen-Stuart, and M. Dijkstra, Nat. Commun. 4, 2704 (2013).
  • Bernard and Krauth (2011) E. P. Bernard and W. Krauth, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107, 155704 (2011).
  • Tailleur and Cates (2008) J. Tailleur and M. E. Cates, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100, 218103 (2008).
  • Thompson et al. (2011) A. G. Thompson, J. Tailleur, M. E. Cates, and R. A. Blythe, Journal of Statistical Mechanics: Theory and Experiment 2011, P02029 (2011).
  • Bialké et al. (2013) J. Bialké, H. Löwen, and T. Speck, EPL (Europhysics Letters) 103, 30008 (2013).
  • Stenhammar et al. (2013) J. Stenhammar, A. Tiribocchi, R. J. Allen, D. Marenduzzo, and M. E. Cates, Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 145702 (2013).
  • Wittkowski et al. (2014) R. Wittkowski, A. Tiribocchi, J. Stenhammar, R. Allen, D. Marenduzzo, and M. Cates, Nat. Commun. 5, 4351 (2014).
  • Speck et al. (2014) T. Speck, J. Bialké, A. M. Menzel, and H. Löwen, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 218304 (2014).
  • Takatori et al. (2014) S. C. Takatori, W. Yan, and J. F. Brady, Phys. Rev. Lett. 113, 028103 (2014).
  • Buttinoni et al. (2013) I. Buttinoni, J. Bialké, F. Kümmel, H. Löwen, C. Bechinger, and T. Speck, Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 238301 (2013).
  • Redner et al. (2013) G. Redner, M. Hagan, and A. Baskaran, Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 055701 (2013).
  • Fily and Marchetti (2012) Y. Fily and M. C. Marchetti, Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 235702 (2012).
  • Cates and Tailleur (2013) M. E. Cates and J. Tailleur, EPL (Europhysics Letters) 101, 20010 (2013).
  • Fily et al. (2014) Y. Fily, S. Henkes, and M. C. Marchetti, Soft Matter 10, 2132 (2014).
  • Stenhammar et al. (2014) J. Stenhammar, D. Marenduzzo, R. J. Allen, and M. E. Cates, Soft Matter 10, 1489 (2014).
  • Theurkauff et al. (2012) I. Theurkauff, C. Cottin-Bizonne, J. Palacci, C. Ybert, and L. Bocquet, Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 268303 (2012).
  • Gnan et al. (2012) N. Gnan, E. Zaccarelli, and F. Sciortino, J. Chem. Phys. 137, 084903 (2012).
  • Heni and Löwen (2000) M. Heni and H. Löwen, Phys. Rev. Lett. 85, 3668 (2000).
  • Dijkstra (2004) M. Dijkstra, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 108303 (2004).
  • Elgeti and Gompper (2013) J. Elgeti and G. Gompper, EPL (Europhysics Letters) 101, 48003 (2013).
  • Costanzo et al. (2014) A. Costanzo, J. Elgeti, T. Auth, G. Gompper, and M. Ripoll, EPL (Europhysics Letters) 107, 36003 (2014).
  • Molina et al. (2013) J. Molina, Y. Nakayama, and R. Yamamoto, Soft Matter 9, 4923 (2013).
  • Harder et al. (2014) J. Harder, S. A. Mallorya, C. Tung, C. Valeriani, and A. Cacciuto, J. Chem. Phys. 141, 194901 (2014).
  • Ray et al. (2014) D. Ray, C. Reichhardt, and C. J. O. Reichhardt, Phys. Rev. E 90, 013019 (2014).

Appendix A Supplementary Materials

In the 2D system of active hard spheres, the interaction between particle and is modeled with a steep Weeks-Chandler-Andersen (WCA) potential given by


where is the center-to-center distance between the two spheres, and is the diameter of the particles, with and the Boltzmann constant and the temperature of the system , respectively. Here, the strength of the interaction is set . Moreover, the interaction between particle and wall is given by , in which is minimal distance between the center of particle and points on the line segment .

In the quasi-2D system of active hard spheres confined betwen two horizontal walls, the interaction between particle at and the two horizontal walls is


where is the height of the confinement.

Figure S1: (a-e) Typical snapshots of 2D systems of self-propelled colloidal hard spheres at density with self-propulsion and 80, respectively. (f) Illustration of the system to study the interaction mediated by the dynamic clusters of self-propelled colloidal hard spheres, and the two vertical lines indicate the two parallel hard walls. The red arrows indicate the direction of random self-propulsion.

The effect of polydispersity of active force on the dynamic wetting force is shown in Fig. S2. The self-propulsion on particle is given by


where is average active force in the system, and is a Gaussian random number with zero mean and the standard deviation .

Figure S2: Effective interaction between two parallel walls as a function of wall-wall distance for systems of active hard spheres with different polydisperse active propulsions . The density of the system is fixed at , and the average self-propulsion is with the particle diameter.
Comments 0
Request Comment
You are adding the first comment!
How to quickly get a good reply:
  • Give credit where it’s due by listing out the positive aspects of a paper before getting into which changes should be made.
  • Be specific in your critique, and provide supporting evidence with appropriate references to substantiate general statements.
  • Your comment should inspire ideas to flow and help the author improves the paper.

The better we are at sharing our knowledge with each other, the faster we move forward.
The feedback must be of minimum 40 characters and the title a minimum of 5 characters
Add comment
Loading ...
This is a comment super asjknd jkasnjk adsnkj
The feedback must be of minumum 40 characters
The feedback must be of minumum 40 characters

You are asking your first question!
How to quickly get a good answer:
  • Keep your question short and to the point
  • Check for grammar or spelling errors.
  • Phrase it like a question
Test description