Spectroscopy of the hot pulsating star \beta Cephei.Velocities and EWs from C,N,O and Si lines

Spectroscopy of the hot pulsating star  Cephei.
Velocities and EWs from C,N,O and Si lines

G. Catanzaro gca@oact.inaf.it F. Leone I. Busá P. Romano INAF-Osservatorio Astrofisico di Catania, via S. Sofia 78, 95123 Catania, Italy Sezione Astrofisica-Dipartimento di Fisica e Astronomia, Università di Catania, via S. Sofia 78, 95123 Catania, Italy
Abstract

Frequencies in oscillating Cephei stars are usually inferred by means of radial velocities measured from the Siiii triplet  4552 - 4574 Å. These lines, relatively insensitive to the variation of T through a pulsation cycle, show small equivalent width variations.

In this study we aimed to verify if the behavior of radial velocities and equivalent widths measured from other ions are compatible with the one observed from Siiii lines and than to verify the possible vertical stratification along the stellar atmosphere. For this reason we selected from our spectra a number of, unblended and well isolated, Cii, Nii and Oii lines besides the famous Siiii triplet. All those lines cover the range in optical depth between -2.1 and -0.5.

Unfortunately, we did not find any differences in the radial velocities behavior line-by-line and then we derived the frequency of the principal radial mode combining all the velocities derived from each spectral line separately. The inferred frequency was  = 5.249677  0.000007 c d.

Another important task we would like to accomplish with this paper is to make available to the community our large sample of spectroscopic data, that is 932 velocities and equivalent widths measured from our sample of C, N, O and Si lines. All the spectra were acquired at the 1-meter class telescope of the stellar station of the INAF - Osservatorio Astrofisico di Catania, in the period starting from July, the 27 2005 to November, the 1 2006.

keywords:
Astronomical catalogs, Pulsations, oscillations, and stellar seismology, Low-amplitude blue variables
Pacs:
95.80.+p, 97.10.Sj, 97.30.Dg
journal: New Astronomythanks: Based on observations collected at the 91 cm telescope of the INAF - Osservatorio Astrofisico di Catania

, Corresponding author. , and

1 Introduction

The star Cephei (HD 205021) is the prototype of a class of hot pulsating variables. For complete reviews on Cephei stars, we refer the readers to Aerts & De Cat (2003), who describe in detail the line-profile variations and to Sterken & Jerzykiewicz (1992), who give an overview of the photometric behavior of all the Cep stars known up to that time.

From the spectroscopic point of view, the data used to recover frequencies of oscillations are commonly the radial velocities. Checking through the most recent literature published on this topic, it is easy to realize that the common guideline is to derive the velocities from the lines of the Siiii triplet at 4552, 4567 and 4574 Å. There are three common reasons for this choice: they are strong lines not affected very much by blending and almost insensitive to the temperature variations (De Ridder et al., 2002).

Up to the study by Aerts et al. (1994), Cephei has been believed to oscillate with only a single radial mode. In their analysis these authors revealed the multi-periodicity of this star detecting three frequencies in total:  = 5.2497104 c d,  = 5.385 c d and  = 4.920 c d. Later on, Telting et al. (1997) by a CLEANing analysis of the same data added two more frequencies:  = 5.083 c d and  = 5.417 c d.

Further, the star Cep (V = 3.2) is actually a complicated multiple system. In fact the star, beside to have a visual companion (V = 7.9) at a distance of 13.4”, is also a member of a spectroscopic system whose second star was discovered by Gezari et al. (1972), using speckle interferometry, at a distance of 0.25” (V = 6.6). The parameters of the close binary orbit have been determined later by Pigulsky & Boratyn (1992) from speckle interferometry and the variations in the pulsation period, due to the so-called light time effect. Recent speckle measurements by Hartkopf et al. (2001) place the position of the companion to about 0.1” from the primary. More observation are still necessary to improve the orbital solution.

Another question, people are still debating, is the nature of the random variable H emission which was the cause of the Be status assigned to Cep. The problem was that typically Be stars are rapid rotators while Cep has an equatorial velocity of 26 km s (Morel et al., 2006). Hadrava & Harmanec (1996), attempted to solve this problem argued that the observed emission is due to the secondary component of the spectroscopic binary which is probably a Be star. They, for the first time, separated the emission and absorption component of the H profile. Recently, Schnerr et al. (2006) confirmed this result using data obtained at Nordic Optical Telescope. Unfortunately, they obtained only one spectrum and, then, no conclusion about the variability of the emission could be drawn.

Starting from the pioneering work by Osaki (1971), a lot of studies have been undertaken with the aims to infer the oscillation modes from the analysis of line profile variation (LPV). It is generally accepted that the weakness of these studies is the lack in the knowledge of how some important thermodynamic quantities change during the pulsation. For instance, during each pulsation cycle effective temperature, surface gravity and microturbulent velocity are expected to change with time and than the knowledge of their effect on the line profiles could avoid errors in the modes determination.

It is a matter of fact that, because of its low rotational velocity, the spectrum of Cephei is full of lines generated by various chemical elements at different depths in the photosphere. The analysis of the radial velocity inferred from a sample of lines opportunely selected could be useful to study the velocity stratification along the photosphere. A similar approach has been tempted by Baldry et al. (1998) in a spectroscopy study of the roAp star  Cir. In this study latter authors selected a sample of spectral region containing various metallic lines and they found a dependence of the amplitudes with the depth along the atmosphere.

With the aim to infer if a similar stratification is present also in Cep, we selected from our spectra as many as possible lines not affected by blends, sufficiently isolated to allow an easy measurements and well distributed along the atmosphere. A complete list of selected lines is reported in Tab. 2. In this paper we present a large time-resolved dataset of line-by-line radial velocities collected from July 2005 to November 2006, for a total of 932 spectra and, moreover, for the first time we present also their equivalent widths.

Velocities and equivalent widths can be retrieved from the CDS via anonymous ftp.

JD n JD n
3579 56 3933 49
3580 44 4013 35
3581 46 4016 30
3635 65 4017 26
3672 64 4018 41
3673 95 4019 43
3674 82 4021 19
3871 58 4022 18
3872 61 4023 5
3873 64 4041 31
Table 1: Journal of observations. JD are in the form JD - 2450000, n is the number of spectra collected in each night.

2 Observations and data reduction

All the data analyzed in this study have been obtained at the 91 cm telescope of the INAF - Osservatorio Astrofisico di Catania. The telescope is fiber linked to a REOSC echelle spectrograph, which allows to obtain R = 20 000 spectra in the range 4300-6800 Å. The resolving power has been checked using emission lines of the Th-Ar calibration lamp. Spectra were recorded on a thinned, back-illuminated (SITE) CCD with 1024 x 1024 pixels of 24 m size, typical readout noise of 6.5 e and gain of 2.5 ph/ADU.

Our observations (932 spectra in total) were spread over a baseline greater than one year, precisely from July, the 27 2005 (JD = 2453579) to November, the 1 2006 (JD = 2454041), for a total of 462.14 days. The exposure time was set to 5 minutes, with the exception of a couple of nights in October 2006 during which we had to increase it to 10 minutes because of the bad weather condition. This leads to a temporal resolution of  2 and  4, respectively, of the pulsational period, small enough in both cases to avoid phase smearing effects. The signal-to-noise ratio of our spectra resulted always above 150.

The stellar spectra, calibrated in wavelength and with the continuum normalized to a unity level, were obtained using standard data reduction procedures for spectroscopic observations within the NOAO/IRAF package, that is: bias frame subtraction, trimming, scattered light correction, flat-fielding, fitting traces and orders extraction and, finally, wavelength calibration. IRAF package rvcorrect has been used to include the velocity correction due to the Earth’s motions, all the spectra were then reduced into the heliocentric rest of frame.

Systematic errors on radial velocities have been estimated observing stars with constant and well known radial velocity taken from the list of standard stars published by Udry et al. (1999): HD 12929, HD 20902, HD 186791 and HD 206778. Whenever it was not possible to obtain a spectrum of a standard star, we evaluated the systematic shift from the wavelength positions of the strong telluric lines between 6275 Å and 6320 Å.

Figure 1: Phase diagrams of the radial velocity variations derived by carbon, nitrogen, oxygen and silicon lines (left side) and velocities computed from average over all the lines selected (right side). Parameters of the over-imposed sinusoidal fits are reported in Tab. 2. Error bars extend for  1 .

3 Radial velocities and equivalent widths measurements

As we stated before, radial velocities in this class of pulsating stars are usually measured from the Siiii triplet. Here we have considered the heliocentric V measured from lines of other ions with the final aim to verify if their behavior is different line-by-line. Thus, we selected all the strong, unblended lines present in the spectral range covered by our spectra. These lines are reported in the first column of Tab. 2 and are, precisely, 2 lines belonging to Cii, 5 to Nii, 2 to Oii and 3 lines to Siiii.

For each of these lines we adopted as radial velocity the value obtained from the barycentric wavelength which has been converted in radial velocity via the classical Doppler shift formula. The integrations evaluated to compute and the equivalent width (EW) of each line extend over a carefully chosen, constant region in wavelength and they have been evaluated after a local re-normalization of the continuum close to the edges of the line. This procedure let us to minimize the systematic effects due to the arbitrary choice of the lines boundaries or the position of the continuum. Errors on V and EW have been computed from a formal application of the error propagation rules to the used equations, assuming that the main source of error is the noise in the observed spectrum.

Single values of radial velocities and equivalent widths are presented only in the online tables111Table 1 reports lines from Cii 6578 to Nii 5676, Table 2 reports lines from Nii 5679 to Siiii 4574, available at the CDS, which are organized as follow: the first column reports the heliocentric julian date, the others reported line-by-line the measured radial velocities and equivalent widths together with their errors. Blank space means a discarded line profile contaminated by cosmic rays.

HRV fit parameters EW fit parameters
           freq K rel. K
        (Å) (c/d) (km s) (km s) (%) (mÅ) (mÅ)
Cii 6578.052 2.11 5.24967(1) 3.2  0.6 15.5  0.1 0.526  0.001 9.5 88.2  0.2 8.4  0.2 0.28  0.01
Cii 6582.882 1.84 5.24967(1) 3.3  0.5 13.5  0.1 0.544  0.002 9.9 82.4  0.2 8.1  0.2 0.19  0.01
Nii 4607.153 0.53 5.24969(2) 1.9  0.4 15.3  0.2 0.456  0.002 9.1 56.0  0.2 5.2  0.3 0.19  0.01
Nii 5010.621 0.53 5.24967(2) 1.8  0.5 13.1  0.2 0.530  0.002 7.4 51.0  0.3 3.8  0.4 0.24  0.02
Nii 5666.629 0.97 5.24967(2) 3.1  0.5 14.1  0.2 0.528  0.002 8.4 83.3  0.2 7.0  0.2 0.18  0.01
Nii 5676.017 0.82 5.24967(2) 4.3  0.4 13.3  0.2 0.536  0.003 7.9 69.4  0.2 5.5  0.2 0.19  0.01
Nii 5679.558 1.27 5.24968(1) 4.5  0.6 14.3  0.2 0.500  0.002 7.1 120.2  0.2 8.5  0.2 0.21  0.01
Oii 4591.010 0.82 5.24967(1) 5.3  0.7 15.1  0.1 0.544  0.001 1.2 120.5  0.3 1.5  0.4 0.05  0.04
Oii 4661.643 0.97 5.24966(1) 4.7  0.7 15.9  0.1 0.597  0.001 1.9 121.5  0.3 2.4  0.4 0.39  0.03
Siiii 4552.622 1.70 5.24967(1) 1.9  0.8 14.4  0.1 0.535  0.002 2.5 209.0  0.2 5.2  0.3 0.33  0.01
Siiii 4567.840 1.41 5.24967(1) 2.6  0.7 15.0  0.1 0.556  0.001 2.7 174.3  0.2 4.8  0.3 0.36  0.01
Siiii 4574.757 0.97 5.24968(1) 3.2  0.6 15.4  0.1 0.505  0.001 2.9 117.9  0.2 3.4  0.3 0.27  0.02
All 5.249677(7) 3.5  0.4 15.5  0.1 0.516  0.001
Table 2: Parameters and relative errors of the sinusoidal fits presented in Fig. 1 and in Fig. 3. For each line we report respectively: wavelenght, , derived frequecy of the principal radial mode (in parentheses the estimated error), , semi-amplitude and phase of the variation. Columns from seventh to tenth reported the parameters derived for the fits of EWs, that is: relative amplitude, average, semi-amplitude and phase of the variations.
Figure 2: In this figure we report as a function of optical depth the computed frequencies, center of mass (), amplitudes and phases derived from the fit of velocities for each of the selected lines. Meaning of the symbols is: circles (red) carbon lines, stars (magenta) silicon lines, triangles (blues) oxygen lines and boxes (green) nitrogen lines.

4 Data Analisys

One of the most used code to analyse a large set of periodic data in order to obtain frequency, velocity of center of mass (), amplitude of the variation (K) and phase (), is Period04 developed by Lenz & Breguer (2005). We used this code to perform a line-by-line sinusoidal fit of our velocities. For each selected line, we reported in Tab. 2 frequency, , amplitude K and phase and relative errors as determinated by using that code. Each box on the left side of Fig. 1 shows the velocities derived line by line folded with the corresponding frequency and with the sinusoidal fit over-imposed.

With the aim to search for vertical stratification, we plotted all the quantities reported in Tab. 2 regarding the velocity versus optical depths. To compute the optical depths, we used the code XLINOP (Kurucz & Avrett, 1981) applied to LTE atmospheric model with T = 24000 K,  = 3,9, solar metalicity and  = 8 km . These atmospheric values have been derived by us in the framework of a detailed abundances revision that it is currently under study. As we shown in Fig. 2, there is no evidence of some kind of stratification through the stellar atmosphere, at least in the range of optical depth probed by our lines.

Since the results obtained line-by-line are consistent, with the aim to improve the quality of our measurements, we computed the radial velocity as an average over the values obtained from all lines, without paying any attention to the different chemical species. In this case, the fitting procedure described before gave us the results presented in the last row of Tab. 2 and then we adopted it as frequencies of the radial mode of Cep:  = 5.249677  0.000007 c d. The corresponding phase diagram is shown in the right side of Fig. 1. The epoch used for the plot is that of the minimum radius, that is HJD = 24 53579.2649.

Since the study by Pigulsky & Boratyn (1992), it is well known that Cephei shows apparent changes of its pulsation period because the light - time effect induced by the orbital motion of the binary system. In our conclusion we have neglected this effect since our time baseline covers scarcely 1.4  of the orbital period, estimated by those authors in 91.6 yrs.

As a by-product, we measured also the equivalent widths of each selected line. In Fig. 3 (left side), we show the phase diagrams obtained for all the EW measured for the selected lines phased with the ephemeris derived from the velocities. As we stated in the previous section, all these lines are unblended and sufficiently isolated to avoid contamination from nearby lines. Sinusoidal fits over-imposed on the experimental data have been computed neglecting those points for which their relative errors exceed 20  and keeping all the points within  3  from the mean value, where is the standard deviation. The parameters of the sinusoidal fits with their errors are presented in Tab. 2. We did find variations with small amplitude for some lines as for example Oii 4661 Å and Siiii lines (relative amplitudes  3 ). A more marked variability, up to  10 , has instead been inferred for Nii and Cii lines.

Despite difficulties in measuring the EW of a spectral line, for instance the choice of line limits and continuum, the phase diagrams showed a scatter not justified if related to errors. For the sake of clarity, we showed in Fig. 3 (right side) the EW measured in 10 different nights for the Nii 5679 Å line. Similar behavior have been observed also in the variations of the others spectral lines here considered. A so complex changing, observed night by night, could be ascribed to the multi-periodic nature of Cep (Aerts et al. (1994), Telting et al. (1997)).

Figure 3: (Left side) Variability of the measured equivalent widths for all the selected lines. Parameters of the sinusoidal fits over-imposed are those reported in Tab. 2. (Right side) Equivalent width variations for the Nii 5679 Å observed in ten different nights. In each box we indicated the julian day - 24 50000.

5 Conclusions and discussion

Spectroscopic observations of Cephei have been carried out at the stellar station of the INAF - Osservatorio Astrofisico di Catania, in total we collected 932 spectra with a time baseline covering more than one year.

As for the radial velocities we checked the behavior of velocities coming from different lines and for each group of velocities we computed the pulsation frequency of the radial mode, the , amplitude and phase of the relative sinusoidal fit. Plotting these values as a function of the optical depth of each line we do not see any evidence of stratification through the stellar atmosphere. For what that concerns equivalent widths, we showed their behavior in time and, in the case of the Nii 5679.558 Å, the possible influence of the non-radial pulsation on the amplitude and shape observed night by night. Further, we did find clear variability for Cii and Nii lines, while Siiii and Oii  4661 Å show very small amplitude. For Oii  4591 Å we concluded that its EW is constant with time, at least at the resolving power of our spectra.

At the end, we think that such large data set of data, radial velocities and equivalent widths, could be useful for a number of studies, like for instance the study of the orbit utilizing the light-time effect or frequencies analysis, so we would like put them at astronomical communinity’s disposal.

References

  • Aerts & De Cat (2003) Aerts, C., & De Cat, P. 2003, Space Science Reviews, 105, 453
  • Aerts et al. (1994) Aerts, C., Mathias, P., Gillet, D., & Waelkens, C. 1994, A&A, 286, 109
  • Baldry et al. (1998) Baldry, I. K., Bedding, T. R., Viskum, M., Kjeldsen, H., & Frandsen, S. 1998, MNRAS, 295, 33
  • De Ridder et al. (2002) De Ridder, J., Dupret, M.-A., Neuforge, C., & Aerts, C. 2002, A&A, 385, 572
  • Gezari et al. (1972) Gezari, D. Y., Labeyrie, A., & Stachnik, R. V. 1972, ApJ, 173, L1
  • Hadrava & Harmanec (1996) Hadrava, P., & Harmanec, P. 1996, A&A, 315, L401
  • Hartkopf et al. (2001) Hartkopf, W., Mason, B., Wycoff, G., & McAlister, H. 2001, Fourth Catalog of Interferometric Measurements of Binary Stars
  • Kurucz & Avrett (1981) Kurucz, R. L., & Avrett, E. H. 1981 SAO Special Report, 391
  • Lenz & Breguer (2005) Lenz P., & Breger M. 2005, CoAst, 146, 53
  • Morel et al. (2006) Morel, T., Butler, K., Aerts, C., Neiner, C., & Briquet, M. 2006, A&A, 457, 651
  • Osaki (1971) Osaki, Y. 1971, PASJ, 23, 485
  • Pigulsky & Boratyn (1992) Pigulsky, A. & Boratyn, D. A. 1992, A&A, 253, 178
  • Schnerr et al. (2006) Schnerr, R. S., Henrichs, H. F., Oudmaijer, R. D., & Telting J. H. 2006, A&A, 459, L21
  • Stellingwerf (1978) Stellingwerf, R. F. 1978, ApJ, 224, 953
  • Sterken & Jerzykiewicz (1992) Sterken, C., & Jerzykiewicz, M. 1992, Space Science Reviews, 62, 95
  • Telting et al. (1997) Telting, J. H., Aerts, C., & Mathias, P. 1997, A&A, 322, 493
  • Udry et al. (1999) Udry, S., Mayor, M., & Queloz, D. 1999, Precise Stellar Radial Velocities, IAU Colloq. 170, ed. J. B. Heamshaw, & C. D. Scarfe, ASP Conf. Ser., 185, 367
Comments 0
Request Comment
You are adding the first comment!
How to quickly get a good reply:
  • Give credit where it’s due by listing out the positive aspects of a paper before getting into which changes should be made.
  • Be specific in your critique, and provide supporting evidence with appropriate references to substantiate general statements.
  • Your comment should inspire ideas to flow and help the author improves the paper.

The better we are at sharing our knowledge with each other, the faster we move forward.
""
The feedback must be of minimum 40 characters and the title a minimum of 5 characters
   
Add comment
Cancel
Loading ...
101649
This is a comment super asjknd jkasnjk adsnkj
Upvote
Downvote
""
The feedback must be of minumum 40 characters
The feedback must be of minumum 40 characters
Submit
Cancel

You are asking your first question!
How to quickly get a good answer:
  • Keep your question short and to the point
  • Check for grammar or spelling errors.
  • Phrase it like a question
Test
Test description