On the robustness of entanglement in analogue gravity systems

On the robustness of entanglement in analogue gravity systems

D E Bruschi111Present address: Racah Institute of Physics and Quantum Information Science, Givat Ram, Hebrew University of Jerusalem, 91904, Jerusalem, Israel, N Friis, I Fuentes222Ivette Fuentes previously published as Ivette Fuentes-Guridi and Ivette Fuentes-Schuller and S Weinfurtner School of Electronic and Electrical Engineering, University of Leeds, Woodhouse Lane, Leeds LS2 9JT, United Kingdom School of Mathematical Sciences, University of Nottingham, University Park, Nottingham NG7 2RD, United Kingdom Institute for Quantum Optics and Quantum Information, Austrian Academy of Sciences, Technikerstr. 21a, A-6020 Innsbruck, Austria SISSA, Via Bonomea 265, 34136, Trieste, Italy and INFN, Sezione di Trieste
January 2013July 13, 2019
January 2013July 13, 2019

We investigate the possibility to generate quantum-correlated quasi-particles utilizing analogue gravity systems. The quantumness of these correlations is a key aspect of analogue gravity effects and their presence allows for a clear separation between classical and quantum analogue gravity effects. However, experiments in analogue systems, such as Bose-Einstein condensates, and shallow water waves, are always conducted at non-ideal conditions, in particular, one is dealing with dispersive media at nonzero temperatures. We analyze the influence of the initial temperature on the entanglement generation in analogue gravity phenomena. We lay out all the necessary steps to calculate the entanglement generated between quasi-particle modes and we analytically derive an upper bound on the maximal temperature at which given modes can still be entangled. We further investigate a mechanism to enhance the quantum correlations. As a particular example we analyze the robustness of the entanglement creation against thermal noise in a sudden quench of an ideally homogeneous Bose-Einstein condensate, taking into account the super-sonic dispersion relations.

03.65.Ud, 11.10.-z

1 Introduction

Can quantum effects in curved spacetimes be simulated in compact, laboratory-based experimental setups? Following the formal analogy between quantum field theory on curved spacetimes and classical fluid systems that was established by W. G. Unruh in [1], this question has captivated researchers for decades (see, e.g., Ref. [2] for a recent review). In particular, the prospect of accessible experimental setups to test the quantum effects of varying spacetime backgrounds has motivated scientists, who have subsequently directed their ingenuity and effort towards the study of analogue gravity systems. The range of physical systems in which such simulations can be performed is vast, reaching from actual shallow water waves [3, 4, 5, 6], and Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs) [7, 8, 9], to laser pulse filaments [10, 11], to name but a few.

A central aim in such studies is the observation of radiation that can be associated to quantum pair creation processes, for instance, to the Hawking-, Unruh- and the dynamical Casimir effect. All of these effects rely on similar mechanisms in quantum field theory, i.e., particle creation due to time-dependent gravitational fields and boundary conditions, or the presence of horizons. It is then only natural to ask what are the criteria for associating the effects of quantum field theory with the analogue systems. How can these criteria distinguish quantum from classical scattering processes? In particular, since it is a matter of ongoing debate which systems actually exhibit quantum effects, while others, e.g., water waves, are not expected to produce genuine quantum effects at all. One aspect that has already been studied theoretically [12], and has been rigourously tested in experiments is the spectrum of the radiation and its relation to the effective gravitational field (see, e.g., Ref. [4]). However, it might be argued that the ingredient that is missing so far is the verification of the quantumness of the observed radiation via a direct detection of entanglement, which cannot be inferred from the spectrum alone without additional information. Efforts have been directed towards addressing this issue by studying non-classical behaviour as captured by sub-Poissónian statistics and the connected violation of Cauchy-Schwarz inequalities [13, 14]. However, the most paradigmatic quantum mechanical feature—entanglement—has not yet been verified in analogue gravity systems, despite the fact that typical pair creation processes in curved spacetime scenarios [15] involve the creation of mode entanglement. For instance, entanglement is created between modes of quantum fields in an expanding spacetime (see, e.g., Ref. [16]), a system that has been previously studied in the context of analogue gravity (see, for example, Refs. [17, 18, 19]). However, the presence of quantum correlations depends not only on the presence of entangling processes, but also on the initial state of the system. The temperature in the system needs to be low enough to allow entanglement to be generated.

Here we study how robust possible entanglement generation phenomena in analogue gravity systems, e.g., in BEC simulations of an expanding universe [20, 21, 16] and the dynamical Casimir effect [9], are against such thermal noise. For this purpose we connect the techniques for quantum information processing with continuous variables (see, e.g., Ref. [22]) and relativistic quantum information (RQI). During the last decade the RQI community has developed techniques to quantify entanglement in quantum field theory (for a review see, e.g., Ref. [23]). While previous work, see, e.g., Refs. [24, 25], has already provided model specific discussions, in this article we apply the framework recently developed within RQI [26, 27] to establish the first general description of entanglement generation in analogue gravity systems, including such effects as initial temperatures and nonlinear dispersion relations. Connecting RQI and analogue gravity promises to be a fruitful endeavour. We address the central question: Is it in principle possible to observe quantum correlations in analogue gravity systems? Naively, the answer is: Yes. But, the effects are highly sensitive to the levels of thermal noise. We provide closed analytical expressions for the required maximal background temperatures. Our framework applies directly to all analogue gravity systems where only two degrees of freedom are mixed. For example, all homogeneous analogue gravity systems and such inhomogeneous systems where only two phononic modes become entangled. In cases where more degrees of freedom are mixed, for example in the presence of inhomogeneities, our results can be considered as a limiting case that supplies an upper bound for the allowed temperature by virtue of the monogamy of entanglement [28]. Our criteria thus represent critical benchmarks that need to be taken into account by the next generation of analogue gravity experiments. In addition, we consider a scheme—entanglement resonances—to enhance the generation of quantum correlations to overcome temperature restrictions. We illustrate our results for a particular example, an ideally homogeneous BEC undergoing a single sudden quench, i.e., a change of the speed of sound, or series of such transformations, for which we explicitly include the effects of nonlinear dispersion and we assume that the dispersive effects are negligible.

2 Entanglement in analogue gravity systems

Let us start with a brief overview of the description and quantification of entanglement. For an introductory review see, e.g., Ref. [29]. A quantum state is called separable with respect to the bipartition into subsystems A and B if the corresponding density operator can be written as


where , , and are pure states of the subsystems A or B respectively. Such states can contain classical correlations, i.e., correlations that depend on the local (in the sense of the subsystems A and B) choice of basis. Quantum states that cannot be decomposed in the form of above are called entangled. A formal way to quantify the entanglement of a given state is the entanglement of formation , defined as [30]


Here is the entropy of entanglement, given by the von Neumann entropy of the reduced state . The minimum in Eq. (2) is taken over all pure state decompositions that realize the state , i.e., such that . For mixed states of arbitrary dimension this measure is not computable but for some special cases, including those we discuss in this paper, the minimization in Eq. (2) can be carried out and can be computed analytically.

In the analogue gravity context that we want to consider here, the subsystems and will be two (out of an ensemble of possibly infinitely many) bosonic modes, e.g., associated to phonons in a BEC [21]. The corresponding annihilation and creation operators, and satisfy the commutation relations and . The operators and may be combined into the quadrature operators and , which, in turn, can be collected into the vector


For the particularly important class of Gaussian states, which includes, e.g., the vacuum and thermal states, all the information about the state is encoded in the first moments and the second moments


where denotes the expectation value of the operator in the state (see Ref. [22]). Furthermore, the covariance matrix contains all the relevant information about the entanglement between the modes.

Let us now consider a typical transformation occurring in analogue gravity systems, for example, the generation of phonons in a BEC that is undergoing a sudden change of the speed of sound. Such transformations are described by Bogoliubov transformations, i.e., linear transformations


between two sets of annihilation and creation operators, and , , that leave the canonical commutation relations invariant. The Bogoliubov transformation induces a unitary transformation on the Hilbert space of states. In phase space, on the other hand, these unitaries are realized as symplectic transformations that satisfy , where the symplectic form is defined by the relation . The transformation  can be expressed in terms of the coefficients and , which allows us to quantify the entanglement that is being generated between the modes for a wide variety of scenarios (see Ref. [26]).

At this point it is crucial to notice that, in the most favorable scenarios in analogue gravity (e.g., homogenous systems) the structure of the Bogoliubov transformations can be particularly simple. In these cases, the transformations mix pairs of degrees of freedom and the only non vanishing Bogoliubov coefficients are and . For example, in the case of homogeneous systems, the absence of boundaries that couple counter-propagating modes along with momentum conservation implies that only coefficients and are non-zero, where labels the momentum. This occurs even if the dispersion relation allows for more than two modes to correspond to the same frequency. In other words, the transformation cannot shift the momenta of individual excitations but it allows for the creation of (quasi-)particle pairs with equal but opposite momenta. Furthermore, in systems that are inherently inhomogeneous, such as analogue black hole setups, the coupling can be limited to pairs of frequencies due to the system’s stationarity. In order to illustrate our techniques we specialize to systems where the mixing occurs between modes of opposite momenta. This simple structure of the Bogoliubov coefficients permits us to consider the covariance matrix for any pairs of modes  and  independently of any other modes of the continuum. In the following we consider this simple structure to be an approximation for inhomogeneous systems with minor density fluctuations. In realistic setups, entanglement is generated between more than two degrees of freedom. For example, in the setups we address here, the effect of the inhomogeneity is to distribute the entanglement that is generated also across modes with different momenta [31], introducing additional noise in the reduced state of the modes and . Due to monogamy restraints [28] this will decrease the amount of entanglement produced between these modes, such that the results we obtain can be considered as upper bounds on the entanglement generation.

Dispersive effects on the other hand, e.g., in effective Friedmann-Robertson-Walker spacetimes, are easily taken into account in terms of modified Bogoliubov coefficients. These can be obtained by solving the corresponding equation of motion for the field modes, involving forth order derivatives in space for sub- and super-luminal dispersion relations. For the two chosen modes the symplectic transformation can be written as


where the blocks are given by


with . The unitarity of the transformation implies


and, in general for , we have


where the phase is left undetermined by the unitarity of the transformation. Let us now consider the effect of the Bogoliubov transformation on the entanglement between the modes and , including dispersive and finite temperature effects. Ideally, these modes are initially in the ground state. However, in every analogue gravity setup, the background temperature is non-zero (see, e.g., Ref. [9]). We are therefore applying the transformation to the covariance matrix of a thermal state at temperature . Since in our case the modes and have the same initial frequency their thermal covariance matrix is proportional to the identity and given by (see [32]),


such that the average particle number is distributed according to Bose-Einstein statistics. The transformed state has the form


where is composed of the matrices of Eq. (7) and the reduced state covariance matrices of the individual modes, and , are identical thermal states


with non-zero temperature even when the initial temperature is vanishing. We shall use this fact to define a characteristic temperature of the individual modes via the relation


where we have taken into account a possible change in frequency, , for fixed , due to nonlinear dispersion. This entanglement temperature , which corresponds to the Hawking temperature for a black hole evaporation process, can be attributed purely to the entanglement that is generated from the initial vacuum in a homogeneous system, in complete analogy to the mixedness that is quantified by the entropy of entanglement in Eq. (2).

If the first moments of the initial state vanish, the average particle number after the transformation can be computed from


where the are the elements of the covariance matrix [see Eq. (4)], and we obtain


which reduces to the usual Bose-Einstein statistics for , while it takes the familiar form [15] starting from the initial vacuum. Initially, i.e., for , the distribution (15) is thermal but after the transformation this is not necessarily the case since . From Eq. (12) we can further infer that is a symmetric state, i.e., , for which the entanglement of formation can be computed explicitly (see Ref. [22]). It is simply given as a function of the parameter , the smallest eigenvalue of , where represents partial transposition of mode . If the transformed state is entangled and is a monotonously decreasing function of , given by




For the state of Eq. (11) we find


While Eqs. (16)-(18) completely quantify the entanglement that is generated by the Bogoliubov transformation in the initial thermal state of temperature , it is Eq. (18) alone that is needed to determine whether or not any entanglement is created at all. In particular, we can identify the sudden death temperature , i.e., the initial temperature at which a given Bogoliubov transformation no longer generates any entanglement between the fixed modes and . It is determined by the condition . By combining the entanglement temperature and Eq. (18) we can express this condition as


which, in turn, implies


This simple relation provides us with a powerful tool to determine if a particular analogue gravity setup can in principle be expected to produce entanglement, for instance in a BEC simulating an expanding universe [16]. However, we can also formulate a simple procedure to identify transformations whose repetitions—should they be implementable—will resonantly enhance the entanglement produced between particular modes. In the following we will study the symplectic representation of such a repeatable transformation and identify the conditions for enhancing the ability of detecting entanglement.

3 Entanglement resonances

Any symplectic transformation of two modes can be decomposed into a passive transformation , with , representing rotations and beam splitting, and an active transformation , consisting of single- and two-mode squeezing, i.e., (see Ref. [33]). From the reduced states in Eq. (12) we can easily see that the transformation described by Eq. (6) contains no single-mode squeezing. Consequently, is a pure two-mode squeezing operation, , the paradigm Gaussian entangling operation, where is the squeezing parameter. For initial states of two modes that are proportional to the identity, as in our case, we can consider a resonance condition as discussed in Ref. [27], i.e.,


Since the typical Bogoliubov transformations in analogue gravity systems do not contain any single mode squeezing, i.e., , the condition of Eq. (21) has a very intuitive interpretation. It suggests that the state is invariant under the passive transformation , . Since two-mode squeezing operations form a one parameter subgroup of the symplectic transformations, , one can easily see that a transformation which satisfies the resonance condition (21) will accumulate entanglement when repeated. In particular, the entanglement of formation of is given by , see Eqs. (16) and (17). The increase of entanglement for particular modes is then a matter of tuning the transformation at hand to fulfill the resonance condition (21).

4 Sudden quench of a BEC

Let us now discuss a specific application of the general principles we have mentioned so far. We shall consider the Bogoliubov transformation that describes a single, sudden change of the speed of sound, a “quench”, of a BEC at some initial temperature . This can be achieved via a Feshbach resonance, i.e., a sudden change of the interaction strength, such that the density and phase of the BEC remain continuous, see Ref. [21] for details. As before we are going to make the approximation that the system is homogeneous throughout the process and that any effects of the inhomogeneity, in particular any caused by the quench, will enter as noise that reduces the entanglement. The non-adiabatic adjustment of the speed of sound, , causes the frequencies of the phononic modes to be altered, , while the momenta remain the same. The Bogoliubov coefficients thus have exactly the previously discussed structure for . More specifically we have [21]


where is the time of the transition which becomes relevant for consecutive quenches. The frequencies are given by the nonlinear dispersion relation


with , where is Planck’s constant, and is the mass of the atoms of the BEC. For a BEC only the positive sign —super-sonic dispersion—occurs in Eq. (23), but it is straightforward to consider the sub-sonic case for other systems. The nonlinear dispersion relation now enters the problem of entanglement creation due to the Bogoliubov transformation in two places. First, the nonlinear effects influence the -dependence of the initial temperature distribution, i.e., the average number of phonons is still a thermal distribution but it is strongly suppressed for higher mode numbers, as illustrated in Fig. 1. Additionally, the nonlinearity enters directly in the Bogoliubov coefficients (22), which decreases the number of quasi-particles that are produced by the quench. Together, the effects of the nonlinearity and the initial temperature compete to determine the entanglement generation in Eq. (18). It thus becomes evident that, given a specific transformation and dispersion relation, the entanglement generation is optimal for particular regions in -space. We have illustrated this behaviour in Fig. 2 for convenient, but not necessarily experimentally accessible, values of the parameters and .

Figure 1: Average particle number across the spectrum: The average particle number after the sudden quench is plotted as a function of the wave number  for a nonlinear dispersion relation. All curves are plotted for ms and ms. Values for the parameter  are shown in units of , while temperatures  are displayed in units of K. For a thermal state at temperature  with nonlinear dispersion the initial average particle number (dashed purple curve) increases due to the sudden quench (solid purple curve). The increase is strongly suppressed for higher mode numbers with respect to the case of linear dispersion (dotted-dashed purple curve).
Figure 2: Entanglement generation across the spectrum: The entanglement of formation that is generated by a sudden quench is plotted as a function of the wave number with a nonlinear dispersion relation and nonzero temperature (solid thick blue line). For a linear dispersion relation and zero temperature, , the generated entanglement (horizontal blue dashed line) and the particle production as measured by (horizontal red dotted line) are independent of . The nonlinearity of the dispersion relation, e.g., as shown here for (in units of ), is damping the generation of particles (solid red curve [bottom]) and of the entanglement (solid gray line) for higher energy modes, i.e., large . Nonzero temperature, on the other hand, suppresses the entanglement generation for small energies (dotted-dashed blue line). All curves are plotted for ms and ms. Temperatures are displayed in units of K.

Finally, we can attempt to construct a resonant transformation from the single quench to enhance the entanglement production. For this transformation to be repeatable it has to take . We can achieve a nontrivial transformation of this type by combining a first quench, with , at time with a second quench that takes at time . We then evaluate the resonance condition (21) for the total transformation for which we find the two necessary conditions


where , and


with . The equations (24) are trivially satisfied if for any . In these cases the combined transformation reduces to local rotations that do not change the initial state. However, for the remaining condition can still suffice. Then the resonance condition reduces to the transcendent equation


which can be solved numerically. However, for some special values an analytical solution lies close at hand. For instance, the transformation can be picked such that the ratio of and is rational, i.e., , . Inserting this into (26) the transcendent equation can be easily solved for . Since we are excluding the trivial transformations for which , , we obtain the resonant solutions of Eq. (24) by additionally requiring that and have odd separation, i.e., .

While such a series of sudden transformation might be only a rough estimation of the sinusoidal modification of the speed of sound applied in Ref. [9], our framework allows to estimate whether a given system is above or below the sudden death temperature by measuring the average particle number for a given frequency and the initial temperature. With this information, Eq. (15) can be used to provide and determine if entanglement is present even if the explicit Bogoliubov coefficients are not known. Since tests of entanglement in analogue systems can be rather involved, this check is vital to ensure the viability of such experiments. As mentioned above our results are in principle applicable to both super- and sub-luminal types of non-linear dispersion, for instance surface waves.


While our analysis assumes that the transformations of interest mix only couples of degrees of freedom (i.e., within homogeneous systems), the sudden death temperature we provide represents an upper bound on the allowed temperature for the inhomogeneous case as well. In particular in the case of resonant enhancement, e.g., by driving the transformation at a fixed frequency [9], the inhomogeneity leads to a smearing of the sharp peaks and the entanglement is distributed over several adjacent modes.

In conclusion, we have conducted an analysis of the entanglement generation in analogue gravity systems at finite initial temperature. We find that the entanglement generation is fully determined by the Bogoliubov transformations describing the simulated gravitational, or relativistic effects. For every pair of quasi-particle modes of the system, the problem can be phrased in terms of an effective entanglement temperature . If the initial temperature is above the benchmark of then no entanglement is produced between the particular modes corresponding to , regardless of the homogeneity of the system. The detection of entanglement in analogue gravity systems is a major ambition of future setups, for instance, to test Bell inequalities [34] in similar settings as in Ref. [9]. Our results provide clear-cut criteria for the feasibility of such endeavours that are applicable to a broad range of current analogue gravity experiments. In particular we want to direct attention to Ref. [35], which appeared shortly after submission of our work and analyses closely related questions.

We thank Denis Boiron, Luis J. Garay, Marcus Huber, Antony R. Lee, Raphael Lopes, Carlos Sabín, Chris Westbrook, Angela White, and Ivar Zapata for useful discussions and comments. S. W. would like to thank Piyush Jain for useful comments and discussions. N. F. and I. F. acknowledge support from EPSRC (CAF Grant No. EP/G00496X/2 to I. F.). D. E. B. acknowledges support from EPSRC (Grant No. EP/J005762/1) and the European Community’s Seventh Framework Programme under Grant Agreement No. 277110. N. F. and D. E. B. also want to thank SISSA for hospitality and support. S. W. was supported by Marie Curie Actions — Career Integration Grant (CIG); Project acronym: MULTIQG-2011, the FQXi Mini-grant “Physics without borders”, and the Royal Society University Research Fellowship “Quantum Gravity Laboratory”.



  • [1] Unruh W G 1981 Phys. Rev. Lett. 46 1351
  • [2] Barceló C, Liberati S, and Visser M 2005 Living Rev. Relativity 8 12
  • [3] Rousseaux G, Mathis C, Maissa P, Philbin T G, and Leonhardt U 2008 New J. Phys. 5 053015
  • [4] Weinfurtner S, Tedford E W, Penrice M C J, Unruh W G, and Lawrence G A 2011 Phys. Rev. Lett. 106 021302
  • [5] Jannes G, Piquet R, Maissa P, Mathis C, and Rousseaux G 2011 Phys. Rev. E 83 056312
  • [6] Weinfurtner S, Tedford E W, Penrice M C J, Unruh W G, and Lawrence G A 2013 Classical aspects of Hawking radiation verified in analogue gravity experiment Lect. Notes Phys. 870, 167 (arXiv:1302.0375 [gr-qc])
  • [7] Garay L J, Anglin J R, Cirac J I, and Zoller P 2000 Phys. Rev. Lett. 85 4643
  • [8] Lahav O, Itah A, Blumkin A, Gordon C, Rinott S, Zayats A, and Steinhauer J 2010 Phys. Rev. Lett. 105 240401
  • [9] Jaskula J C, Partridge G B, Bonneau M, Lopes R, Ruaudel J, Boiron D, and Westbrook C I 2012 Phys. Rev. Lett. 109 220401
  • [10] Belgiorno F, Cacciatori S L, Clerici M, Gorini V, Ortenzi G, Rizzi L, Rubino E, Sala V G, and Faccio D 2010 Phys. Rev. Lett. 105 203901
  • [11] Rubino E, McLenaghan J, Kehr S C, Belgiorno F, Townsend D, Rohr S, Kuklewicz S E, Leonhardt U, König F, and Faccio D 2012 Phys. Rev. Lett. 108 253901
  • [12] Recati A, Pavloff N, and Carusotto I 2009 Phys. Rev. A 80043603
  • [13] Kheruntsyan K V, Jaskula J C, Deuar P, Bonneau M, Partridge G B, Ruaudel J, Lopes R, Boiron D, and Westbrook C I 2012 Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 260401
  • [14] de Nova J R M, Sols F, and Zapata I 2012 Violation of Cauchy-Schwarz inequalities by spontaneous Hawking radiation in resonant boson structures arXiv:1211.1761 [cond-mat.quant-gas] .
  • [15] Birrell N D and Davies P C W 1982 Quantum Fields in Curved Space (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press)
  • [16] Ball J L, Fuentes-Schuller I, and Schuller F P 2006 Phys. Lett. A 359 550
  • [17] Barceló C, Liberati S, and Visser M 2003 Int. J. Mod. Phys. D 12 1641
  • [18] Calzetta E and Hu B L 2003 Phys. Rev. A 68 043625
  • [19] Fedichev P O and Fischer U R 2003 Phys. Rev. Lett. 91 240407
  • [20] Jain P, Weinfurtner S, Visser M, and Gardiner C W 2007 Phys. Rev. A 76 033616
  • [21] Weinfurtner S, White A, and Visser M 2007 Phys. Rev. D 76 124008
  • [22] Adesso G and Illuminati F 2005 Phys. Rev. A 72, 032334
  • [23] Alsing P M and Fuentes I 2012 Class. Quantum Grav. 29 224001
  • [24] Horstmann B, Reznik B, Fagnocchi S, and Cirac J I 2010 Phys. Rev. Lett. 104 250403
  • [25] Horstmann B, Schützhold R, Reznik B, Fagnocchi S, and Cirac J I 2011 New J. Phys. 13 045008
    Horstmann B, Schützhold R, Reznik B, Fagnocchi S, and Cirac J I 2011 New J. Phys. 13 069601 (erratum)
  • [26] Friis N and Fuentes I 2013 J. Mod. Opt. 60 22
  • [27] Bruschi D E, Dragan A, Lee A R, Fuentes I, and Louko J 2013 Phys. Rev. Lett. 111, 090504
  • [28] Hiroshima T, Adesso G, and Illuminati F 2007 Phys. Rev. Lett. 98 050503
  • [29] Bruß D 2002 J. Math. Phys. 43 4237
  • [30] Bennett C H, Di Vincenzo D P, Smolin J A, and Wootters W K 1996 Phys. Rev. A 54 3824
  • [31] Richartz M, Weinfurtner S, Penner A J, and Unruh W G 2009 Phys. Rev. D 80 124016
  • [32] Aspachs M, Calsamiglia J, Muñoz-Tapia R, and Bagan E 2009 Phys. Rev. A 79 033834
  • [33] Arvind A, Dutta B, Mukunda N, and Simon R 1995 Pramana 45 471
  • [34] Stobińska M, Jeong H, and Ralph T C 2007 Phys. Rev. A 75 052105
  • [35] Busch X and Parentani R 2013 Phys. Rev. D 88, 045023
Comments 0
Request Comment
You are adding the first comment!
How to quickly get a good reply:
  • Give credit where it’s due by listing out the positive aspects of a paper before getting into which changes should be made.
  • Be specific in your critique, and provide supporting evidence with appropriate references to substantiate general statements.
  • Your comment should inspire ideas to flow and help the author improves the paper.

The better we are at sharing our knowledge with each other, the faster we move forward.
The feedback must be of minimum 40 characters and the title a minimum of 5 characters
Add comment
Loading ...
This is a comment super asjknd jkasnjk adsnkj
The feedback must be of minumum 40 characters
The feedback must be of minumum 40 characters

You are asking your first question!
How to quickly get a good answer:
  • Keep your question short and to the point
  • Check for grammar or spelling errors.
  • Phrase it like a question
Test description