Nonrelativistic isothermal fluid in the presence of a chameleon scalar field: Static and collapsing configurations
We consider a gravitating spherically symmetric nonrelativistic configuration consisting of a massless chameleon scalar field nonminimally coupled to a perfect isothermal fluid. The object of this paper is to show the influence of the chameleon scalar field on the structure and evolution of an isothermal sphere. For this system we find static, singular and regular solutions depending on the form of the coupling function. A preliminary stability analysis indicates that both stable and unstable solutions exist. For unstable configurations, by choosing the special form of the coupling function, we consider the problem of the gravitational collapse by applying the similarity method.
pacs:04.40. – b
Over the course of the past decades, there has been substantial progress in cosmology and astrophysics supported by a growing quantity and quality of observational data requiring its theoretical description. Difficulties associated with such description are obvious: in considering various objects and processes in the Universe, one must deal with scales which differ by orders of magnitude. It forces the use of only approximate models and methods permitting considerable simplification in describing the structure and evolution of the Universe. In this respect, various scalar fields are ones of the most called-for objects which are being used in investigations of the Universe on all scales. They are relevant in describing the early inflationary Universe Linde (), the present accelerated Universe Copeland:2006wr (), and the processes on scales of order of galaxies and separate stars. In particular, this has come to refer to attempts of describing the dark matter in galaxies Bertone:2004pz () and to a consideration of compact configurations – boson stars supported by various scalar fields Schunck:2003kk ().
In modeling boson stars, it usually assumes that they consist of complex or real scalar fields in their own gravitational field. However, it is also possible to imagine a situation when besides a scalar field there can exist other forms of matter in a system. This can be fermion fields Schunck:2003kk (), an electromagnetic field Matos:1995my (), or ordinary matter. In the latter case, ordinary matter can interact with a scalar field either only via gravity or by use of nonminimal coupling as well. In the present paper we consider a case of the presence of such nonminimal coupling in a compact gravitating configuration. As applied to cosmology, the idea of nonminimal coupling between a scalar field and ordinary matter in the form of a perfect fluid was suggested in Refs. Khoury:2003aq (); Khoury:2003rn (); Brax:2004qh (), where the nonminimal coupling was used in describing the accelerated expansion of the present Universe. In this case the effective mass of the scalar field can change depending on the background environment. Because of it, such a scalar field was called a “chameleon scalar field.” The idea that the properties of a scalar field could be influenced by the environment/matter surrounding the scalar field was studied earlier, in particular, in the papers Ellis:1989as (); Mota:2003tc () where the interaction between matter and the scalar field was used to model a dependence of fundamental coupling constants on the local environment. Further development of this idea can be found in the papers Farajollahi:2010pk (); Cannata:2010qd (), where the authors describe different forms of cosmological evolution within the framework of the chameleon cosmology.
In progressing from cosmological to astrophysical scales, in a recent work arXiv:1106.1267 () we considered the model of chameleon stars consisting of a scalar field nonminimally coupled to ordinary matter in the form of a perfect polytropic fluid having the equation of state , where and are the density and the pressure of the fluid, and is some constant. For this system we found static, regular, asymptotically flat solutions for both relativistic and nonrelativistic cases for and . For these values of , it was shown that the presence of the nonminimal interaction leads to substantial changes both in the radial matter distribution of the star and in the star’s total mass.
In the present paper we continue studying compact astrophysical objects consisting of a scalar field nonminimally coupled to the polytropic fluid having . This case corresponds to the isothermal gas sphere whose temperature is assumed to be constant along the radius. In the nonrelativistic case, there are known static singular and regular solutions describing such equilibrium configurations in weak gravitational fields Chandra:1939 (). Depending on the parameters of the model, they can be gravitationally stable or unstable. In the latter case, instability leads to motion of matter that can be realized in the form of collapse. The gravitational collapse of an isothermal gas cloud is a well-studied problem. In different variants, this problem has been investigated frequently. In particular, there is a number of works devoted to the consideration of self-similar motions of an isothermal gas. We indicate some of them here.
In considering the collapse, there has been a great deal of attention paid to the specification of initial conditions. Larson Larson:1969mx () and Penston Penston:1969yy () chose zero initial velocity and uniform density of the fluid. Such conditions provide a homologous inflow that evolves to a central region. This solution assumes that there exists the flow at large radii, or equivalently as , which is directed inward at times the sound speed and the density in the envelope is proportional to . It gives the density be times the value appropriate to hydrostatic equilibrium. Shu Shu:1977uc () criticizes this solution and suggests new self-similar solutions, which did not have these problems. He assumes the initial density profile in the form . Such a sphere is quasistatic, so that the infall velocities are negligible at the moment of protostar formation. The resulting initial configuration is the singular isothermal sphere, which is an unstable hydrostatic equilibrium. Shu showed that in this case the cloud collapse begins at the center, and the infall spreads outward. He called this solution the expansion-wave solution. Hunter Hunter:1977 () has been continuing the work in that direction, and found a new class of similarity solutions which includes Shu’s expansion-wave solution as one limit. He considered different initially unstable spheres and studied whether their collapses are well described by similarity solutions.
In this paper we consider the model of a nonrelativistic configuration consisting of a perfect isothermal fluid in the presence of a massless chameleon scalar field. Our intention here is to clarify the influence of the chameleon scalar field on such a widely studied system as the gravitating isothermal fluid. The paper is organized as follows: In Sec. II we derive the equations for a static configuration with the arbitrary coupling function (see the Lagrangian (1) below). Using these equations, in next three subsections we consider various static configurations for different choices of . For such configurations, we find analytical and numerical solutions, and also address the issue of their stability. Using as initial conditions unstable static singular spheres from Sec. II.1, in Sec. III we consider similarity solutions describing the collapse of such configurations. Our conclusions are summarized in the final section, where we also suggest some possible lines of further investigation.
Ii Static configurations
As discussed in the Introduction we consider a gravitating system of a real scalar field coupled to a perfect fluid. In the general case of strong gravitational fields, the Lagrangian for this system is
Here is the real scalar field with the potential ; is the Lagrangian of the perfect isotropic fluid i.e. a fluid with only one radial pressure; is some function describing the nonminimal interaction between the fluid and the scalar field. An interaction similar to this was used to describe the evolution of dark energy within the framework of chameleon cosmologies Farajollahi:2010pk (); Cannata:2010qd (). The case corresponds to the absence of the nonminimal coupling. In this case the two sources are still coupled via gravity.
The above Lagrangian was used by us in arXiv:1106.1267 () to construct static relativistic and nonrelativistic configurations. In that case, the Lagrangian for the isentropic perfect fluid was chosen to have the form Stanuk1964 (); Stanuk (). Using this Lagrangian, the corresponding energy-momentum tensor is (details are given in Appendix in Ref. arXiv:1106.1267 ())
where and are the mass density and the pressure of the fluid, is the four-velocity. Henceforth we will use the Lagrangian (1) and the energy-momentum tensor (2) both when considering static configurations and in the study of the collapse. It will be shown in Appendix A that the process of the collapse permits self-similar motions only in the case of a massless chameleon scalar field, i.e. when . Bearing this in mind, we restrict ourselves to the consideration of configurations supported by the massless chameleon scalar field only.
Now we derive the equations describing static configurations. In generalized curvilinear coordinates the static spherically symmetric metric in the nonrelativistic limit can be written in the form Land1 ()
where is the metric on the unit 2-sphere. Using this metric, the -component of the covariant conservation law (which is the only nonzero component in the static case) is
In the nonrelativistic limit, in turn, the metric function can be rewritten in terms of the Newtonian gravitational potential in the following form Land1 ():
The corresponding equation for (the Poisson equation) can be found from the Einstein equations by using the transition to the nonrelativistic limit Land1 (). Then, using the above expression for and the energy-momentum tensor (2), and leaving terms of order only, we get
Next, introducing the mass
one can find from the Poisson equation (6):
This equation differs from the usual equation of hydrostatic equilibrium by the factor reflecting the presence in the system of the nonminimal coupling. Correspondingly, a full description of the configuration under consideration requires an additional equation for the scalar field . In general form, it can be obtained by varying the Lagrangian (1) with respect to as follows:
with , where is the speed of sound in the fluid. Using this equation of state and introducing the dimensionless variables
In the absence of the scalar field, i.e. when , only the first equation remains which has the following solutions Chandra:1939 (): (i) an analytical singular solution in the form which diverges at the center of the configuration as ; (ii) numerical regular solutions which satisfy the boundary conditions at . These solutions approach asymptotically, as , to the singular solution from (i). Both sets of solutions imply that only asymptotically as . That is, such solutions describe only infinite size configurations.
It will be shown below that the presence of the chameleon scalar field permits the existence not only singular and regular solutions similar to those described above, but also new finite size, regular solutions. If we are going to seek such solutions, it is obvious that a crucial role will be played by the form of the coupling function . In the next three subsections we consider several types of solutions. In doing so, we will track the behavior of the energy density from (2). In the nonrelativistic approximation using the above dimensionless variables (10), the total mass density has the form
The second term on the right-hand side of this expression is proportional to the square of the ratio of the speeds of sound and light, . It is obvious that this term is small compared with the first term everywhere just except perhaps the vicinity of the points where both terms tend to zero simultaneously.
Below, we demonstrate a few examples of solutions with different choices of the coupling function . In making the choice of , two approaches are possible: (i) One assumes to be an arbitrary function of the scalar field whose form is chosen to satisfy the requirement of obtaining the solutions needed. As an example, in Sec. II.1 one of the simplest choice of in the form of the exponential function, , is presented. In this case, it is possible to get analytical singular and numerical regular solutions. (ii) One can suggest to be a function of the radial coordinate, . As an example, we choose below power functions for giving either infinite size singular solutions (see Sec. II.2) or finite size, regular solutions (see Sec. II.3). The solutions for the scalar field obtained in this case define the parametric dependence .
ii.1 Singular and regular solutions with
The parameter can be absorbed by introducing the rescaling that allows to put in further calculations. But we will bear in mind that can be always restored in final expressions by using the above rescaling. The above choice of allows to find the following analytical solutions
where are integration constants. These solutions describe a configuration which is singular at the origin of coordinates, where, as , the mass density from (13) diverges as , and regular asymptotically, as , where .
The coupling function from (14) permits also the existence of regular solutions which can be found numerically. In this case we can choose the parameter from (10) to be the central density of the fluid, . With this normalization the system (11)-(12) takes the form
We will look for a solution of this system which satisfy the following boundary conditions at :
which, after the rescalings , takes the form
This equation is an analogue of the Lane-Emden equation for the isothermal fluid without a scalar field Chandra:1939 (). Thus, Eq. (19) [or equivalently Eqs. (16) and (17)] together with the boundary conditions (18) describes the regular isothermal gas sphere in the presence of the chameleon scalar field. Without the scalar field, such configuration has the central density . In the presence of the scalar field, it follows from Eq. (13) that the central density of the configuration under consideration is now defined by the value of the function at as well. In the case when the coupling function has the form (14), we have from (13): . It implies that the configuration under consideration will have a greater or smaller concentration of matter at the center depending on the sign of , and correspondingly different distributions of the mass density along the radius. The size of such configuration, as in the case without the scalar field, will also be infinite. The corresponding asymptotic solutions of the system (16)-(17) are:
As in the case of an isothermal fluid without a scalar field, here we will consider a configuration embedded in an external medium of pressure . For such static configurations without a scalar field, in the works of Ebert Ebert:1955 () and Bonnor Bonnor:1956 (), the issue of their stability was investigated. Following these works and taking into account the equation of state from (9), we represent the central density of the fluid of the configuration under consideration as follows (see also Ref. Hunter:1977 ()):
Then, taking into account the total pressure , which includes both the pressure of the fluid and the contribution from the scalar field, and follows from (2), , in terms of the dimensionless variables (10), we have
Substituting this expression in (20) and taking into account that at the outer boundary of the configuration, where , the total pressure is equal to the external pressure, i.e. , we finally have
Then one can find that the total mass of the configuration is
The maximum possible , given , or the maximum possible , given , follows from the fact that the function attains a maximum value at some . In the case when is chosen in the form (14), the maximum value of is . One can see that this value depends on the initial value of the field , and differs from the case without a scalar field when Bonnor:1956 (); Hunter:1977 (). The maximum value of the radial coordinate, , corresponds to the mass of the cloud having the critical value
This value is factor of smaller than the critical Bonnor-Ebert sphere. Notice that the critical mass does not depend on the initial value of the scalar field and is determined just by the external pressure , as in the case of the critical Bonnor-Ebert sphere. The relation between the central density and the total density at the outer boundary of the configuration, , corresponding to this critical mass, can be written as . Then for clouds with masses less than two types of configurations are possible: a larger stable one with a range of density less than , and a smaller unstable one with a range of density greater than . For both cases . Configurations with are always unstable, and with are marginally stable.
In the limit of configurations with infinite central density described by the singular solutions (15), the unstable equilibria approach the singular sphere which has the following density and mass distributions:
This singular solution, truncated at a boundary pressure , has a total radius and a total mass given by
which are, respectively, factors of and differ from the critical Bonnor-Ebert sphere. Here we restored the parameter from (14) whose value allows varying the radius of the configuration for the given mass. The plots of total pressure distributions of several configurations described above are shown in Fig. 1.
ii.2 Singular solutions with
In this and the next subsections, we seek solutions of the system (11)-(12) starting not from a straightforward choice of the specific form of the coupling function , but by choosing an appropriate form of the product , defining the total density (13). In paper arXiv:1106.1267 (), we already found the analytical solutions for a massless scalar field in a particular nonrelativistic case of an incompressible fluid. Below we will obtain analytical solutions for the case of the isothermal fluid being considered here.
Choose first the above product in the form
where are arbitrary positive constants. This choice gives the positive-definite total mass density from (13) which is singular at the origin of coordinates. The choice (25) allows to find the general solution of Eq. (11) in the form
In the case when , we have
Here are integration constants. The scalar field equation (12), in turn, can also be integrated analytically giving the expression for .
Of special interest is the case of . In this case one can get a solution similar to the singular solution without a scalar field. Indeed, choosing the integration constants as and , we obtain the following solutions:
In the case when we return to the singular solution without a scalar field from (i) [see after Eq. (12)]. The values of the constant imply that the scalar field changes along the radius that provides changes in the distribution of the mass density from (13).
It is obvious from two first expressions that the parametric dependence gives the expression coinciding with the coupling function from (14). In Sec. III below, a self-similar motion of matter with such choice of will be considered.
ii.3 Regular solutions with
Bearing in mind that we seek finite size, regular solutions, let us try to choose such an expression for that provides the required solutions. In doing so, we will look for such solutions of Eqs. (11) and (12) which have a value of the total mass density from (13) at the center of the configuration, at , equal to the central density of the fluid, , i.e. , and at the outer boundary of a cloud, at , we require that . One of the simplest variants is to take the following power-law dependence
Next, from expression (27), let us determine the point in which : . Requiring that in this point the derivative also be equal to zero, we substitute this value of in Eq. (29) and find the corresponding value of :
Using this expression, we get
This point can be interpreted as the outer boundary of the configuration, where the total density from Eq. (13) is equal to zero. In this case the spheres described by Eqs. (11) and (12) are a one-parameter family, with the size of depending only on one parameter . As , the value , and as , we have . Thus, by changing the value of the parameter , we can change the size of the configuration in a wide range at the given and .
Note that the scalar field energy density which is proportional to from (29), can take both positive and negative values along the radius depending on the value of the parameter . This is related to the structure of the scalar field equation (8) which, at positive pressure and a specific choice of , can effectively correspond to a scalar field equation for a ghost scalar field. Since the form of is defined parametrically through the solution for the scalar field , and depends on the value of the parameter , then a situation may occur where the scalar field equation (8) demonstrates the ghostlike behavior with . However, since in the nonrelativistic limit the main contributions to the energy density (13) come from the first term on the right-hand side, which is always positive, then the total energy density remains positive as well.
Returning to the dimensional variables from (10), the radius of the configuration under consideration is given by
In Sec. III, where we will consider the process of the collapse of the singular sphere from Sec. II.1, the speed of sound is chosen to be . If we use the same value in the estimation of the size of the regular configuration which is considered here, we have
where is the central density of the configuration in .
It is seen from the obtained results that the isothermal fluid in the presence of the nonminimally coupled scalar field with the coupling function defined through Eq. (27) permits the existence of finite size, regular solutions. This situation differs from the classical problem without a scalar field when infinite size solutions are the only possible ones Chandra:1939 ().
Because of the nonrelativistic character of the problem, we neglect the influence of the scalar field. Next, using expression (13), we define the average density as
For the density concentration, we have
By combining two last expressions, we find
Taking into account the expression for from (10), we obtain
One can see from this equation that drops with increasing , which is the abnormal behavior for a stable star in equilibrium. Thus, regardless of the value of the parameter , the choice of the coupling function in the form (27) gives only unstable configurations.
Iii Self-similar collapse of the singular sphere
In this section we consider the spherical gravitational collapse of the singular configuration investigated in Sec. II.1. Such problems have been considered frequently for polytropic spheres both in relativistic and nonrelativistic cases. In doing so, two main approaches are being used: (i) One solves the system of hydrodynamic partial differential equations; (ii) A self-similar motion of polytropic matter is considered.
Here we study self-similar motions of the matter of the singular configuration considered in Sec. II.1. In the absence of the chameleon scalar field, such problem for an isothermal sphere have been considered by many authors (see the Introduction). We obtain below the similarity solutions describing the collapse of the singular sphere in the presence of the chameleon scalar field. These solutions will be compared to the known solutions found in Shu’s paper Shu:1977uc ().
In Appendix A we derived the following set of nonrelativistic hydrodynamic equations which take into account the influence of a chameleon scalar field:
Here is the total mass inside radius at time , the radial velocity, the pressure, and the density. If the coupling function is chosen in the form , then the corresponding system of self-similar Eqs. (A.21)-(A.23) from Appendix A can be written as follows:
The similarity variables involved were obtained from expressions (A.14) in the case when , . This gives
where defines the instant when the mass of the core, , is zero. The instant corresponds to the instant of core formation for the collapse problem. In the case of collapse the variables are positive while is negative.
In terms of the above similarity variables we have the following expression for the mass function from (A.15):
In dimensional units, these solutions correspond to the time-independent singular solution (23) with . As in the case of the problem without a scalar field considered by Shu in Shu:1977uc (), in our case this singular solution is the only hydrostatic solution allowing self-similarity. Following Shu:1977uc (), we will use this solution as the “initial state” when the process of collapse starts.
Below, we will seek numerical solutions of the system (35)-(37). However, this numerical study needs some caution because the solution can pass through critical points, as well as in the case of the absence of a scalar field Shu:1977uc (). The existence of the critical points assumes that the denominator of Eqs. (35) and (36) vanishes:
Solutions of these equations make the numerators of Eqs. (35) and (36) equal to zero, thereby providing the regularity of the solutions at the critical points. The particular solutions of the system (41) are
To find a solution of Eqs. (35)-(37), it is necessary to specify the corresponding boundary conditions. When considering a problem of collapse, it is reasonable to assume that the fluid velocity is negligible at the “initial instant,” i.e. that as . Then one can show that solutions of the system (35)-(37) which have this property have the following asymptotic behavior:
where is a value of the velocity as . The collapse begins from the initial inhomogeneous distribution of the matter in the form
which corresponds to the singular static sphere from (23). This sphere being initially in unstable hydrostatic equilibrium, can spontaneously generate inflow at every radii when . Several solutions of the system (35)-(37) with different initial values of the velocity are presented in Fig. 2.
Shu starts his similarity solutions with the initial singular state of the type (43) using as initial conditions the asymptotic expressions for the velocity and for the initial density distribution depending on the value of the arbitrary parameter . In the limiting case , Shu returns to the singular sphere which is the solution of static equations. As a result, he obtains the limiting self-similar solutions, called the “expansion-wave collapse solutions.” In our case we also have similar solution shown in Fig. 2 by the thick solid line. We will describe this solution in detail in Sec. III.1.
Here are constants whose value is determined from the solution, and depends on , and is the value of the mass at the center. When , i.e. in the absence of the scalar field, we return to the known solutions from Ref. Shu:1977uc ():
Following Shu:1977uc (), let us calculate the ratio of the gravitational acceleration to the pressure gradient acceleration for the fluid:
which tends to the constant at finite as . This situation differs from Shu’s result, where the above relation diverges that is quite expected behavior for the collapse problem. The obtained result is obviously related to the presence in the system of the scalar field whose behavior becomes dominant in the limit . In this case one can suppose that it is needed to perform a more correct study of the problem assuming the presence of the scalar field in the expression for the energy density from (A.2) which is not taken into account in the present model because of its nonrelativistic character.
The constant , which represents the reduced mass of the core, is expressed through the above constants which, in turn, are defined implicitly by the constant from (42), but not by which, as it is obvious from the structure of Eqs. (35)-(37), does not influence the solutions. The values of , and correspondingly can be found by numerical integration with the starting conditions (42) determined at large . Numerical calculations show the following linear dependence which is approximately valid at : .
iii.1 Expansion-wave collapse solution
Following Shu Shu:1977uc (), in this section we consider similarity solutions starting from the initial static singular distribution of matter in the form (43). Then, letting the initial velocity from (42) equal to zero, the solutions obtained below can be interpreted as follows: we start from the initially unstable singular sphere (43) with zero initial velocity at the instant . The collapse begins at the central region as a small perturbation of density spreading in the external envelope at the speed of sound up to the outer boundary of the configuration, , defined by Eq. (24). Behind the front of this expansion wave, the motion of the matter is described by Eqs. (35)-(37) whose solutions are sought in the range . The value corresponds to the outer boundary of the configuration where . The time required for initiation of the collapse over the whole configuration is . During the collapse, in the neighborhood of the center of the configuration, the accumulation of mass from the initial value to takes place. The latter value represents a total reduced mass contained inside and equal to the original equilibrium value from (40). The physical mass contained in the expansion wave and in the core increases linearly with time according to Eq. (38). As well as in Shu’s work, the mass contained in the core at any instant always comprises about of the total mass contained within .
Let us now illustrate the process of collapse described above by using numerical calculations with a specific choice of the value of the speed of sound, Shu:1977uc (). In Ref. Shu:1977uc () the external pressure was chosen to be (here is the Boltzmann constant) which defines the size and the total mass of the configuration as and , respectively. It allowed Shu to identify such an object as a Bok globule embedded in an H II region, and to use it as an initial state from which the process of collapse started. If we want to get the same value of the mass as in Shu:1977uc (), then by comparing our expressions for the size of the configuration and its mass, given by Eq. (24), with the corresponding expressions from Shu:1977uc (), given by Eq. (3), it can be seen that in our case one needs to take the pressure 8 times smaller than Shu’s value. It will lead, in turn, to the growth of radius which is now times larger than the value from Shu:1977uc ().
The collapse begins in the neighborhood of the center of the configuration at the instant . The expansion wave moving through the configuration with the speed of sound , reaches the outer boundary at (that is about 1000 times the distance of Neptune from the Sun) at the instant . The profiles of distributions of the density and the velocity in the neighborhood of the outer boundary of the configuration, , are shown in Fig. 3 at different instants of time. Notice here that in performing numerical calculations, it is convenient to introduce new exponential function .
By comparing the results presented in Figs. 2 and 3 with Shu’s calculations shown in his Figs. 2 and 3, it can be seen that the presence of the chameleon scalar field with the coupling in the form (14) does not result in qualitative changes of the picture of the collapse. Changes touch upon just some quantitative characteristics: starting from the task of obtaining the mass of the collapsed object of order a stellar mass, we have to take the external pressure 8 times smaller, and the size of the initial configuration larger, compared to Shu’s problem. Near the center, the process of collapse is analogous to the problem from Ref. Shu:1977uc () when the total mass density and the velocity [see expressions (44)] that provides the constant in time central accretion rate.
Iv Summary and conclusions
In this paper, we have studied nonrelativistic gravitating configurations consisting of an isothermal fluid nonminimally coupled to a chameleon scalar field , and described by the Lagrangian (1). The aim of this work was to clarify how the scalar field affects the distribution and motion of matter in such configurations. The crucial role here is played by the form of the coupling function . In considering these problems we restrict ourselves to the particular case of a massless chameleon scalar field. Besides allowing us to find some analytical solutions for static configurations, it allows us to consider the problem of the gravitational collapse by applying the similarity method.
Namely, in Sec. II.1 the static singular and regular solutions were found for the case of . It was shown that there exist analytical singular solutions (15) similar to known solutions for an isothermal sphere without a scalar field Chandra:1939 (). The study of the regular solutions indicates that the properties of the configuration under consideration depend substantially on the central value of the scalar field : (i) Depending on the sign of , the configurations will have a larger or smaller concentration of matter at the center; (ii) For a configuration embedded in an external medium of pressure , the hydrostatic equilibrium has the critical value of mass (22) which is factor of smaller than the critical Bonnor-Ebert sphere Ebert:1955 (); Bonnor:1956 (); (iii) There is a critical size of the configuration, , corresponding to the above critical mass, whose value is determined by the value of . In this case configurations with sizes less than may be either stable or unstable depending on the central density, and configurations with are always unstable.
Next, in Secs. II.2 and II.3 the energy density of the system is chosen to be a power function of the radial coordinate in the form (25) and (27). For these cases, singular and regular solutions were found. The regular solutions permit the existence of finite configurations whose size is determined just by one free parameter – the exponent in expression (27). This situation differs from that in problems without a chameleon scalar field when only solutions describing infinite size configurations do exist. A simple stability analysis indicates that, for the choice of in the form (27), the regular, finite size solutions are unstable.
The above studies indicate that systems under consideration can be stable or unstable. In the latter case, a question arises as to the possible motion of matter in its own gravitational field. As an example of such motion, in Sec. III the self-similar collapse of the singular sphere with function chosen in the exponential form (14) was considered. Without a scalar field, the similar problem was investigated by Shu in Shu:1977uc (). That is why we basically compared our calculations with Shu’s results. It was shown that the qualitative behavior of the solutions remains the same as in the case without the scalar field: the process of collapse starts from the initially singular sphere (23) truncated at a boundary pressure and having the radius and the total mass given by expressions (24). The collapse is initiated by an initial density perturbation near the center that propagates outward to the edge of the configuration in the form of the expansion wave with the speed of sound . The presence of the scalar field gives some quantitative differences which are obviously connected with the fact that the initial density distribution (43) differs from Shu’s distribution by the factor . As a result, starting from the task of obtaining the mass of the collapsed object of order a stellar mass, it is necessary to set the external pressure 8 times smaller, and the size of the initial configuration larger, compared to Shu’s problem.
As in Shu’s problem, in this paper we consider the collapse of the singular isothermal sphere bounded by some artificial external pressure. Without the scalar field, inclusion of such external pressure is the only possibility of obtaining finite size configurations with finite masses (both for singular and regular cases). As shown in Sec. II.3, in the presence of the chameleon scalar field interacting with the fluid in the form (27), it becomes possible to find regular solutions describing more realistic finite size configurations without the external pressure. Such configurations being initially unstable, in principle, might be used as initial states when considering the collapse of isothermal clouds in the presence of the scalar field.
Another possibility of obtaining finite size solutions can come from a consideration of Eqs. (11) and (12) as a system which is equivalent to two interacting scalar fields and . In this case it is possible to introduce the effective Lagrangian of the system in the following form:
where the effective potential . By varying this Lagrangian with respect to and , one can obtain Eqs. (11) and (12). Then the problem of searching the finite size solutions to the field equations amounts to finding such a form of the coupling function that provides the required solutions, if any.
The author is grateful to the Research Group Linkage Programme of the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation for the support of this research.
Appendix A Derivation of the self-similar equations
In this appendix we derive equations describing self-similar motion of a perfect isothermal fluid in the presence of a chameleon scalar field. To do this, we start with the energy-momentum tensor (2). Let us choose the metric in the Newtonian approximation in the form
where is the metric on the unit 2-sphere, and is the Newtonian gravitational potential. Using this metric and taking into account the expressions for the components of the four-velocity
where is the ordinary three-dimensional velocity, one can obtain the following components of the energy-momentum tensor (2) in the nonrelativistic limit:
Next, using the law of conservation
we get two equations: The component corresponding to the hydrodynamic equation of continuity
The component (Euler’s equation):
where the prime and the dot denote differentiation with respect to and , respectively. In the case when and the scalar field is absent, Eq. (A.4) reduces to the usual equation of continuity, and Eq. (A.5) to Euler’s equation for the spherically symmetric case.
The equation for the scalar field coming from the Lagrangian (1) is
Using this field equation with the Lagrangian for the perfect fluid , and the metric (A.1), we get the following scalar field equation
In obtaining this equation, we neglect the term , in the spirit of the nonrelativistic character of the problem. In this approximation, Eq. (A.6) is static, i.e. one assumes that perturbations of the scalar field propagate with infinite velocity. Substituting Eq. (A.6) in (A.5), we get the usual Euler’s equation
Next, introducing the mass contained within a sphere of radius
one can rewrite the equation of continuity (A.4) in the following form:
Substituting expression (A.8) in the Poisson equation
we obtain the usual equation for the Newtonian potential
Substituting this in (A.7), we get the final form of the set of equations describing the dynamics of the system under consideration:
Here is the total mass inside radius at time . These equations are invariant under the time reversal operation: that allows us considering only the range of . Notice here that in the absence of the nonminimal interaction, i.e. when the coupling function , the system becomes uncoupled: the evolution of the fluid does not affect the distribution of the scalar field. This situation differs from the case of the presence of strong gravitational fields considered in Ref. arXiv:1106.1267 () when even at equations describing static configurations are not independent, but are coupled via gravity.
In the case of the polytropic equation of state with polytropic exponent
where is some dimensional constant, and – a dimensionless constant. Rewriting Eqs. (A.9) and (A.10) in terms of the above dimensionless similarity variables, we get an algebraic expression for in terms of and
Next, Eq. (A.11) gives