Noncommutative geometry inspired rotating black string
Noncommutativity is an idea dating back to the early times of Quantum Mechanics and that string theory induced noncommutative (NC) geometry which provides an effective framework to study short distance spacetime dynamics. Also, string theory, a candidate for a consistent quantum theory of gravity, admits a variety of classical black hole solutions including black strings. In this paper, we study a NC geometry inspired rotating black string to cylindrical spacetime with a source given by a Gaussian distribution of mass. The resulting metric is a regular, i.e. curvature-singularity free, rotating black string, that in large limit interpolates Lemos lemos96 () black string. Thermodynamical properties of the black strings are also investigated and exact expressions for the temperature, the entropy and the heat capacity are obtained. Owing to the NC correction in the solution, the thermodynamic quantities have been also modified and that the NC geometry inspired black string is always thermodynamically stable.
In general relativity, finding an exact solution to the Einstein field equations has been a subject of great interest, specially, the black hole solutions take an important place because thermodynamics, gravitational theory and quantum theory are connected via quantum black hole physics. The importance of spherical black holes has come from its role as the final state of complete gravitational collapse of a star, and hence it is useful to investigate if black holes with different topology may also emerge from gravitational collapse of some matter distribution. Many of these studies in the gravitational collapse were motivated by Thorne in hoop conjecture kst () that after collapse will yield a black hole only if a mass is compressed into a region with circumference in all directions. If the hoop conjecture is true, naked singularities may form if collapse can yield in some direction. Thus, cylindrical matter will not form a black hole (or a black string) jps (). However, the hoop conjecture was imposed on spacetimes with a zero cosmological term, but when a negative cosmological constant is introduced, the spacetime will become asymptotically anti-de Sitter. Indeed, Lemos jps () has shown that cylindrical black holes are formed rather than naked singularity from gravitational collapse of a cylindrical matter distribution in an anti-de Sitter spacetime, violating in this way the hoop conjecture. In addition, string theory also gave a great variety of classical black hole solutions including black strings 1 (); 2 (); 3 (); 4 (); 5 (); 5.1 (); 6 (); 7 (); 8 (); 9 (); 10 (); 11 (); 13 (); 14 (); 15 (). Horowitz and Strominger 14 () showed that there does not exist static, cylindrically symmetric black hole (or a black string) solution with asymptotically flat spacetime in the transverse directions. However, Lemos lemos95 (); lemos951 () constructed the cylindrical black hole in four dimensions which is asymptotically anti-de Sitter not only in the transverse direction but also in the string direction, and it has a corresponding three dimensional black hole solution lemos95 (). The Lemos black string can be obtained starting from the Einstein-Hilbert action of the (3+1) dimensional gravity with a negative cosmological constant lemos95 ()
where is the action of matter field, is the curvature scalar, is the determinant of the metric, is the cosmological constant and is the gravitation constant. The equation of motion can be obtained by varying action (1) with respect to the gravitational field which yields
with and is ADM mass of black string. The constant has the dimension of inverse of length which is related to cosmological constant by . The metric (3) has three Killing vectors: which corresponds to the translational symmetry along the axis, which has closed periodic trajectories around the axis and corresponding to the invariance under time translations. The rotating counterpart of the metric (3) can be obtained by the following transformations lemos96 ()
and the metric of the rotating black string reads lemos96 ():
where and are constants. The metric (5) is to be asymptotically anti-de Sitter, if we impose the condition . It is useful to define the parameter and angular velocity to study the solution and its causal structure, which are related to the angular momentum and angular velocity via
The metric (5) after rearrangements of various terms can be put in the following form
The metric (7) has many similarities with the metric on the equatorial plane for axis-symmetric rotating Kerr metric. The differences and similarities between these two solutions are given in lemos96 (); Cai96 (), and we shall not discuss them here.
Ii Noncommutative Geometry Inspired Solution
By now, it is clear that string theory influenced the NC geometry snyder (); snyder1 (), that provides an effective way to analyze the short distant spacetime dynamics. The NC spacetime was originally introduced by Snyder snyder (); snyder1 () to study the divergences in relativistic quantum field theory. On the other hand, the NC geometry appears naturally from the study of open string theories. In particular, the NC black holes are involved in the study of string theory and M-theory Haro (); Haro1 (). The noncommutativity eliminates the point-like structure in the form of smeared objects Myung:2008kp (). The NC geometry inspired Schwarzschild black hole is obtained by Nicolini et. al nicoli06 (), which they also extended to the Reisnner-Nordstrom balck holenicoli07 (), generalized to Schwarzschild-Tangherilini spacetime by Rizzo Rizzo:2006zb (), to charged higher dimensions black holes nicoli09 (), and then to the BTZ black holes Kim:2007nx () (see also Ref. Nicolini:2006 (), for a review of NC geometry inspired black holes). It turns out that the NC geometry inspired Schwarzschild black hole smoothly interpolates between a de-Sitter core at short distance and the ordinary Schwarzschild black hole at large nicoli06 (). Our aim is to find an NC geometry inspired black string i.e. to find the NC counterpart of the solutions (3) and (7) and discuss their thermodynamical properties. The NC theories are built on spaces whose coordinate do not commute and therefore one cannot localize their points with an arbitrary precision. In the NC geometry inspired black hole spacetime, the point-like object is replaced by the smeared object, whose mass density is described by a Gaussian distribution of some minimal width. The modified black hole due to noncommutativity of spacetime does not allow the black hole to decay beyond a minimal mass. Then, the evaporation processes terminate when the black hole reaches a Planck scale remnant at zero temperature, which does not diverse at all. In NC spacetime, a description of the point mass is not possible due to the fuzziness of spacetime. The fuzziness can be introduced by the following relation:
where is an antisymmetric matrix, which determines the fundamental cell discretization of spacetime much in the same way as the discretizes the phase space. Clearly, at a distance , the classical concept of smooth spacetime is no longer valid, where is close to the Planck length. The expression of the mass density which is smeared into a minimal width Gaussian profile for cylindrically symmetric spacetime is given as Myung:2008kp ()
which is a matter source, and total mass is diffused in the region of size . In order to completely define the energy â momentum tensor, we rely on the covariant conservation condition , which for the cylindrically symmetric metric (3) reads
Thus, the energy momentum tensor for the anisotropic perfect fluid is given as and is completely known with , the energy density of the anisotropic perfect fluid, whereas, and or respectively are the radial and the tangential pressure. On solving the Einstein’s equations (2) for the energy-momentum tensor (12), one obtains
is the lower incomplete gamma function. The surface area per unit height on -axis is and hence the mass parameter is related to mass density (10) by
where is the minimal width of the Gaussian profile given in (10). The solution (13) can be also obtained by replacing by in Eq. (3) 51 (); 50 (). In the limit , Eq. (13) reduces to the Lemos lemos96 () black string solution . Thus, we see that instead of being concentrated at a point, the sourse is spreading throughout a region of linear size because of the noncommutativity. We note that the following properties of matter density: near the origin , , deviation from the origin , and asymptotically we get . The horizon of the NC geometry inspired black string is located at
However, Eq. (16) can not be solved analytically, and hence we plot them in Fig. 1 with different values of mass parameter. The horizon radius increases with an increase in the mass parameter. The large distance limit gives the black string event horizon located at . Thus the metric (13) describes a NC geometry inspired black string and it is useful to see how the noncommutativity affects the thermodynamical properties.
In the large radius , the NC effect can be neglected. But at the short distance , one expects important changes. It turns out that NC makes the space-time regular which can be seen by the behavior of curvature scalar (), Ricci square () and Kretschmann invariant () of the NC geometry inspired black string (13). These invariants are calculated at the origin, which read
We see from the above expressions of invariants (17) that they are finite and regular everywhere including at the origin for the non-zero values of . These invariants are also regular even if we take and hence NC black string are regular solution.
In the previous section, we showed that NC inspired black string (13) admits two horizons. Next, we calculate exact thermodynamic quantities in terms of horizon radius () associated with the NC geometry inspired black string (13). From the equation , the mass of the NC geometry inspired black string can be expressed as
In the large radius limit, , the NC effect vanishes and we get the mass of the black string, lemos95 (); lemos951 (); lemos96 (). However, when the noncommutativity becomes important nicoli07 (); nicoli09 () as shown in Fig. 2. In NC case the mass does not vanish, rather it gives the finite value , even when the horizon radius shrinks to zero (cf. Fig. 2 ). This minimal mass of NC black string corresponds to the Planck scale remnant beyond which no further decay of NC black string is possible. But in the standared black string solution (3), mass term vanishes as horizon radius approaches to zero. The mass of two solutions (3) and (7) coincides at (cf. Fig. 2).
The Hawking temperature associated with the black string is given by , where is the surface gravity and it is defined as
Eq. (20) gives the NC geometry inspired black string temperature and in large radius limit, , one recovers the temperature of the commutative black string :
The temperature is a monotonically increasing function of horizon radius. Therefore at the initial stage of black hole evaporation, the temperature decreases as the horizon radius. In NC case the temperature does not increase linearly as it does in the case of black string. The spacings between the two temperatures given by (20) and (21) decreases as we go from smaller to larger horizon radii and becomes maximum at corresponding to temperature (see in Fig. 3). As we can see clearly, the graph of two temperatures deviates significantly upto few order of standard deviation in the noncommutative limit of spacetime geometry and they coincide at . The zero temperature corresponds to the termination of evaporation process of the black string.
thus on integrating the first law, we have
The entropy of the NC geometry inspired black string does not satisfy the area law. However, in the large radius limit the entropy obeys the Bekenstein area law, , where is the area of the black string Cai96 ().
To analyze the thermodynamical stability of NC geometry inspired black string (13), we evaluate the heat capacity. The heat capacity of the black string is defined as
In the limit when , one finds that
which is the specific heat of commutative black string (3). For large two black string solutions (3) and (13) have the nearly same heat capacity as shown in Fig. 4. The thermodynamical stability of the system is related to the sign of the heat capacity. If it is positive (), then the black string is thermodynamically stable, when it is negative (), the black string is said to be thermodynamically unstable. For the standard black string case, we have parabolic variation of the horizon radius with the heat capacity. But when noncommutativity encounters, scenario becomes very important for the horizon radius up to few order of standard deviation. Thus, inclusion of the NC factor into the black string solution has direct impact on heat capacity at short distances. In the standard black string solution heat capacity vanishes as horizon radius shrinks to zero. But in case of NC black string even if the horizon radius approaches to zero, the heat capacity never meets the origin, rather it gives a finite value. As the heat capacity is always positive, both the NC geometry inspired black string and standard black string are always thermodynamically stable (cf. Fig. 4) and no further phase transition is possible.
Iv Rotating Black String Solution
The metric of rotating counterpart of NC geometry inspired black string (13) reads:
where is the rotation parameter. The event horizon of NC geometry inspired rotating black string is obtained by , which in turn yields . From the expression (29) we see that the rotation parameter should have the range lemos96 () for the horizon radius to have the real values. Thus, the horizon of (28) is found to be
The Eq. (30) can’t be solved analytically and hence it is shown in Fig. 5 for different values of rotation parameter with the fixed value of in terms of units. The horizon radius increases with the decrease in rotation parameter . In the large distance limit , Eq. (30) gives the rotating black string horizon and the horizon is located at corresponding to non-rotating case. Thus, the metric (28) together with Eq. (29) describes the NC geometry inspired rotating black string and is useful to see how the noncommutativity affects the thermodynamical properties including stability. Here, we calculate thermodynamical quantities associated with the NC geometry inspired rotating black string. From Eq. (29) the mass of the NC geometry inspired rotating black string can be expressed in term of as
The large radius limit, , leads to
When in Eq. (31), one gets the mass of NC geometry inspired black string (3). We observe that the mass of the NC geometry inspired black string increases with horizon radius and also increases with the rotation parameter (cf. Fig. 6a). In NC case the mass does not vanish, rather it gives a finite value, even when the horizon radius shrinks to zero (cf. Fig. 6b). But in the standared black string solution (3) mass vanishes as horizon radius approaches to zero. The mass of NC geometry inspired black string coincides with that of the standard black string at with (cf. Fig. 6b). The rotating black string has larger mass as compared to non-rotating case for the same values of horizon radius.
The temperature of the rotating black string is obtained through Eq. (19). The rotating black string has two Killing vectors: and , which amount to time translational and rotational symmetry. Thus, the Killing field is expressed as . Eq. (19) together with the solution (28) gives the expression of the temperature of NC geometry inspired rotating black string as
we can find the temperature of rotating black string in the limit as
This temperature (34) is also obtained by Lemos but they calculated it in terms of mass after Euclideanizing the rotating black string lemos95 (). The temperature profile looks similar to the non-rotating case. The temperature shifts toward the smaller values of horizon radius with increase in the rotation parameter . Having a positive defined temperature cannot exceed the interval . As approaches to 2/3, the temperature diverges. In the region , the temperature deviates from the standard result (cf. Fig. 7a). The temperature of NC geometry inspired rotating black string (33) coincides with rotating black string (34) at (cf. Fig. 7b).
Now, the entropy of the NC geometry inspired rotating black string is determined by using the first law of thermodynamics
we obtain the expression of entropy for NC geometry inspired rotating black string,
We recover the entropy of the rotating of the black string in the limit as
Finally, we analyze the thermodynamical stability of the NC geometry inspired rotating black string. The specific heat is given by Eq. (25), substituting (31) and (33) into (25), we find the heat capacity of the NC geometry inspired rotating black string as
again the large radius limit leads to
which is the specific heat of commutative rotating black string (7).
In the standard rotating black string solution heat capacity vanishes as horizon radius shrinks to zero. But in case of NC geometry inspired rotating black string the heat capacity does not vanish even if the horizon radius is zero (cf. Fig. 8b). We observed that the heat capacity has single stable phase in the interval and it shifts toward the divergences with increase in the value of rotation parameter (cf. Fig. 8a). As approaches to 2/3, the heat capacity diverges. In the region the specific heat () deviates from the standard result (41), and coincides at with fixed value of rotation parameter (cf. Fig. 8b).
Motivated by a string theory arguments snyder (), NC geometry inspired black hole spacetime has been explored extensively. In this paper, we have obtained NC geometry inspired cylindrically symmetric rotating black string solutions at a short distance, and thus Lemos black string solution is recovered in the large distance limit. It has been shown by Nicolini et. al nicoli06 () that noncommutatitivity can be introduced in general relativity by modifying the energy-momentum tensor. The resulting energy-momentum tensor has description of perfect fluid form with non-zero pressure and with the energy density distribution of diffused source. After solving Einstein’s field euations with this source, one can find the metric funtion of NC geometry inspired balck holes. Similiarly, we have applied this recipe to obtain the NC geometry inspired balck string (including its rotating counterpart) and discuss it’s behaviours in the region . Interestingly, it turns out that NC cures the divergences appearing in various form in the classical general relativity.
The black string metrices are governed by an anisotropic type of matter, whose non-vanishing pressure prevents matter collapsing into a singularity. Our black string solution contains their general relativity counterpart in the limit . The construction for the existence of extreme black string is derived. Despite of complexity due to NC geometry, we have obtained the exact expression for the thermodynamic quantities associatd with the NC geometry inspired black string, such as the Hawking temperature, the entropy and the heat capcity. In particular, the heat capacity is analysed in detail and shown that heat capacity is always positive at all radius. Both the NC geometry inspired rotating and non-rotating black strins have two horizon corresponding to certain values mass parameter, but one of the horizons (the inner or Cauchy horizon) has very small value() and therefore, is not visibile in the graphs. The results presented here are the generalization of the previous discussions of Lemos black string in general relativity in a more general setting, and the possibilit in by of a further generalization of these results to higher dimensional BTZ like solution is an interesting problem for future research.
Acknowledgements.Dharm Veer Singh acknowledges the University Grant Commission, India, for financial support through the D. S. Kothari Post Doctoral Fellowship (Grant No.: BSR/2015-16/PH/0014). S.G.G. would like to thanks SERB-DST Research Project Grant No. SB/S2/HEP-008/2014 and DST INDO-SA bilateral project DST/INT/South Africa/P-06/2016 and also to IUCAA, Pune for the hospitality while this work was being done.
- (1) K. S. Thorne, in Magic without magic, ed. J. R. Klander (Freeman, San Francisco, 1972).
- (2) J. P. S. Lemos, “Collapsing shells of radiation in antiâde Sitter spacetimes and the hoop and cosmic censorship conjectures” Phys. Rev. D 59, 044020 (1999).
- (3) E. Witten, “String theory and black holes” Phys. Rev. D 44, 314 (1991).
- (4) G. Mandal, A. Sengupta, and S.Wadia,“Classical Solution of 2-Dimensional String Theory” Mod. Phys. Lett. A 6, 1685 (1991).
- (5) C. G. Callan, Jr., S. B. Giddings, J. A. Harvey, and A.Strominger,“ Evanescent black holes” Phys. Rev. D 45, R1005 (1992).
- (6) R. B. Mann, A. Shiekh, and L. Tarasov, “Classical and quantum properties of two-dimensional black holes ” Nucl. Phys.B 341, 134 (1990).
- (7) K. C. K. Chan and R. B. Mann, “Static charged black holes in (2+ 1)-dimensional dilaton gravity” Phys.Rev. D 50, 6384 (1994).
- (8) K. C. K. Chan and R. B. Mann,“Static solution in three dimensions with naked singularity for gravity with massive scalar field” Phys. Lett. B 371, 199 (1996).
- (9) G. T. Horowitz and D. L. Welch, “String theory formulation of the three-dimensional black hole” Phys. Rev. lett. 71, 328 (1993).
- (10) J. H. Horne and G. T. Horowitz, “Exact Black String Solutions in Three Dimensions” Nucl. Phys. B 368, 444(1992).
- (11) W. G. Anderson and N. Kaloper, “Some new black string solutions in three dimensions ” Phys. Rev. D 52, 4440 (1995).
- (12) N. Kaloper, “Exact primordial black strings in four dimensions”, Phys. Rev. D 48, 4658 (1993).
- (13) A. Sen, “ Rotating charged black hole solution in heterotic string theory” Phys. Rev. Lett. 69, 1006 (1992).
- (14) G. Horowitz and A. Strominger, “Black strings and p-branes” Nucl. Phys. B 360, 197 (1991).
- (15) S.W. Hawking, “Black holes in general relativity ” Commun. Math. Phys 25, 152 (1972).
- (16) J . S. F. Chan and R. B Mann, “Inside a spinning black string ” Phys. Rev. D 51, 5428 (1995).
- (17) C. G. Huang and C. B. Liang, “A torus-like black hole ” Phys. Lett. A 201, 27 (1995).
- (18) P.S. Lemos, “Three dimensional black holes and cylindrical general relativity ” Phy. Lett. B 353 (1995) 46-51.
- (19) P.S. Lemos ,“Two-dimensional black holes and planar general relativity” Class. Quantum Grav., 12 (1995) 1081-1086.
- (20) P.S. Lemos and Vilson T Zanchin, “Rotating charged black strings and three-dimensional black holes” Phy. Rev D 54 (1996) 3840.
- (21) Rong-Gen Cai and Yuang-Zhong Zhang, “Black plane solution in four-dimensional spacetime” Phy. Rev. D 54 4891.
- (22) H. S. Snyder, “Quantized Space-Time” Phys. Rev.,71 38 ( 1947).
- (23) H. S. Snyder, “The Electromagnetic Field in Quantized Space-Time” Phys. Rev.,72, 68 (1947).
- (24) S. de Haro,“Non-Commutative Black Hole Algebra and String Theory from Gravity” Class. Quant. Grav. 15, 519 (1998).
- (25) S. de Haro,“Planckian Scattering and Black Holes” JHEP 9810, 23 (1998).
- (26) Y. S. Myung and M. Yoon, “Regular black hole in three dimensions,” Eur. Phys. J. C 62, 405 (2009).
- (27) Piero Nicolini, Anais Smailagic, Euro Spallucci, “Noncommutative geometry inspired Schwarzschild black hole” Physics Letters B 632 (2006) 547â551.
- (28) Piero Nicolini, Anais Smailagic, Euro Spallucci “Noncommutative geometry inspired charged black hole” Physics Letters B 645 (2007) 261â266.
- (29) T. G. Rizzo, “Noncommutative Inspired Black Holes in Extra Dimensions,” JHEP 0609, 021 (2006).
- (30) Piero Nicolini, Anais Smailagic, Euro Spallucci “Noncommutative geometry inspired higher-dimensional charged black hole” Phys. Lett. B 670 (2009) 449â454.
- (31) H. C. Kim, M. I. Park, C. Rim and J. H. Yee, “Smeared BTZ Black Hole from Space Noncommutativity,” JHEP 0810, 060 (2008).
- (32) P. Nicolini, “Noncommutative Black Holes, The Final Appeal To Quantum Gravity: A Review” Int. J. Mod. Phys. A , 24 1229 (2009).
- (33) Rabin Banerjee, Bibhas Ranjan Majhi and Sujoy Kumar Modak “Noncommutative Schwarzschild black hole and area law” Class. Quantum Grav. 26 (2009) 085010.
- (34) Robin. Banerjee, Bibhas Majhi and Saurav Samanta “Noncommutative Black Hole Thermodynamics” Phys. Rev. D 77, 124035 (2008).
- (35) C. Bambi and L. Modesto, “Rotating regular black holes,” Phys. Lett. B 721, 329 (2013).
- (36) S. G. Ghosh,“A nonsingular rotating black hole,” Eur. Phys. J. C 75 (2015) no.11, 532.
- (37) Simon F. Ross “ Black Hole Thermodynamics” arXiv: 0502195 [hep-th]
- (38) Y. S. Myung, Y. W. Kim and Y. J. Park, “Thermodynamics of regular black hole,” Gen. Rel. Grav. 41 (2009) 1051 arXiv:0708.3145 [gr-qc].
- (39) Sushant G. Ghosh, Uma Papnoi, and Sunil D. Maharaj “Cloud of strings in third order Lovelock gravity” Phys. Rev. D 90, 044068 (2014).