In-plane magnetic field effect on hole cyclotron mass and g_{z} factor in high-mobility SiGe/Ge/SiGe structures

In-plane magnetic field effect on hole cyclotron mass and factor in high-mobility SiGe/Ge/SiGe structures

Abstract

The high-frequency (ac) conductivity of a high quality modulation doped GeSi/Ge/GeSi single quantum well structure with hole density =610cm was measured by the surface acoustic wave (SAW) technique at frequencies of 30 and 85 MHz and magnetic fields of up to 18 T in the temperature range of 0.3 – 5.8 K. The acoustic effects were also measured as a function of the tilt angle of the magnetic field with respect to the normal of the two-dimensional channel at =0.3 K. It is shown, that at the minima of the conductivity oscillations, holes are localized on the Fermi level, and that there is a temperature domain in which the high-frequency conductivity in the bulk of the quantum well is of the activation nature. The analysis of the temperature dependence of the conductivity at odd filling factors enables us to determine the effective factor. It is shown that the in-plane component of the magnetic field leads to an increase of the cyclotron mass and to a reduction of the factor. We developed a microscopic theory of these effects for the heavy-hole states of the complex valence band in quantum wells which describes well the experimental findings.

pacs:
73.63.Hs, 73.50.Rb

I Introduction

Modulation doped SiGe/Ge/SiGe structures with a two-dimensional (2D) hole gas are attractive systems for both fundamental and applied studies since they are compatible with silicon-based technology and, at the same time, have a record high hole mobility among all group IV semiconductors. As compared to silicon-based metal-oxide-semiconductor field-effect-transistor structures, they are also characterized by a strong spin-orbit coupling and a large and strongly anisotropic -factor, which is of interest for the study of spin-related phenomena. However, the details of the band structure and the quantum transport in -SiGe/Ge/SiGe systems have not yet been sufficiently explored. It is known, that due to the lattice constant mismatch the 2D hole channel is located in strained Ge so that, the ground subband is formed by heavy-hole (hh) states while the light-hole (lh) subband is split off by a hundred meV. (1) The splitting should suppress the hh-lh mixing and lead to a strong anisotropy of the hh -factor tensor with vanishingly small in-plane component (2) One can therefore expect that the transport properties of the hole channel in SiGe/Ge/SiGe are determined by the normal component of the magnetic field only, (3) as they are in a strained -type channel of AB semiconductors. (4); (5); (6) Such a behavior has been observed in -Ge/SiGe multilayer structures by studying the resistivity oscillations in tilted magnetic fields up to a tilt angle of 60(7); (8) What concerns us about the absolute value of the hh out-of-plane -factor, , is that the data available in literature vary from 20.4 for bulk Ge, (9) to 16.5 for strained Ge, (10) to 14.2 and 5.8 for -Ge/GeSi multilayers, (9); (11) and to 1 for a single quantum well. (12) These drastically different values may be the result of many-body effects and spectrum nonparabolicity (2) which are also responsible for the observed dependence of the in-plane effective mass on the hole density.(13); (14)

In this paper, we report a comprehensive study of the high-frequency conductivity of the high-mobility 2D hole gas embedded in a SiGi/Ge/SiGe structure in tilted magnetic fields. The measurements are carried out by means of the contactless surface acoustic wave technique. It probes the “bulk” electric properties of the two-dimensional system and provides information on the 2D hole energy spectrum unaffected by chiral edges which play a key role in conventional four-probe measurements of the quantum Hall effect. The experimental data allow us to determine the hole cyclotron mass from the temperature dependence of Shubnikov-de Haas (SdH) oscillations and the effective factor for our samples. We find that both the cyclotron mass and the factor can be tuned by applying an in-plane magnetic field. Raising the in-plane field component leads to an increase of the cyclotron mass and decrease of the factor. We have developed a microscopic theory of these effects for the complex valence band of germanium and have shown that the theory describes well the experimental data.

Ii Sample and Method

The experiments were carried out on a -type SiGe/Ge/SiGe heterostructure with a single hole channel (sample K6016). (1); (15) The layer structure of the sample is illustrated in Fig. 1a. The two-dimensional hole gas has a density of 10cm and mobility  cm/(Vs) at 4.2 K. The structure was grown by low-energy plasma-enhanced chemical vapor deposition (LEPECVD) on a Si(001) substrate by making use of the large dynamic range of growth rates. (16) The buffer, graded at the rate of about 10m to the final Ge content of 70, and the 4-m-thick GeSi layer were grown at the high rate of nm/s gradually lowering the substrate temperature from 720C to 450C. The active part, consisting of a 20-nm-thick pure Ge layer sandwiched between cladding layers with a Ge content of about 60, and the Si cap were grown at the low rate of about 0.3 nm/s at = 450C. Modulation doping was achieved by introducing dilute diborane pulses into the cladding layer at a distance of about 30 nm above the channel. In the structure grown on a relaxed SiGe buffer layer, the Ge channel is compressively strained in the interface plane due to the lattice mismatch of about %, which leads to a splitting between the hh and lh subbands. Following Ref. (17), we estimate the hh-lh splitting  meV for our sample.

The properties of the 2D hole gas are studied by a contactless acoustoelectric method. The technique was first employed in Ref. (18) for GaAs/AlGaAs heterostructures. The experimental setup is illustrated in Fig. 1(b). A surface acoustic wave (SAW) is excited on the surface of a piezoelectric LiNbO platelet by an inter-digital transducer. The SAW propagating along the lithium niobate surface induces a high-frequency electric field which penetrates into the hole channel located in the SiGe/Ge/SiGe structure slightly pressed to the piezoelectric platelet by means of springs. The field produces an ac electrical current in the channel. As the result of the interaction of the SAW electric field with holes, the wave attenuates and its velocity is modified, governed by the high-frequency conductivity . This “sandwich-like” experimental configuration enables contactless acoustoelectric experiments on non-piezoelectric 2D systems, such as SiGe/Ge/SiGe. The measurements were done at SAW frequencies of 30 and 85 MHz, in external magnetic fields of up to 18 T, and in the temperature range of 0.3 – 5.8 K. The samples were mounted on a one-axis rotator, which enabled us to change the angle between the quantum well (QW) normal and the magnetic field.

Figure 1: (Color online) (a) Cross-section of the studied sample and (b) sketch of the acoustic experimental setup.

Iii Experimental results

Figure 2 shows the dependencies of the SAW attenuation change and normalized change of the SAW velocity on the magnetic field applied along the QW normal . The dependencies are presented for different temperatures. All curves contain pronounced oscillations, which are caused by the formation of Landau levels in the two-dimensional hole gas and microscopically are similar to the oscillations of the magnetoconductivity in the Shubnikov-de Haas and quantum Hall effects. We note that is negligibly small compared to due to very high electric conductivity of the hole gas at zero magnetic field, .

Figure 2: (Color online) Magnetic field dependences of and measured in a field up to 18 T at the SAW frequency  MHz, and in the temperature ranges of (a) 0.3–1.8 K and (b) 2–5.8 K. Arrows denote the positions of integer filling factors.

From the experimentally measured values of the SAW absorption and the relative change of the SAW velocity, one can calculate the real and imaginary components of the high-frequency conductivity of the hole channel by using Eqs. (1) and (2) of Ref. (15). Below, we focus on the real part of the ac conductivity only since it enables us to determine the parameters of the energy spectrum. The corresponding dependence of on the magnetic field for different temperatures is presented in Fig. 3. The magnetic field dependence of the conductivity contains the Shubnikov-de Haas oscillations evolving into the integer quantum Hall effect at strong fields. The positions of the even and odd filling factors corresponding to the orbital and spin splitting of the Landau levels, respectively, are shown by vertical arrows.

Figure 3: (Color online) Dependence of on the magnetic field at different temperatures for and for a SAW frequency  MHz. The positions of integer filling factors are marked by arrows.

Comparison of the temperature dependence of the conductivity at odd and even filling factors allows us to determine the absolute value of the factor. The procedure is the following. For odd filling factors, we found a temperature range (0.5-5.8 K) where the conductivity in the oscillation minima is of activation nature and described by the Arrhenius law

(1)

Here is the activation energy and is the temperature. Thus, the slope of the linear dependence of on yields the activation energy. The corresponding Arrhenius plots for the filling factors =3, 5, and 7 together with linear fits are presented in Fig. 4a. The activation energy is given by , where is the Zeeman splitting, is the Bohr magneton, and is the Landau level broadening. The latter also depends on the magnetic field, the calculation in the self-consistent Bohr approximation yields with being the field-independent parameter. (19); (20)

For even filling factors, the activation conductivity is also described by the Arrhenius law

(2)

where , is the energy spacing between the orbital Landau levels and is the cyclotron mass. The cyclotron mass for our Ge/SiGe structure is known with high accuracy from analysis of the Shubnikov-de Haas oscillations. (15) The Arrhenius plots for the even filling factors =10, 12, and 14 together with linear fits are presented in Fig. 4b.

The best fit of the activation conductivity for odd and even filling factors by Eqs. (1) and (2) yields and  meV T. The extracted dependence of the Zeeman splitting on the magnetic field is shown in the inset in Fig. 4a. Note, that the theoretical estimation (see Ref. (20)) yields the very close value  meV T for the quantum relaxation time  ps calculated for our sample from the Shubnikov-de Haas oscillations at the temperature 1.7 K. (15) The obtained value of the out-of-plane -factor differs from that of the heavy holes in bulk Ge, . We attribute the difference to renormalization of the energy spectrum in Ge quantum wells due to size quantization, strain, and interaction effects. The dispersion of heavy holes in quantum wells is typically non-parabolic so that the in-plane effective mass and -factor depend on the Fermi energy. We also note that in the above analysis we neglected possible oscillations of the hole -factor in the magnetic field due to exchange interaction. While the exchange contribution to the g-factor may be important for 2D electron systems, experimental results and theoretical analysis reveal that it is suppressed in GaAs-based hole systems. (21); (22); (23) The problem of the exchange interaction in strained Ge-based systems requires further study and is out of the scope of this paper.

Figure 4: (Color online) Dependence of on for (a) odd and (b) even filling factors. Lines are the result of linear fitting. Inset shows the obtained Zeeman splitting vs perpendicular magnetic field for odd filling factors.

To study the -factor anisotropy, the SAW absorption and velocity change were measured in tilted magnetic fields of magnitude . Figure 5 shows the obtained dependence of the real part of the conductivity on the normal component of magnetic field for various tilt angles . One can see that the positions of the conductivity minima are determined by the normal component of the magnetic field, which is in agreement with the 2D character of the hole states. Such behavior comes from the significant strain in -SiGe/Ge/SiGe structures resulting in the splitting between the hh and lh subbands of about 100 meV which exceeds the Fermi energy of 14 meV. Therefore, the in-plane component of the hh -factor vanishes and the Zeeman splitting is determined by .(24) Similar dependencies are also presented in Fig. 6a where the conductivity oscillations corresponding to small filling factors , 3, and 4 are shown as a function of the total magnetic field. With increasing the tilt angle, the positions of the oscillation minima are shifted towards higher magnetic fields while the oscillation amplitudes remain almost the same. Note, however, that study of conductivity at small filling factors requires high and therefore for =4 we were limited by 60 tilt angle.

Figure 5: (Color online) Dependence of on the normal component of the magnetic field for different tilt angles =(082); =30 MHz, =0.3 K.

Figure 6: (Color online) (a) Dependence of on the total magnetic field for different tilt angles; (b) vs for the tilt angles =0 - 80; =30 MHz, and =0.3 K. Arrows denote the positions of integer filling factors.

Figure 6b shows the magnetoconductivity oscillations as a function of at various angles for large filling factors , where a strong in-plane field can be applied to the sample. Surprisingly, we observe an effect of on the oscillations: The conductivity in the minima increases with increasing tilt angle at large and the oscillation amplitude decreases. We emphasize that such a behavior is observed for both even and odd filling factors, see Fig. 6b. Therefore, it cannot be explained by changes in relative positions of the Landau levels since, in that case, the amplitudes of conductivity oscillations corresponding to even and odd would change in antiphase. We attribute the observed features to the effect of the in-plane magnetic field on the hole cyclotron mass, factor, and Landau level broadening in the complex valence band of germanium.

According to the Arrhenius law Eq. (1), the decrease of the oscillation amplitudes at odd filling factors indicates a decrease of the activation energy . We suggest that the decrease is caused by the reduction of the absolute value of the hole -factor and increase of the Landau level broadening in the in-plane magnetic field. To second order in , the dependence of and on the magnetic field is given by

(3)

where and are the -factor and the parameter of the Landau level broadening at zero in-plane field, which are calculated above, and are parameters. Below, see part IV, we present the microscopic theory of the Zeeman splitting of heavy-hole states in QWs and show that exactly such a dependence of the -factor on the in-plane field follows from the theory. Equations (1) and (3) yield

(4)

where we take into account that for heavy holes in Ge, and is the conductivity in perpendicular magnetic field for given odd filling factor (an in-plane field independent term). To determine the field corrections to both the factor and Landau level broadening we plot in Fig. 7 the dependence of on for and  in the range of activation behavior of conductivity. The dependencies are linear, as expected, and yield  T,  meV T. For the magnetic field  T corresponding to the effect of on the Zeeman splitting is more than twice as large as the effect of on the level broadening.

Figure 7: Dependence of on for the filling factors =5 and 7.

The oscillations corresponding to even filling factors are also damped out with increasing the tilt angle , see Fig. 6b. This indicates a decrease of the activation energy which can be attributed to the increase of the cyclotron mass and the Landau level broadening by the in-plane component of the magnetic field. Similar behavior was observed for -type 2D systems in a number of papers and ascribed to the increase of (25); (26); (27) To second order in , the effect is phenomenologically described by

(5)

where is the free electron mass and is a parameter. From the Arrhenius law at even filling factors, Eq. (2), we obtain

(6)

where is the conductivity in perpendicular magnetic field for given even filling factor (the term independent of ).

Figure 8 shows the dependence of on measured at different corresponding to the filling factors , 12, and 14. In accordance with Eq. (6), the dependencies are linear. Fitting the experimental data by Eq. (6) with the parameters and obtained above yields  T. Comparing with we conclude that the dominant contribution to the variation of is due to change of the cyclotron mass.

Figure 8: (Color online) Dependence of on at the conductivity minima corresponding to the even filling factors =10, 12, and 14.

Below we calculate the parameters and determining the corrections to the spin splitting and cyclotron mass, respectively, for the heavy-hole subband in QWs and compare them with the values obtained from our experiment.

Iv Theory

We describe the effect of the in-plane magnetic field on the cyclotron mass and factor in the framework of the Luttinger model. In the axial approximation, the effective Hamiltonian of holes in Ge quantum wells in an external magnetic field has the form

(7)

where is the Luttinger Hamiltonian for zero in-plane momentum,

(8)

and are the Luttinger parameters, () are the matrices of the angular momentum , is the identity matrix, , is the diagonal matrix of confinement potentials which are different for the heavy-hole and light-hole subbands due to strain, is the Zeeman Hamiltonian,

(9)

is the parameter of the Zeeman splitting of hole states at the point of the Brillouin zone in bulk material, is the contribution to the Luttinger Hamiltonian accounting for the in-plane momentum and magnetic field,

(10)

, is the hole charge, is the vector potential of the magnetic field , and the braces denote the symmetrized product . Other possible contributions to the effective Hamiltonian beyond the Luttinger model, e.g., or , do not seem to give a substantial contribution to the cyclotron mass and factor in moderate in-plane magnetic fields.

We calculate the hole energy spectrum in the symmetric heterostructure subjected to the magnetic field in two steps. First, we solve the Schrödinger equation for the case of and find the envelope functions and and energies and of the heavy-hole and light-hole states, respectively, where are the subband indices. Each state is two-fold degenerate. Then we use perturbation theory and calculate the in-plane effective mass for the subband, which becomes anisotropic in the presence of the in-plane magnetic field, as well as the Zeeman splitting at the subband bottom. We assume that the magnetic field is oriented in the plane and choose the vector potential in the form . The corrections to the in-plane mass and the Zeeman splitting are proportional to and emerge in the second, third, and fourth orders of the perturbation theory. The knowledge of the in-plane effective masses and the Zeeman splitting enables us to obtain the quasi-classical structure of the Landau levels.

The calculation shows that the energy spectrum in the subband has the form

(11)

where is the cyclotron mass, and are the in-plane effective masses in the directions perpendicular and parallel to the in-plane component of the magnetic field, respectively, and is an integer number. The in-plane component of the -factor tensor vanishes at in the uniaxial approximation (28) and therefore gives only higher order corrections () to the Zeeman splitting for tilted magnetic fields.

The factor determining the spin splitting of Landau levels is given by Eq. (3) where the value in the perpendicular field has the form (29)

(12)

are the matrix elements of the momentum operator, and the coefficient is given by

(13)

Here we take into account that the matrix elements and are real while the matrix elements are purely imaginary (). The major contribution to comes typically from the terms containing only one light-hole energy in the denominator.

Figure 9: (Color online) Dependence of the coefficient on the Luttinger parameters in strain-free QW of width  Å.

Figure 9 shows the dependence of responsible for the factor renormalization on the Luttinger parameters calculated after Eq. (13) for strain-free rectangular QWs with infinitely high barriers. In this model, the dependence of on the QW width is simplified to . The curves in Fig. 9 are plotted for  Å. It follows from the calculation that the correction to the factor caused by the in-plane magnetic field depends on the material parameters.

The in-plane masses are given by

(14)

where is the in-plane mass at zero magnetic field,

(15)

The parameter , which determines renormalization of the cyclotron mass in the in-plane field, and the parameter describing the mass anisotropy have the form

where is given by Eq. (13),

(16)
(17)
(18)

and are the overlap integrals of the envelope functions. We note that the dominant contribution to the cyclotron mass renormalization comes from the coupling of the and subbands by the in-plane magnetic field given by the first term in , Eq. (16), and is similar to that in electron systems. (19) However, in contrast to the conduction band where the effective mass is modified only for the direction perpendicular to the magnetic field, in hole systems both components of the effective mass tensor are renormalized.

Equations (13) and (16) enable one to calculate the renormalizations of the cyclotron mass and Zeeman splitting in hole systems caused by the in-plane magnetic field.

V Discussion and Summary

The experimental results discussed above demonstrate that, in SiGe/Ge/SiGe quantum wells, the in-plane component of the magnetic field leads to a decrease of the effective factor and to an increase in the hole cyclotron mass. The effects are described by Eqs. (3) and (5), respectively, which also follow from the microscopic theory, with the fitting parameters  T and  T.

Figure 10 shows the theoretical dependence of the coefficients and describing the effective mass and factor renormalization, respectively, on the QW width. The curves are calculated for a rectangular Ge quantum well with the infinitely high barriers, taking into account the strain-induced splitting of the hh and lh subbands (solid curves) and neglecting the strain (dashed curves). Both and increase with the QW width. The coefficient is almost independent of strain since its dominant part is determined by the structure of the hh subbands only. In contrast, the Zeeman splitting renormalization occurs due to the mixing of the hh and lh subbands and is therefore sensitive to the hh-lh splitting induced by strain. The dependence of on strain is more pronounced for wide QWs where the hh-lh splitting due to size quantization is comparable to or smaller than the strain-induced splitting. The absolute values of and extracted from the experiment correspond to the calculated values for the QW width of about  Å  according to Fig. 10. The nominal QW width in the studied sample is  Å, but the effective length of the hole confinement might be considerably smaller due to the build-in electric field produced by ionized dopants incorporated in the barrier above the QW (see Sec. II). This electric field pushes the holes to the upper interface thereby reducing the effective QW width.

Figure 10: Dependence of (a) and (b) on the QW width for a strained ( meV, solid curves) and strain-free (, dashed curves) Ge quantum well. The curves are calculated for the Luttinger parameters and .

To summarize, we have performed contactless acoustoelectric measurements of the high-frequency conductivity of the two-dimensional hole gas in a -SiGe/Ge/SiGe structure subjected to a strong magnetic field. It has been shown that in certain temperature domains and integer filling factors the conductivity is of the activation nature. The analysis of the activated conductivity at odd and even filling factors in perpendicular magnetic field enabled us to determine . By applying a tilted magnetic field we observed that at fixed normal component of the field, the conductivity in oscillation minima increases with increasing ( ) at both even and odd filling factors for 5. Such a behavior is attributed to the decrease of the cyclotron frequency and Zeeman splitting of holes and the broadening of the Landau levels by the in-plane component of the magnetic field. We have developed a microscopic theory of the heavy-hole cyclotron mass and factor renormalization in the framework of the Luttinger Hamiltonian. This theory describes the experimental data and predicts the renormalization to be more pronounced in wide quantum wells.

Acknowledgements.
The authors would like to thank E. Palm, T. Murphy, J.-H. Park, and G. Jones for technical assistance and V.A. Volkov and V.S. Khrapai for useful discussions. This work was supported by Russian Foundation for Basic Research, the Program ”Spintronika” of Branch of Physical Sciences of RAS, and the U.M.N.I.K grant 16906. National High Magnetic Field Laboratory is supported by NSF Cooperative Agreement No. DMR-1157490, the State of Florida, and the U.S. Department of Energy.

References

  1. H. von Känel, M. Kummer, G. Isella, E. Müller, T. Hackbarth, Appl. Phys. Lett. 80, 2922 (2002).
  2. E.L. Ivchenko and G.E. Pikus, Superlattices and Other Heterostructures: Symmetry and Optical Phenomena (Springer, Berlin, 1997).
  3. S.A. Tarasenko, Fiz. Tverd. Tela 44, 1690 (2002) [Phys. Solid State 44, 1769 (2002)].
  4. R.W. Martin, R.J. Nicholas, G.J. Rees, S.K. Haywood, N.J.Mason, and P.J. Walker, Phys. Rev. B 42, 9237 (1990); Proc. of the 20th Int.Conf. on the Physics of Semiconductors, Thessaloniki v.2, 909, Thessaloniki (1990). Tilting done till angles of 64.
  5. S.I. Dorozhkin, Sol. St. Comm. 72, 211 (1989), Phys. Rev. B 61, 7803 (2000).
  6. S.Y. Lin, H.P. Wei, D.C. Tsui, J.F. Klem, S.J. Allen Jr., Phys. Rev. B 43, 12110 (1991). Tilting done till angles of 49.5.
  7. N.A. Gorodilov, O.A. Kuznetsov, L.K. Orlov, R.A. Rubtsova, A.L. Chernov, N.G. Shelushinina, G.L. Shtrapenin, Pis’ma Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 56, 409 (1992) [JETP Letters 56, 394 (1992)].
  8. Yu.G. Arapov, N.A. Gorodilov, O.A. Kuznetsov, V.N. Neverov, L.K. Orlov, R.A. Rubtsova, G.I. Kharus, A.L. Chernov, N.G. Shelushinina, G.L. Shtrapenin, Fiz. Tekh. Poluprovodn. 27, 1165 (1993) [Semiconductors 27, 642 (1993)].
  9. Yu.G. Arapov, V.N. Neverov, G.I. Harus, N.G. Shelushinina, M.V. Yakunin, O.A. Kuznetsov, L. Ponomarenko and A. de Visser, Low Temp. Phys. 30, 867 (2004). [Fiz. Nizk. Temp. 30, 1157 (2004)].
  10. A. V. Nenashev, A. V. Dvurechenskii, and A. F. Zinovieva, Phys. Rev. B 67, 205301 (2003).
  11. A.V. Chernenko, N.G. Kalugin, O.A. Kusnetsov, JETP 87, 337 (1998) [Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 114, 619 (1998)].
  12. R. Moriya, Y. Hoshi, Y. Inoue, S. Masubuchi, K. Sawano, Y. Shiraki, N. Usami, T. Machida, Bull. APS 58, 259 (2013).
  13. T. Irisawa, M. Myronov, O.A. Mironov, E.H.C. Parker, K. Nakagawa, M. Murata, S. Koh, Y. Shiraki, Appl. Phys. Lett. 82, 1425 (2003).
  14. B. Rössner, B. Batlogg, H. von Känel, D. Chrastina, G. Isella, Mat. Sc. Semicond. Proc. 9, 777 (2006).
  15. I.L. Drichko, A.M. Diakonov, E.V. Lebedeva, I.Yu. Smirnov, O.A. Mironov, M. Kummer, and H. von Känel, J. Appl. Phys. 106, 094305 (2009).
  16. C. Rosenblad, H.R. Deller, A. Dommann, T. Meyer, P. Schroeter, and H. von Känel, J. Vac. Sci. Technol. A 16, 2785 (1998).
  17. C.G. Van de Walle, Phys. Rev. B39, 1871 (1989).
  18. A. Wixforth, J. Scriba, M. Wassermeier, J. P. Kotthaus, G. Weimann, and W. Schlapp, Phys. Rev. B 40, 7874 (1989); A. Wixforth, J.P. Kotthaus, and G. Weimann, Phys. Rev. Lett. 56, 2104 (1986).
  19. T. Ando, A.B. Fowler, and F. Stern, Rev. Mod. Phys. 54, 437 (1982).
  20. P.T. Coleridge, Sol. St. Comm. 127, 777 (2003).
  21. R. Winkler, E. Tutuc, S.J. Papadakis, S. Melinte, M. Shayegan, D. Wasserman, and S.A. Lyon, Phys. Rev. B 72, 195321 (2005).
  22. Y.T. Chiu, M. Padmanabhan, T. Gokmen, J. Shabani, E. Tutuc, M. Shayegan, and R. Winkler, Phys. Rev. B 84, 155459 (2011).
  23. T. Kernreiter, M. Governale, R. Winkler, and U. Zülicke, Phys. Rev. B 88, 125309 (2013).
  24. The vanishingly small value of the in-plane -factor is additionally supported by the fact that no change in the ac conductivity is observed in the pure in-plane magnetic field.
  25. V.S. Khrapai, E.V. Deviatov, A.A. Shashkin, V.T. Dolgopolov, Proc. NGS 10 IPAP Conf. Series 2, 105 (2001).
  26. V.E. Kozlov, S.I. Gubarev, I.V. Kukushkin, JETP Letters 94, 397 (2011) [Pis’ma v Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 94, 429 (2011)].
  27. A.T. Hatke, M.A. Zudov, L.N. Pfeiffer, K.W. West, Phys. Rev. B 85, 241305(R) (2012).
  28. X. Marie, T. Amand, P. Le Jeune, M. Paillard, P. Renucci, L.E. Golub, V.D. Dymnikov and E.L. Ivchenko, Phys. Rev. B 60, 5811 (1999).
  29. Th. Wimbauer, K. Oettinger, Al.L. Efros, B.K. Meyer, and H. Brugger, Phys. Rev. B 50, 8889 (1994).
Comments 0
Request Comment
You are adding the first comment!
How to quickly get a good reply:
  • Give credit where it’s due by listing out the positive aspects of a paper before getting into which changes should be made.
  • Be specific in your critique, and provide supporting evidence with appropriate references to substantiate general statements.
  • Your comment should inspire ideas to flow and help the author improves the paper.

The better we are at sharing our knowledge with each other, the faster we move forward.
""
The feedback must be of minumum 40 characters
Add comment
Cancel
Loading ...
131416
This is a comment super asjknd jkasnjk adsnkj
Upvote
Downvote
""
The feedback must be of minumum 40 characters
The feedback must be of minumum 40 characters
Submit
Cancel

You are asking your first question!
How to quickly get a good answer:
  • Keep your question short and to the point
  • Check for grammar or spelling errors.
  • Phrase it like a question
Test
Test description