Generalized Bloch’s theorem for viscous metamaterials: Dispersion and effective properties based on frequencies and wavenumbers that are simultaneously complex

Generalized Bloch’s theorem for viscous metamaterials: Dispersion and effective properties based on frequencies and wavenumbers that are simultaneously complex

Michael J. Frazier    Mahmoud I. Hussein Department of Aerospace Engineering Sciences, University of Colorado Boulder, Boulder, CO 80309-0429, USA
July 5, 2019

It is common for dispersion curves of damped periodic materials to be based on real frequencies versus complex wavenumbers or, conversely, real wavenumbers versus complex frequencies. The former condition corresponds to harmonic wave motion where a driving frequency is prescribed and where attenuation due to dissipation takes place only in space alongside spatial attenuation due to Bragg scattering. The latter condition, on the other hand, relates to free wave motion admitting attenuation due to energy loss only in time while spatial attenuation due to Bragg scattering also takes place. Here, we develop an algorithm for 1D systems that provides dispersion curves for damped free wave motion based on frequencies and wavenumbers that are permitted to be simultaneously complex. This represents a generalized application of Bloch’s theorem and produces a dispersion band structure that fully describes all attenuation mechanisms, in space and in time. The algorithm is applied to a viscously damped mass-in-mass metamaterial exhibiting local resonance. A frequency-dependent effective mass for this damped infinite chain is also obtained.

thanks: Current affiliation: California Institute of Technology

I Introduction

Phononic materials have been attracting much attention in the materials physics and engineering communities because of their rich scope of acoustic and elastodynamic properties MeadJSV1996 (); HusseinAMR2014 (); Deymier2013 (); Khelif2015 (); Laude2015 (). There are two classes of phononic materials: phononic crystals SigalasJSV1992 (); KushwahaPRL1993 () and locally resonant acoustic/elastic metamaterials LiuScience2000 (). Phononic crystals resemble atomic-scale crystals in that they consist of repeated units in space. The dispersion curves for elastic wave propagation in a phononic crystal, or a periodic material in general, appear in bands and in some cases band gaps may arise. Bragg scattering is the prime band-gap opening mechanism in a phononic crystal. Metamaterials are usually also periodic, although not by necessity. The prefix meta- (meaning “beyond”) is associated with the notion that through deliberate design of the internal structure, these materials manifest unusual properties that exceed those of conventional composites and phononic crystals. In the context of wave propagation, local resonances are generally the key feature in metamaterials leading to salient properties such as subwavelength band gaps LiuPRB2002 (); WangPRL2004 (); PennecPRB2008 (); WuAPL2008 (), negative effective material properties LiPRE2004 (); DingPRL2007 (); AoWRCM2010 (); LiuAPL2011 (), enhanced dissipation HusseinJSV2013 (); AntoniadisJSV2015 (); Chen_Sun_2016 (), and thermal conductivity reduction DavisHusseinPRL2014 (), among others.
At present, much of the phenomena of wave propagation in phononic materials is understood from the perspective of conservative linear elasticity. Realizing their full potential, however, requires an account of energy dissipation from damping. Already, metamaterials possessing internal resonating bodies have been shown to demonstrate enhanced dissipation under certain conditions (i.e., beyond which may be attributed to the sum of the individual material constituents) HusseinJSV2013 (); AntoniadisJSV2015 (); Chen_Sun_2016 (). This property is beneficial where enhanced dissipation in a structure is needed but without appearing at the expense of stiffness. There are numerous avenues for the treatment of damping in material or structural models, including those representing phononic materials. A common approach is to consider viscous damping, for which a simple version is known as Rayleigh Rayleigh1877 (), or proportional, dampingwhereby the matrix of damping coefficients is assumed to be proportional to the mass and/or stiffness matrices CaugheyJAM1965 (); AdhikariJSV2006 (); AdhikariJVA2009 (). If the proportionality condition is not met, then the model is described as generally damped WoodhouseJSV1998 (); AdhikariJSV2001 (). Experiments are used to determine an appropriate damping model for a given material or structure PhaniJSV2007 ().
Beyond the choice of the damping model, an important consideration is whether the frequency or the wavenumber is selected to be real and, consequently, which is permitted to be complex. There are two classes of problems dealing with damped phononic materials. In one class, the frequencies are assumed a priori to be real thus allowing the effects of damping to manifest only in the form of complex wavenumbers. Physically, this represents a medium experiencing wave propagation due to a sustained driving frequency and dissipation taking effect in the form of spatial attenuation only. This approach follows a formulation (where and denote wavenumber and frequency, respectively) resulting from either a linear TassillyIJES1987 (); LangleyJSV1994 (); LaudePRB2009 (); RomeroNJP2010 (); MoiseyenkoPRB2011 (); AndreassenJVA2013 () or a quadratic MeadJSV1973 (); FarzbodJVA2011 (); ColletIJSS2011 () eigenvalue problem (EVP). In the other class, the frequencies are permitted to be complex thus allowing dissipation to take effect in the form of temporal attenuation. Physically, this represents a medium admitting free dissipative wave motion, e.g., due to impulse loading. Here, a formulation leading to a linear EVP is the common route (in some cases with the aid of a state-space transformation); see Refs. MukherjeeCS1975 (); SprikSSC1998 (); HusseinPRB2009 (); HusseinJAP2010 (); PhaniJVA2013 (); AndreassenJVA2013 ().
In the ‘driven waves’ path, a real frequency is prescribed and the underlying EVP is solved for a corresponding pair of real and imaginary wavenumbers, representing propagation and attenuation constants, respectively. All modes are described by complex wavenumbers due to the dissipation. In the ‘free waves’ path, on the other hand, a real wavenumber is specified, and complex frequencies emerge as the solution (the real and imaginary parts respectively provide the loss factor and the frequency for each mode). Because of the common association of the driven waves problem to an EVP for which the frequency is the independent variable and, in contrast, the free waves problem to an EVP for which the wavenumber is the independent variable, it is often viewed that the two only available options are: real frequencies and complex wavenumbers versus real wavenumbers and complex frequencies Achenbach1999 (); MaceJSV2008 (); ManconiJSV2010 (). However, if the medium permits spatial attenuation in its undamped statewhich is the case for phononic materials within band-gap frequenciesthen, in principle, there should be an imaginary wavenumber component (in addition to the real wavenumber component) even when the frequencies are complex. This, in fact, represents a more complete picture of the dispersion curves for damped free wave motion in media that contain inherent mechanisms for spatial attenuation, such as Bragg scattering and local resonance. Since this scenario pertains only to free waves, one expects to see complex frequencies for bands admitting only spatial propagation as well as bands admitting evanescent waves (with the real part of the wavenumber being either zero or divided by the lattice spacingthe two values that represent the limits of the irreducible Brillouin zone). For a proportionally damped problem, a solution that permits both the frequencies and wavenumbers to be complex has been obtained using the transfer matrix method which gives a linear EVP HusseinHB2013 (). For a generally damped problem, however, an all-complex solution cannot be obtained from a linear EVP, nor from directly solving a quadratic EVP.
In this paper, we consider damped free motion in 1D systems and provide an algorithmbased on a quadratic EVPthat provides the dispersion curves and damping ratio constants for both spatially propagating and attenuating waves. As an example, we focus on a viscously damped mass-in-mass chain representing a locally resonant acoustic/elastic metamaterial HuangIJES2009 (). With a complex wavenumbers-complex frequencies band structure at hand, we also compute a frequency-dependent effective mass. In the absence of dissipation, this effective mass is real and negative in the region of the band gap. As damping alters the dispersion characteristics, we observe the effective mass to transition to complex form and its region of negativity diminishes as the intensity of the damping increases.

Ii Theory: Dispersion Relations

We consider a nested 1D lumped parameter mass-spring-dashpot model similar to what is investigated in Ref. HuangIJES2009 (). Infinite in extent, a model of a locally resonant acoustic/elastic metamaterial is constructed by appending copies ad infinitum of the unit cell depicted in Fig. 1a along the line of motion. Prior to application of boundary conditions, there are three degrees of freedom (DOF) in this unit cell with , , and denoting the displacement of the left and right cell boundaries and an internal DOF, respectively. Each of these have an associated mass: , , and . On the boundaries, the forces and apply. Springs with stiffness and dashpots with viscosity connect the DOFs.

Figure 1: One-dimensional, discrete unit cell for a periodic material with lattice spacing : (a) 2-DOF acoustic/elastic metamaterial; (b) equivalent 1-DOF material

Balancing all dynamic forces, the motion of each DOF in Fig. 1a is described by the following equations:


Together, Eqs. (1) may be assembled into a system of equations


where , , and are the assembled mass, damping, and stiffness matrices, respectively. Collecting and arranging the nodal displacements and forces , allows the mass, damping, and stiffness matrices to be defined as follows:


where we utilize the ratios , , and to write the matrices in terms of the resonator parameters. Dividing by , the system in Eq. (2) is written as


where is a measure of damping intensity (which varies with ,) and is the resonance frequency.

In the periodic material, is tied to of the previous unit cell; likewise, is tied to of the subsequent unit cell. For the material to support Bloch wave propagation, the displacements at the boundaries are related according to . If we define the essential set of displacements as ( gathers the essential boundary displacements and collects all the internal displacements), then the complete set of displacements may be written in terms of and the translational operator as follows:


Given and ,


The Bloch boundary condition is applied via the matrix . Substituting Eq. (5) into Eq. (4) and premultiplying by (the conjugate transpose of ), we arrive at




Equilibrium in the region between unit cells leads to FarzbodJVA2011propagation (). For general wave motion, a displacement solution takes the form . For driven waves, , while for free waves, is generally complex and yet to be determined. Applying this solution form to Eq. (7) yields


which, upon simplification, gives the following quadratic matrix relationship for a non-trivial solution:


where and . This formulation may proceed along two paths resulting in either generalized frequency solutions, , or generalized wavenumber solutions, .

ii.1 Frequency Solutions from Linear Eigenvalue Problem

In the case of a prescribed, real-valued wavenumber, the matrices in Eq. (7) are written explicitly as follows:


In general, is not simultaneously diagonalizable with and/or Rayleigh1877 () except if specific conditions are met to allow for a Rayleigh damping model CaugheyJAM1965 (); AdhikariJSV2006 (); AdhikariJVA2009 (). Reference HusseinPRB2009 () has conveniently considered the Rayleigh damping scenario and demonstrated that dissipation, especially when intense, can generate unique phenomena in the band structure such as branch overtaking and wavenumber cut-offs and cut-ons. Additional analysis on the effects of damping on the band structure, including in generally damped models, is offered in Ref. PhaniJVA2013 ().
Presently, Eq. (9) represents a nonlinear eigenvalue problem. In order to recover a linear form, we first apply a state-space transformation to Eq. (7) HusseinJAP2010 ()


where . Assuming a state-space solution , where is a complex wave amplitude vector, we formulate the following generalized linear eigenvalue problem in :


The associated characteristic equation takes the form




In general, the solutions (where is equal to the number of DOF) to Eq. (14) are complex and take the form


Specifically, is the damped wave frequency and is the temporal rate of decay of the wave amplitude. The quantity is the dimensionless damping ratio (loss factor) and is referred to as the “resonant frequency”. Explicitly, retaining the solutions for which , the damped frequency relation for branch is


and the complementary wavenumber-dependent damping ratio relation is


ii.2 Wavenumber Solutions from Quadratic Eigenvalue Problem

The preceding linear eigenvalue formulation is applicable only for prescribed, real-valued wavenumbers, . In general, however, the wavenumber is complex regardless if we are considering driven waves or free waves, as explained in Section I. The wavenumber in complex form is expressed as , with representing the wave spatial oscillation and representing the spatial amplitude decay. In order to determine these quantities for a wave of a given frequency, , the problem must be reformulated to deliver wavenumber solutions in exchange.

In Eq. (9), we leave the value of the wavenumber (and, therefore, ) to be determined. Taking the determinate of the coefficient matrix in Eq. (9), the characteristic equation in takes the following quadratic form:


where , and


Upon solving for , and are extracted as follows:


In the absence of energy dissipation, , where is a real number representing the wave frequency, and is obtained directly by solving Eq. (19) for a given value of . In the presence of energy dissipation, is obtained also directly by solving Eq. (19) for waves with a prescribed frequency, , i.e., driven waves. However, for free waves, energy dissipation results in the frequency being complex, as is the wavenumber, as discussed above. Thus the frequencies take the form .

From earlier work on viscous problems, e.g., HusseinJAP2010 (), we understand that damped, free wave propagation produces two band diagrams representing the real and imaginary components of the frequency, respectively. Additionally, for locally resonant metamaterials, each free waves band diagram can be divided into band segments featuring only propagating waves (i.e., purely real wavenumbers) and band segments featuring evanescent waves. In the latter case, there are two possible subsegments: one with complex wavenumbers and one with purely imaginary wavenumbers, both of which take place only within a band gap. In a subsegment where the wavenumber is complex, the real part is equal to . Thus a band gap bounded by pass bands from the bottom and the top has a subsegment where and a subsegment where , as illustrated in Fig. 2b. Following the state-space formulation in Sec. II.1, the propagating segments are readily obtained HusseinJAP2010 (). However, a complete solution featuring all available imaginary wavenumbers is not possible with this formulation.

Figure 2: Undamped band structure of the locally resonant metamaterial of Fig. 1a. (a) Uppermost branch is obtained by a standard formulation as well as by the proposed algorithm, thus providing a verification on the accuracy of the algorithm. (b) Illustration of wavenumber subsegments inside the band gap. Separated by an anti-resonance frequency, the lower subsegment has and the upper subsegment has .

We approach this problem also by using Eq. (19). However, a unique combination of the real and imaginary components of does not exist without constraints. Following from the above discussion, a free wave does not allow any propagating component (other than ) to exist inside a band gap. Thus a damped, free wave at a particular frequency is either outside a band gap and is purely propagating or inside a band gap and is evanescent. Based on these characteristics, we develop an algorithm to find the () pair that satisfies Eq. (19) with which gives us the attenuation constant inside band gaps. The propagating portion of the band structure on the other hand is easily determined from Eqs. (17) and (18). Nevertheless, the algorithm may be readily modified to determine the propagating part of the band structure as well. Although this procedure is developed following a quadratic eigenvalue formulation, a similar algorithm based on a linear formulation is a subject for future research.

Algorithm for all-complex band structure for free waves:

This algorithm is specific to the evanescent part of the band structure.

  1. Set .

  2. Determine and following the method in Sec. II.1 for .

  3. Define a two-dimensional search space corresponding to the gap regions in the plot.

  4. Discretize the domain into a grid of points ().

  5. For each , calculate following the method in Sec. II.2.

  6. Set a target value for (maintaining that ) and a target .

  7. Of the that produce within tolerance of the target , retain the one or more that correspond to closest to the target .

  8. Extract and from the retained using Eqs. (17) and (18), respectively.

  9. Repeat steps 6–8 for different target until the evanescent band structure is constructed.

The outcome of the above algorithm is an approximation of the evanescent frequencies and the damping ratios for a particular damping intensity. In addition to setting up a finer grid over the domain for a better approximation of , a more clear picture of the evanescent band structure obviously results from decreasing the separation between subsequent target values.

Figure 3: Demonstration of all-complex band-structure calculation algorithm. (a) For a value, a search space is defined corresponding to the gap regions seen in following Eq. (16) (Steps 1–3). After discretizing the 2D search space, Eq. (21) is used to determine the set of giving approximations (within a preset set tolerance threshold) to the target (red) (Steps 4-6). Of these, the one that best approximates the target (blue) is taken as the solution from which and are extracted (Steps 7 and 8). (b) Demonstration of the same procedure in the corresponding domain.

Figure 3 gives a visual example of an application of the algorithm for a specific set of material parameters (, , , rad/s and . Shown later in Figs. 4b and 4c are the band-gap ranges used to bound the domain for this example. In the closed, discretized domain of Figure 3a, we isolate the set of points that satisfy, separately, the conditions (targets) and . At the intersection of the and loci is the value which is retained as an approximate solution. The intersection moves along the curve for each new target , generating new approximations which ultimately construct the evanescent frequency and damping ratio band diagrams over the range of the targeted values. More than one physical solution may exist for a given . To validate the algorithm, we examine the values corresponding to the uppermost band gap, which for an undamped system is practically unbounded (see Fig. 2a). This upper branch is unique in that it may be obtained by both the state-space formulation given in Sec. II.1 (as demonstrated in Ref.  HusseinJAP2010 ()) as well as by the algorithm. Both independent routes yield the same values for any level of damping intensity.

Iii Theory: Equivalent Mass Model

Figure 1b shows the equivalent lattice model, which we require to exhibit the same dynamic behavior as the original nested-mass model. The equivalent lattice model has the same construction as the original metamaterial (i.e., and are the same) except the motion of the internal resonator is considered unobservable, although its influence is accounted for by , the effective mass. The value varies with frequency, satisfying its own dynamic equilibrium, and concurrently matching the complex frequency of the original mass-in-mass metamaterial. This concept was also applied in Ref. MiltonPRSA2007 () where a rigid bar conceal periodically distributed internal resonators. Expectedly, at low frequencies, the value of converges to the static value, . The terms “static” and “nominal” are used to indicate values attained in the long-wavelength limit.

The equation of motion for each degree of freedom in the equivalent lattice model (Fig. 1b) is given by:


Assembling Eqs. (22) into a system of equations as in Eq. (2), the mass, damping, and stiffness matrices are defined as follows:


with the nodal displacements and forces organized as and , respectively. The essential set of displacements is simply . Assuming a real-valued wavenumber, we apply the Bloch boundary conditions through . This leads to


in which the effective mass ratio has been normalized by the static mass, , and the previously defined ratios , , , , and have been taken advantage of. Applying the harmonic displacement solution , Eq. (24) gives


however, in preparation for substitution, Eq. (25) is algebraically manipulated into the following form:


Now, we tie the dynamic characteristics of the equivalent model to the original metamaterial model by simultaneously substituting Eq. (26) into Eqs. (11b) and (11c).


Using these new matrix definitions for the damping and stiffness matrices, we proceed with Bloch state-space treatment. This process delivers the following characteristic equation:


which we subsequently solve for :


The quantity is evaluated for the damped free waves problem by substituting with the values obtained from the solution of Eq. (14) and the execution of the algorithm.

Iv Numerical Examples

In this section, we present a suite of numerical examples to demonstrate all-complex band structures for damped free wave propagation. The examples are for the mass-in-mass metamaterial model shown in Fig. 1a, which allows us to examine, in a general manner, the role of dissipation in acoustic/elastic metamaterials, both in terms of the dispersion curves and the effective mass. The damping intensity is varied to give a broad representation of dissipative effects. The same set of material parameters used for the Fig. 3 demonstration is used here as an example for our exposition. These parameters are consistent with the relatively high material contrast characteristic of metamaterials and are similar to those selected in Ref. HusseinJAP2010 () thus providing an opportunity for direct comparison with some of the results presented in that publication.

Figure 4: Dispersion band diagrams. (a) The frequency band diagram for driven waves generated by direct solving of where, for , is complex for all prescribed . The incomplete frequency (b) and damping ratio (c) band diagrams for free waves generated by direct solving of for all prescribed where .

As a consequence of the unit cell’s two-DOF character, in the undamped case (), there are two modes of wave propagation comprising an acoustical (lower) branch and an optical (upper) branch. These are shown in the dispersion band diagrams in Fig. 4. Separating the two branches, there is a resonance-induced band-gap region where and describing evanescent modes for which waves do not propagate and their amplitudes spatially decay at rates dictated by the value of . In addition to a closed band-gap region, an unbounded region of evanescent modes exists above the optical branch. For compact presentation, we plot the imaginary wavenumbers within the range . Without an algorithm, a band diagram with complex wavenumbers can only be determined for damped waves with prescribed real frequencies, that is, (Fig. 4a). In this scenario, the band gap closes and becomes progressively more obscure with greater damping intensity. Alternatively, the complex frequencies of damped free waves can only be directly calculated for (Fig. 4b). The frequency band gaps for free waves are shown to shift but remain intact with increased damping intensity. At extreme damping levels, however, branch overtakings and cut-offs and/or cut-ins are observed to take place. Figure 4 contrasts each of these “either/or” scenarios for various values of . A complete band structure description featuring generally a complex and a complex is made possible by the algorithm presented in Section II.2.

Figure 5: All-complex dispersion curves. The complete frequency (a) and damping ratio (b) band diagrams for free waves generated by the proposed algorithm for all prescribed where .

Now, we apply the algorithm and present the resulting all-complex band structure in Fig. 5. This band structure is, by definition, for the damped free waves case. Inspection of the effects of damping can now be done for both the propagating and evanescent modes. We note an intense responsiveness from the optical branch and the upper portion of the evanescent curves to increases in dissipation, in contrast to the still significant but milder effects on the acoustical branch and the lower portion of the evanescent curves. As damping increases, the concavity of the optical branch in Fig. 5a changes. This points to a damping-induced change in the sign of the wave group velocity from positive (longer wavelengths) to negative (shorter wavelengths). In addition, as mentioned above, the more rapid decent of the optical branch compared to the acoustical branch closes the band gap and inevitably leads to branch overtaking. Thus the optical and acoustical modes exchange order in the frequency spectrum over specific wavenumber values. Similarly in the evanescent modes, damping will induce a change in concavity in the upper portion of the curves. One interesting aspect of the behavior displayed in Fig. 5b is that the damping ratio of the lower, non-propagating portion of the evanescent curves appears to peak at approximately regardless of the level of damping.

We turn to the effective mass, which is shown by Eq. (29) to be frequency dependent. Without damping, the effective mass approaches its static value in the long wavelength limit (), as expected. That is, in the long wavelength limit, indicating that . Several studies have shown the effective mass to become negative over a frequency range in the region of the band gap, e.g., Refs. HuangIJES2009 (); NematNasserAIP2011 (). Here and in Refs. HusseinPRB2009 (); HusseinJAP2010 (), we see that viscous damping narrows and eventually closes the band gap. Thus the natural question is: how does damping affect the effective mass? This question is addressed by using Eq. (29) with the complex frequencies determined by the algorithm in Sec. II.2. Figure 6 shows that damping acts to narrow the frequency region at which the effective mass is negative. Also shown is that in the presence of damping, increasing widens this frequency region up to a point after which the effect abruptly reverses and the region narrows.

Figure 6: Dynamic effective mass curves. (a) Real component of effective mass; (b) imaginary component of effective mass; (c) zero (solid curves) and asymptote (dashed curves) of Eq. (29) enclosing the region of negative effective mass. The dashed vertical lines in (a) and (b) represent the real and imaginary asymptotes of Eq. (29), respectively. In (c), the negative frequency range for is highlighted as an example.

We observe that damping causes the effective mass to separate into real and imaginary components, as presented in Figs. 6a and  6b, respectively, and still displays negativity over certain frequency ranges. In Fig. 6a, regardless of the damping intensity, the value of the real component of the effective mass converges to that of the static mass as . As expected, the imaginary component of the effective mass (Fig. 6b) is zero under the same condition. In Figs. 6a and  6b, the dashed vertical lines are the asymptotes of, respectively, the real and imaginary components of the normalized effective mass obtained by setting the denominator of Eq. (29) equal to zero and solving for the frequency for the chosen value of . In the undamped case, this marks the bifurcation experiences as the wave frequency crosses the resonance frequency from below (in the band gap, switches to ), but such a correlation cannot be made in the presence of damping. As seen in Fig. 5, overdamping causes portions of the band structure to collapse to (even far from the long wavelength limit). Consequently, in the frequency dependent diagram of Fig. 6a, converges to at one instance of (long wavelength limit) but tends toward another value at a separate instance of (effect of damping). We also observe that at high damping, there are no longer any frequencies in which the effective mass is only negative. Although the closure of the frequency region of negative effective mass may be difficult to distinguish for some damping scenarios in Fig. 6a, the effect is made clear in Fig. 6c.

The metamaterial considered in our model relies on a massive internal resonator to produce a negative effective mass. In Fig. 6c, we illustrate the importance of the internal resonator by varying , which has the effect of changing the mass of while keeping all other material parameters constant. The solid curves in Fig. 6c are produced by setting Eq. (29) equal to zero and solving for the complex . The frequency at which the effective mass becomes zero marks the frequency at which there is a sign change in the value of the effective mass for both the real and imaginary components. The dashed curves in Fig. 6c represent the asymptotes and are the result of setting the denominator of Eq. (29) equal to zero and solving for the complex . These two curves bound the frequency ranges where . When , that is, when , the effect of the internal resonator diminishes and the identity of our metamaterial becomes ambiguous as it approaches the dynamic behavior of an ordinary phononic crystal. Consequently, in Fig. 6c, as loses influence, the frequency region over which the effective mass is negative shrinks to near nonexistence.

V Conclusions

In this work, we investigated the notion that damped free waves are in principle governed by a dispersion relation in which both the frequency and the wavenumber are generally complex, not only one or the other being complex as commonly assumed. An algorithm based on a formulation, guided by first solving the problem, was presented for 1D periodic chains. The algorithm was applied to a mass-in-mass unit cell representing a viscously damped locally resonant acoustic/elastic metamaterial. This analysis allows one to examine the effects of damping not only on the propagating modes of free waves, but also on the evanescent modes. For both mode sets, the effects of damping appear in both the frequency and the damping ratio band diagrams. A dynamic effective mass for the damped metamaterial model was also calculated and was shown to exhibit negative values over a frequency region near the band gap, as in the undamped case. However, for relatively high levels of damping, no frequencies are found in which the effective mass is only negative. Future work will explore multi-dimensional systems and the effects of other types of damping, e.g., nonviscous damping, in the context of the generalized, all-complex Bloch formulation presented in this paper.

Vi Acknowledgment

This research has been supported by the National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship Grant No. DGE 1144083 and CAREER Grant No. 1254931. Support was also provided by the Department of Education GAANN program.


  • (1) D. J. Mead, “Wave propagation in continuous periodic structures: Research contributions from Southampton, 1964–-1995,” Journal of Sound and Vibration, vol. 190, pp. 495–524, February 1996.
  • (2) M. I. Hussein, M. J. Leamy, and M. Ruzzene, “Dynamics of phononic materials and structures: Historical origins, recent progress, and future outlook,” Applied Mechanics Reviews, vol. 66, p. 040802, May 2014.
  • (3) P. A. Deymier, ed., Acoustic Metamaterials and Phononic Crystals. Heidelberg: Springer, 2013.
  • (4) A. Khelif and A. Adibi, eds., Phononic Crystals: Fundamentals and Applications. New York: Springer, 2015.
  • (5) V. Laude, Phononic Crystals: Artifical Crystals for Sonic, Acoustic and Elastic Waves. Berlin: De Gruyter, 2015.
  • (6) M. M. Sigalas and E. N. Economou, “Elastic and acoustic wave band structure,” Journal of Sound and Vibration, vol. 158, pp. 377–382, October 1992.
  • (7) M. S. Kushwaha, P. Halevi, L. Dobrzynski, and B. Djafari-Rouhani, “Acoustic band structure of periodic elastic composites,” Physical Review Letters, vol. 71, pp. 2022–2025, September 1993.
  • (8) Z. Liu, X. Zhang, Y. Mao, Y. Y. Zhu, Z. Yang, C. T. Chan, and P. Sheng, “Locally resonant sonic materials,” Science, vol. 289, pp. 1734–1736, September 2000.
  • (9) Z. Y. Liu, C. T. Chan, and P. Sheng, “Three-component elastic wave band-gap material,” Physical Review B, vol. 65, p. 165116, 2002.
  • (10) G. Wang, X. S. Wen, J. H. Wen, L. H. Shao, and Y. Z. Liu, “Two-dimensional locally resonant phononic crystals with binary structures,” Physical Review Letters, vol. 93, p. 154302, 2004.
  • (11) Y. Pennec, B. Djafari-Rouhani, H. Larabi, J. O. Vasseur, and A.-C. Ladky-Hennion, “Low-frequency gaps in a phononic crystal constituted of cylindrical dots deposited on a thin homogeneous plate,” Physical Review B, vol. 78, p. 104105, 2008.
  • (12) T. T. Wu, T. C. Huang, Z. G. Tsai, and T. C. Wu, “Evidence of complete band gap and resonances in a plate with periodic stubbed surface,” Applied Physics Letters, vol. 93, p. 111902, 2008.
  • (13) J. Li and C. T. Chan, “Double-negative acoustic metamaterial,” Physical Review E, vol. 70, p. 055602, November 2004.
  • (14) Y. Ding, Z. Liu, C. Qiu, and J. Shi, “Metamaterial with simultaneously negative bulk modulus and mass density,” Physical Review Letters, vol. 99, p. 093904, August 2007.
  • (15) X. Ao and C. T. Chan, “Negative group velocity from resonances in two-dimensional phononic crystals,” Waves in Random and Complex Media, vol. 20, pp. 276–288, March 2010.
  • (16) X. N. Liu, G. K. Hu, G. L. Huang, and C. T. Sun, “An elastic metamaterial with simultaneously negative mass density and bulk modulus,” Applied Physics Letters, vol. 98, p. 251907, June 2011.
  • (17) M. I. Hussein and M. J. Frazier, “Metadamping: An emergent phenomenon in dissipative metamaterials,” Journal of Sound and Vibration, vol. 332, pp. 4767–4774, September 2013.
  • (18) I. Antoniadis, D. Chronopoulos, V. Spitas, and D. Koulocheris, “Hyper-damping properties of a stiff and stable linear oscillator with a negative stiffness element,” Journal of Sound and Vibration, vol. 346, pp. 37–52, 2015.
  • (19) Y. Y. Chen, M. V. Barnhart, J. K. Chen, G. K. Hu, C. Sun, and G. L. Huang, “Dissipative elastic metamaterials for broadband wave mitigation at subwavelength scale,” Composite Structures, vol. 136, pp. 358–371, 2016.
  • (20) B. L. Davis and M. I. Hussein, “Nanophononic metamaterial: Thermal conductivity reduction by local resonance,” Physical Review Letters, vol. 112, p. 055505, 2014.
  • (21) J. W. S. Rayleigh, The Theory of Sound, vol. 1. London: Macmillan and Co., 1877.
  • (22) T. K. Caughey and M. E. J. O’Kelly, “Classical normal modes in damped linear dynamic systems,” Journal of Applied Mechanics – Transactions of the ASME, vol. 32, pp. 583–588, September 1965.
  • (23) S. Adhikari, “Damping modelling using generalized proportional damping,” Journal of Sound and Vibration, vol. 293, pp. 156–170, September 2005.
  • (24) S. Adhikari and A. S. Phani, “Experimental identification of generalized proportional viscous damping matrix,” Journal of Vibration and Acoustics, vol. 131, p. 011008, January 2009.
  • (25) J. Woodhouse, “Linear damping models for structural vibration,” Journal of Sound and Vibration, vol. 215, pp. 547–569, August 1998.
  • (26) S. Adhikari and J. Woodhouse, “Identification of Damping: Part 1, Viscous Damping,” Journal of Sound and Vibration, vol. 243, pp. 43–61, May 2001.
  • (27) A. S. Phani and J. Woodhouse, “Viscous damping identification in linear vibration,” Journal of Sound and Vibration, vol. 303, pp. 475–500, June 2007.
  • (28) E. Tassilly, “Propagation of bending waves in a periodic beam,” International Journal of Engineering Science, vol. 25, pp. 85–94, 1987.
  • (29) R. S. Langley, “On the forced response of one-dimensional periodic structures: Vibration localization by damping,” Journal of Sound and Vibration, vol. 178, pp. 411–428, December 1994.
  • (30) V. Laude, Y. Achaoui, S. Benchabane, and A. Khelif, “Evanescent Bloch waves and the complex band structure of phononic crystals,” Physical Review B, vol. 80, p. 092301, September 2009.
  • (31) V. Romero-García, J. V. Sánchez-Pérez, and L. M. Garcia-Raffi, “Propagating and evanescent properties of double-point defects in sonic crystals,” New Journal of Physics, vol. 12, p. 083024, August 2010.
  • (32) R. P. Moiseyenko and V. Laude, “Material loss influence on the complex band structure and group velocity in phononic crystals,” Physical Review B, vol. 83, p. 064301, February 2011.
  • (33) E. Andreassen and J. S. Jensen, “Analysis of phononic bandgap structures with dissipation,” Journal of Vibration and Acoustics, vol. 135, p. 041015, June 2013.
  • (34) D. J. Mead, “A general theory of harmonic wave propagation in linear periodic systems with multiple coupling,” Journal of Sound and Vibration, vol. 27, pp. 235–260, March 1973.
  • (35) F. Farzbod and M. J. Leamy, “Analysis of Bloch’s method in structures with energy dissipation,” Journal of Vibration and Acoustics, vol. 133, p. 051010, September 2011.
  • (36) M. Collet, M. Ouisse, M. Ruzzene, and M. N. Ichchou, “Floquet-Bloch decomposition for the computation of dispersion of two-dimensional periodic, damped mechanical systems,” International Journal of Solids and Structures, vol. 48, pp. 2837–2848, October 2011.
  • (37) S. Mukherjee and E. H. Lee, “Dispersion relations and mode shapes for waves in laminated viscoelastic composites by finite difference methods,” Computers & Structures, vol. 5, pp. 279–285, December 1975.
  • (38) R. Sprik and G. H. Wegdam, “Acoustic band gaps in composites of solids and viscous liquids,” Solid State Communications, vol. 106, pp. 77–81, April 1998.
  • (39) M. I. Hussein, “Theory of damped Bloch waves in elastic media,” Physical Review B, vol. 80, p. 212301, December 2009.
  • (40) M. I. Hussein and M. J. Frazier, “Band structure of phononic crystals with general damping,” Journal of Applied Physics, vol. 108, p. 093506, November 2010.
  • (41) A. S. Phani and M. I. Hussein, “Analysis of damped Bloch waves by the Rayleigh perturbation method,” Journal of Vibration and Acoustics, vol. 135, p. 041014, 2013.
  • (42) J. D. Achenbach, Wave Propagation in Elastic Solids. London: North-Holland, 1999.
  • (43) B. R. Mace and E. Manconi, “Modelling wave propagation in two-dimensional structures using finite element analysis,” Journal of Sound and Vibration, vol. 318, pp. 884–902, 2008.
  • (44) E. Manconi and B. R. Mace, “Estimation of the loss factor of viscoelastic laminated panels from finite element analysis,” Journal of Sound and Vibration, vol. 329, pp. 3928–3939, 2010.
  • (45) M. I. Hussein, M. J. Frazier, and M. H. Abedinnassab, “Chapter 1: Microdynamics of Phononic Materials,” in Handbook of Micromechanics and Nanomechanics (S. Li and X.-L. Gao, eds.), Pan Stanford Publishing, May 2013.
  • (46) H. H. Huang, C. T. Sun, and G. L. Huang, “On the negative effective mass density in acoustic metamaterials,” International Journal of Engineering Science, vol. 47, pp. 610–617, April 2009.
  • (47) F. Farzbod and M. J. Leamy, “Analysis of Bloch’s method and the propagation technique in periodic structures,” Journal of Vibration and Acoustics, vol. 133, p. 031010, March 2011.
  • (48) G. W. Milton and J. R. Willis, “On modifications of Newton’s second law and linear continuum elastodynamics,” Proceedings of the Royal Society A, vol. 463, pp. 855–880, January 2007.
  • (49) S. Nemat-Nasser and A. Srivastava, “Negative effective dynamics mass-density and stiffness: Micro-architecture and phononic transport in periodic composites,” AIP Advances, vol. 1, p. 041502, 2011.
Comments 0
Request Comment
You are adding the first comment!
How to quickly get a good reply:
  • Give credit where it’s due by listing out the positive aspects of a paper before getting into which changes should be made.
  • Be specific in your critique, and provide supporting evidence with appropriate references to substantiate general statements.
  • Your comment should inspire ideas to flow and help the author improves the paper.

The better we are at sharing our knowledge with each other, the faster we move forward.
The feedback must be of minimum 40 characters and the title a minimum of 5 characters
Add comment
Loading ...
This is a comment super asjknd jkasnjk adsnkj
The feedback must be of minumum 40 characters
The feedback must be of minumum 40 characters

You are asking your first question!
How to quickly get a good answer:
  • Keep your question short and to the point
  • Check for grammar or spelling errors.
  • Phrase it like a question
Test description