Diversity of chemistry and excitation conditions in the high-mass star forming complex W33
Key Words.:Stars: formation – Astrochemistry – Stars: protostars – ISM: individual objects: W33 –ISM: molecules – Submillimeter: ISM
The object W33 is a giant molecular cloud that contains star forming regions at various evolutionary stages from quiescent clumps to developed H ii regions. Since its star forming regions are located at the same distance and the primary material of the birth clouds is probably similar, we conducted a comparative chemical study to trace the chemical footprint of the different phases of evolution. We observed six clumps in W33 with the Atacama Pathfinder Experiment (APEX) telescope at 280 GHz and the Submillimeter Array (SMA) at 230 GHz. We detected 27 transitions of 10 different molecules in the APEX data and 52 transitions of 16 different molecules in the SMA data. The chemistry on scales larger than 0.2 pc, which are traced by the APEX data, becomes more complex and diverse the more evolved the star forming region is. On smaller scales traced by the SMA data, the chemical complexity and diversity increase up to the hot core stage. In the H ii region phase, the SMA spectra resemble the spectra of the protostellar phase. Either these more complex molecules are destroyed or their emission is not compact enough to be detected with the SMA. Synthetic spectra modelling of the HCO transitions, as detected with the APEX telescope, shows that both a warm and a cold component are needed to obtain a good fit to the emission for all sources except for W33 Main1. The temperatures and column densities of the two components increase during the evolution of the star forming regions. The integrated intensity ratios NH(32)/CS(65) and NH(32)/HCO(43) show clear trends as a function of evolutionary stage, luminosity, luminosity-to-mass ratio, and H peak column density of the clumps and might be usable as chemical clocks.
Over the past decades, a commonly accepted picture of massive star formation has emerged (for recent reviews see McKee & Ostriker, 2007; Zinnecker & Yorke, 2007; Beuther et al., 2007; Tan et al., 2014). The earliest stage is the gravitational collapse of a cold dark cloud, which forms a prestellar core of size 0.03–0.2 pc (Bergin & Tafalla, 2007). The prestellar core contracts further and a protostar emerges. With time, the protostar heats the surrounding material and a molecular hot core
Studying the chemical evolution of star forming regions from young infrared dark clouds (IRDCs) to evolved H ii regions yields insights into the chemical and physical processes at work during star formation. Spectral line surveys give information about the chemical composition, the temperature, the density, and the kinematical structures of the star forming material. Many spectral line surveys have been conducted over the last years, focusing on either complete spectral coverage of a certain region like Sgr B2 (e.g. Turner, 1991; Belloche et al., 2013) or Orion-KL (e.g. Turner, 1991; Beuther et al., 2005b) or spectroscopically limited surveys of targets selected by their evolutionary stage (IRDCs, e.g. Vasyunina et al. (2014), Sanhueza et al. (2012) or hot cores, e.g. Beuther et al. (2009)). Recently, Gerner et al. (2014) conducted a 1 mm and 3 mm spectral line survey of 59 high-mass star forming regions in four different evolutionary stages from IRDCs to ultra-compact (UC) H ii regions. They found that the abundances of detected molecules tend to increase during the evolution of the star forming regions. In addition, they show that the overall detection rate of different molecules is much higher for hot cores than for UC H ii regions. However, the number of line surveys which cover different evolutionary stages in samples of high-mass star forming regions is still low and often these observed regions are not connected. They are located at different distances and originate from different giant molecular clouds (GMCs), which complicates a quantitative comparison of the detected chemical features due to different spatial scales and different initial star forming material probed.
1.1 The W33 complex
The W33 complex was first detected as a thermal radio source in the 1.4 GHz survey of Westerhout (1958). The object W33 is located in the Scutum spiral arm in the first quadrant of the Galaxy (e.g. Immer et al., 2013). Observations of the dust emission in the W33 complex made in the course of the Atacama Pathfinder Experiment (APEX) Telescope Large Area Survey of the GALaxy (ATLASGAL, Schuller et al., 2009) at 870 m show three large molecular clumps
From observations of radio recombination lines, HCO absorption, and CO emission, a peculiar velocity field was detected in the W33 complex (e.g. Gardner & Whiteoak, 1972; Gardner et al., 1975; Goldsmith & Mao, 1983). Towards W33 A and W33 Main, emission/absorption peaks were observed at a radial velocity of 36 km s while the emission/absorption was maximal at a radial velocity of 58 km s towards W33 B. However, the CO observations of Goldsmith & Mao (1983) show emission of both velocity components throughout the whole complex. Different explanations for this velocity field have been proposed. Bieging et al. (1978) suggest that W33 is a single connected star forming complex with internal motions of about 20 km s at a near-kinematic distance of 3.7 kpc (corresponding to the 36 km s velocity component). Goss et al. (1978), however, favour a superposition of two unrelated star forming regions along the line of sight. Trigonometric parallax observations of the water masers in W33 B, W33 Main, and W33 A yield distances, which are consistent with 2.4 kpc and show that W33 is one connected star forming complex (Immer et al., 2013).
At a distance of 2.4 kpc, the angular size of W33 corresponds to a physical size of 10 pc. Revising the results of Stier et al. (1984) for a distance of 2.4 kpc, the W33 complex has a total bolometric luminosity of 8 10 L. Haschick & Ho (1983) detected the radio continuum emission of a cluster of zero age main sequence stars with spectral types between O7.5 and B1.5 (revised for a distance of 2.4 kpc) in W33 Main.
Masing transitions of water and methanol have been detected in W33 A, W33 Main, and W33 B (e.g. Genzel & Downes, 1977; Jaffe et al., 1981; Menten et al., 1986; Haschick et al., 1990; Immer et al., 2013), and OH masers have been observed in W33 A and W33 B (Wynn-Williams et al., 1974; Caswell, 1998) (positions listed in Table 1). No masing transitions were observed in the clumps W33 Main1, W33 A1, and W33 B1. The methanol masers in W33 B and W33 A are radiation pumped (Class II, 6.7 GHz) while the methanol maser in W33 Main is pumped by collisions (Class I, 25 GHz; see Menten (1991) for the difference between Class I and Class II methanol masers and their different pumping). In W33 B and W33 A, the methanol, water, and hydroxyl masers are separated by less than 8 and 2, respectively. No OH and 6.7 GHz CHOH masers were detected in W33 Main.
A cluster of three infrared sources, residing in W33 Main, was detected by Dyck & Simon (1977) at 3.4–33 m. Another infrared source was observed in W33 A with deep absorption features at 3 and 10 m (Dyck & Simon, 1977; Capps et al., 1978; de Wit et al., 2010). Stier et al. (1984) conducted far-infrared observations of W33 at 40–250 m and detected four sources in the complex (W33 B, W33 B1, W33 Main, and W33 A). In the center of W33 Main, infrared emission peaks at 3.68 m and at 70500 m are observed in the Spitzer/GLIMPSE and the Herschel/Hi-GAL maps (Fig. (a)a and Fig. (b)b), respectively. The two water masers are located between these infrared peaks. To the east of W33 Main, two arcs of strong mid-infrared emission can be seen in Fig. (a)a. In the west, the mid-infrared emission forms a bubble and a 5 pc long filament. Both are visible at 70 and 160 m in the Herschel/Hi-GAL maps (Fig. (b)b) but not at longer wavelengths. Strong mid- and far-infrared emission is also detected at the center of W33 A and at the border of W33 A1 and W33 B1. Weaker and more diffuse emission is observed at the positions of W33 B and W33 Main1.
Star clusters, signs of advanced star formation in the W33 complex, are detected at the border of the W33 B1 clump, in the centers of W33 Main and W33 A, and east and west of W33 Main (Morales et al., 2013, and references therein; black Xs in Fig. 1). The coordinates of the star clusters, which are labeled SC-1 to -6, are listed in Table 1. The vicinity of the star clusters outside of W33 Main to the arc- and filament-shaped infrared emission suggests that this emission is influenced by the high-mass stars in these clusters.
Observations at radio wavelengths show W33 Main as a compact source, which is embedded in weaker and extended emission. The objects W33 A and W33 B are located at the edges of this extended emission (e.g. Wynn-Williams et al., 1981; Stier et al., 1982; Ho et al., 1986; Longmore et al., 2007). Brogan et al. (2006) observed the W33 complex and its surroundings at 330 MHz with the VLA (Fig. (c)c) to detect supernova remnants (coordinates in Table 1) in the region. Two supernova remnants are found in the north-west of the W33 complex at a distance of about 8 pc from the W33 Main clump (outside of Fig. 1). One strong radio emission peak is detected at the center of W33 Main, which is located between the infrared peaks. The object W33 Main is also the only source that shows strong emission at 5 GHz in the Co-Ordinated Radio ’N’ Infrared Survey for High-mass star formation (CORNISH) VLA survey (Hoare et al., 2012). East of W33 Main, strong radio emission at 330 MHz coincides with the arc-shaped infrared emission. Ho et al. (1986) suggested that the extended emission is an ionisation front, excited by an earlier generation of high-mass stars that penetrates the molecular material around W33 Main. They conclude that shocks from high-mass stars can compress molecular clouds on short time scales (10 yr) if these stars are not too luminous. The star cluster SC-5 could be a candidate for containing this earlier generation of stars. A comparison of the ages of SC-5 and the star cluster in W33 Main (SC-4) could provide information if the star formation in W33 Main was triggered by an earlier generation of stars. Weaker emission at 330 MHz is detected at the position of the infrared bubble and the filament, forming a bow-shaped structure around the star cluster SC-2. Diffuse emission is observed at the border of the W33 B and W33 B1 clumps. No radio emission at 330 MHz is found in the clumps W33 Main1, W33 A1, and W33 A.
The object W33 A was studied by Galván-Madrid et al. (2010) with the Submillimeter Array (SMA) at 219.3–221.3 and 229.3–231.3 GHz. They detected two dust cores, which are surrounded by parsec-scale filaments of cold molecular gas. They suggest that the star formation activity within the cores was triggered by an interaction of the filaments. Evidence for a rotating disk was found in the brighter core which is orientated perpendicular to a strong outflow. The more massive second core has a less powerful outflow and probably is in an earlier evolutionary stage than the first core.
Combining the continuum and maser information, we can sort our sources in different groups (Table 2), which mirrors their evolutionary stages. The sources are sorted along an evolutionary sequence which goes from top to bottom. In the last column, we tentatively assigned evolutionary stages to the sources that have been previously characterised in other star forming regions. In the rest of this publication, we assume that the six clumps follow similar evolutionary tracks despite their different masses and luminosities, and, thus, a comparison of the chemical composition of the different clumps along the evolutionary sequence is valid.
We observed these six molecular clumps with the APEX
The paper has the following structure. In Sect. 2, we describe the observations and complementary data sets that were analysed in this paper. In Sect. 3, we focus on the kinematics in the W33 complex. Section 4 gives dust temperatures and total masses of the studied molecular clumps. In Sects. 5 and 6, we present results from the APEX and SMA observations. In Sect. 7, we infer column densities and gas temperatures from the APEX and SMA observations for each clump. Section 8 discusses the chemical diversity in the W33 clumps. In Sect. 9, we give a short summary of our results. In the online Appendices A and B, we describe the source-specific results of our APEX and SMA observations. The online Appendix C gives a detailed description of the Weeds modelling and the obtained results.
|Source||R.A. (hh mm ss)||Dec (dd )||Object||Reference|
|W33 Main1||18 14 25.021||17 53 58.13||Molecular clump||Contreras et al. (2013); this work|
|W33 A1||18 14 36.087||17 55 04.95||Molecular clump||Contreras et al. (2013); this work|
|W33 B1||18 14 07.144||18 00 45.10||Molecular clump||Contreras et al. (2013); this work|
|W33 B||18 13 54.368||18 01 51.92||Molecular clump||Contreras et al. (2013); this work|
|W33 A||18 14 39.059||17 52 02.72||Molecular clump||Contreras et al. (2013); this work|
|W33 Main||18 14 13.531||17 55 47.47||Molecular clump||Contreras et al. (2013); this work|
|W33 B-OH||18 13 54.79||18 01 47.9||OH maser||Caswell (1998)|
|W33 A-OH||18 14 39.53||17 52 01.1||OH maser||Caswell (1998)|
|W33 B-HO||18 13 54.7457||18 01 46.588||HO maser||Immer et al. (2013)|
|W33 A-HO-a||18 14 34.4366||17 51 51.891||HO maser||Immer et al. (2013)|
|W33 A-HO-b||18 14 39.5714||17 52 00.382||HO maser||Immer et al. (2013)|
|W33 Main-HO-a||18 14 13.8283||17 55 21.035||HO maser||Immer et al. (2013)|
|W33 Main-HO-b||18 14 14.2315||17 55 40.573||HO maser||Immer et al. (2013)|
|W33 Main-CHOH||18 14 11.09||17 55 57.4||CHOH 25 GHz maser (Class I)||Menten et al. (1986)|
|W33 B-CHOH||18 13 54.75||18 01 46.6||CHOH 6.7 GHz maser (Class II)||Green et al. (2010)|
|W33 A-CHOH||18 14 39.53||17 52 00.0||CHOH 6.7 GHz maser (Class II)||Green et al. (2010)|
|SNR-1||18 13 19||17 54||Supernova remnant||Brogan et al. (2006)|
|SNR-2||18 13 37||17 49||Supernova remnant||Brogan et al. (2006)|
|SC-1||18 14 08.0||18 00 15||Star cluster||Morales et al. (2013)|
|SC-2||18 13 55.0||17 56 55||Star cluster||Morales et al. (2013)|
|SC-3||18 13 24.0||17 53 31||Star cluster||Morales et al. (2013)|
|SC-4||18 14 13.0||17 55 55||Star cluster||Morales et al. (2013)|
|SC-5||18 14 22.0||17 56 10||Star cluster||Morales et al. (2013)|
|SC-6||18 14 40.0||17 52 07||Star cluster||Morales et al. (2013)|
|W33 Main1||weak||–||–||High-mass protostellar object|
|W33 A1||weak||–||–||High-mass protostellar object|
|W33 B1||weak||–||–||High-mass protostellar object|
|W33 B||weak||–||Hot Core|
|W33 A||–||Hot Core|
|W33 Main||H ii region|
2 Observations and data reduction
2.1 Submillimeter Array data set
We observed five molecular clumps of the W33 complex (W33 Main1, W33 A1, W33 B1, W33 B, and W33 Main; see contours in Fig. 1) at 230 GHz with the SMA. The observations were taken in compact configuration in 2011 May, covering baselines from 16 to 69 k (corresponding to detected physical scales of 0.04 to 0.18 pc). The full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the primary beam is 55. The five sources were observed with hexagonal seven-pointing mosaics. The two side bands have a bandwidth of 4 GHz each and cover a frequency range of 216.9220.9 GHz (lower sideband, LSB) and 228.9232.9 GHz (upper sideband, USB). The observations have a channel spacing of 0.8125 MHz (corresponding to 1.1 km s). Table 3 lists the coordinates of the mosaic centers (Columns 2, 3) and the noise levels for the continuum and the line emission per source (Columns 5, 6).
The data reduction and analysis was conducted with the software packages
The object W33 A was previously observed with a similar setup by Galván-Madrid et al. (2010). Their observations have a slightly coarser spectral resolution than our observations of 3 km s. The data cube was cleaned with natural weighting with the MIRIAD CLEAN task, resulting in a synthesised beam of 3.9 x 2.3, which gives a slightly better spatial resolution than our data sets. However, the observations only have a bandwidth of 2 GHz per sideband. After flagging bad edge channels, the data cube covers the effective frequency ranges 219.38221.21 GHz and 229.38231.31 GHz.
In 2011 March, W33 Main was observed with the SMA in compact configuration at 345 GHz as part of a filler project. To cover the same area as our 230 GHz observations, W33 Main was observed with 23 pointings in a hexagonal mosaic. In this publication, we focus on the continuum data of these observations. The data reduction was conducted in a similar manner as for the 230 GHz data set. As amplitude, bandpass, and phase calibrators, the sources Titan, 3C279, 1733130, and 1911201 were observed. The on-source observing time of W33 Main was 1 h. The line-free and continuum-free data sets were produced by fitting a linear baseline to line-free channels in both sidebands and subtracting it from the whole data set. Then, we imaged the continuum with CASA’s interactive cleaning task. The image has an rms level of 65 mJy beam. The size of the synthesised beam is 2.9 x 1.9 with a position angle of 151.
|APEX||SMA (230 GHz)|
|(hh mm ss.ss)||(dd .)||(mK)||(mK)||(mK)||(mK)|
|W33 Main1||18 14 25.39||17 54 00.6||13||11||240||330|
|W33 A1||18 14 36.10||17 55 03.0||16||9||250||340|
|W33 B1||18 14 07.07||18 00 44.7||14||9||250||330|
|W33 B||18 13 54.33||18 01 51.7||26||18||240||310|
|W33 A||18 14 39.00||17 52 05.0||35||13||150||110|
|W33 Main||18 14 13.72||17 55 43.6||31||126||260||350|
2.2 Atacama Pathfinder Experiment telescope data set
On-the-fly (OTF) maps of the
six molecular clumps W33 Main1, W33 A1, W33 B1, W33 B, W33 A, and W33 Main
were observed at 280 GHz at the APEX telescope with the FLASH receiver and the facility Fast Fourier Transform Spectrometer (FFTS). The covered area is 1.8 x 1.8. The full width at half maximum (FWHM) of the beam is 23. The observations have two sidebands with a bandwidth of 4 GHz each,
centered at 280.2 GHz and 292.2 GHz, and a smoothed spectral resolution of 1.6 km s (to obtain a higher signal-to-noise ratio).
The calibrated data set was analysed with the software CLASS
2.3 Institut de Radioastronomie Millimétrique 30m telescope data set
To obtain zero-spacing information for the SMA CO and CO observations of W33 Main, the molecular clump was observed with the HERA instrument at the Institut de Radioastronomie Millimétrique (IRAM) 30m telescope using the new FFTS backend in 2012 February. The observations were centered on the (21) transitions of the CO isotopologues CO and CO at 220.398 and 219.56 GHz, respectively. On-the-fly maps were taken in the frequency-switching mode, covering an area of 6 x 6. The calibrated data set was further reduced and analysed with the CLASS software to obtain a continuum-free line database. First, baselines of order 7 and 3 were fitted to the line-free channels and subtracted from the data; the spectra were folded, and then again a linear baseline was fitted to the line-free channels and subtracted from the data. To combine the IRAM30m data sets with the SMA data sets, we smoothed the data to a spectral resolution of 1.2 km s and re-imaged the SMA data of CO and CO with the same spectral resolution. The SMA and IRAM30m data cubes were combined in the image plane with the CASA task feather.
2.4 Additional data sets
|Survey||Telescope/Instrument||Wavelength [m]||Resolution ||Sensitivity|
|MSX||MSX||8.3||18.3||1 MJy sr|
|MSX||MSX||12.1||18.3||16 MJy sr|
|MSX||MSX||14.7||18.3||11 MJy sr|
|MSX||MSX||21.3||18.3||35 MJy sr|
||20.2 mJy beam
||45.2 mJy beam
||12.1 mJy beam
||10.0 mJy beam
||14.4 mJy beam
|ATLASGAL||APEX/LABOCA||870||19.2||4060 mJy beam|
To construct spectral energy distributions of the clumps in the W33 complex, we used observations from the Midcourse Space Experiment (MSX) survey (Price et al., 2001) at 8.3, 12.1, 14.7, and 21.3 m, the Herschel infrared Galactic plane survey (Hi-GAL, Molinari et al., 2010) at 70, 160, 250, 350, and 500 m, and the ATLASGAL survey (Schuller et al., 2009) at 870 m. The resolutions and sensitivities of the different surveys are listed in Table 4.
Additional infrared observations of the W33 complex were obtained from the Spitzer/GLIMPSE survey, which were conducted at 3.6, 4.5, 5.8, and 8.0 m with the InfraRed Array Camera (IRAC) with a resolution of < 2.
To look for supernova remnants in W33, tracing a former generation of high-mass star formation, we used a 330 MHz map taken with the Very Large Array (VLA) in B, C, and D configuration by Brogan et al. (2006). The observations have a spatial resolution of 42 and an rms of 5 mJy beam.
3 Kinematics in the W33 complex
From proper motion measurements of water masers in W33 B, W33 A, and W33 Main, Immer et al. (2013) showed that W33 A is moving tangentially to W33 Main in the plane of the sky with a total speed of 17 km s. The radial velocities of W33 B and W33 Main differ by 22 km s. In the plane of the sky, W33 B moves with a velocity of 22 km s relative to W33 Main, yielding a total speed of 31 km s of W33 B relative to W33 Main.
To determine if W33 A and W33 B are gravitationally bound to W33 Main, we compare the gravitational and kinetic energies of the clumps. Using the projected distances between W33 Main and W33 A and W33 Main and W33 B, respectively, and our mass estimate for W33 Main of 3965 M (see Sect. 4), we estimate the escape speed needed to leave the gravitational field of W33 Main. For a projected distance of 5.5 pc between W33 B and W33 Main and 4.9 pc between W33 A and W33 Main, we calculate values of 2.5 and 2.6 km s for the escape speed. The total speed of W33 B and W33 A are larger than these values. We conclude that both clumps are not gravitationally bound to W33 Main and thus, the large clumps in the W33 complex drift apart with time. However, these results have to be checked carefully with better determined masses of the clumps.
4 Dust temperatures and cloud masses
To determine the dust temperatures of the six W33 clumps, we fit the spectral energy distributions (SEDs) of the clumps with two-component grey-body and black-body models. The SEDs are constructed from infrared maps of the MSX and the Herschel/Hi-GAL surveys and the submillimeter ATLASGAL map, covering a wavelength range of 8870 m. For all wavelengths, we chose the same circular aperture over which the emission was integrated. The radius of the aperture was selected to correspond to the deconvolved radius of the clumps in the ATLASGAL compact source catalog (Contreras et al., 2013, Column 2 in Table 5). To estimate the background emission at all wavelengths, we integrated the emission in apertures with a radius of 40 at 20 positions around the W33 complex. Then, we averaged these values and subtracted the background emission from the total emission of each clump at each wavelength, following formula 1 of Anderson et al. (2012). To account for the intrinsic instrument error and the source extraction uncertainties, we assumed uncertainties of 20% for flux densities at wavelengths longer than 14 m. Since the broad-bands of the MSX receivers at 8 and 12 m often show emission/absorption features due to polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, very small grains, and silicates (e.g. Churchwell et al., 2009), we increased the flux uncertainties to 50%. However, from the photometry at 14 and 20 m, it is clear that a warm component is needed to fit the short-wavelengths part of the SEDs (Fig. 2).
Thus, the generated SEDs are fitted with a “cold” plus a “warm” component. The detection of two temperature components suggests that all six clumps have a heating source inside or nearby. The cold and the warm components were then fitted with a two-component model, fitting a grey-body and a black body simultaneously. From the fits, we determine the bolometric luminosities, the warm and cold temperatures of the clumps, and the spectral emissivity index . The uncertainties of the fitting parameters are calculated from the covariance matrix, which is returned from the Levenberg-Marquardt fitting algorithm. The SED fits are shown in Fig. 2. The cold temperatures and luminosities are listed in Table 5 (Columns 67). The cold temperatures range between 25 and 43 K with the highest values of T being estimated for W33 Main and W33 B1. While the temperatures of both components are similar for all sources, the luminosity covers a wide range of values from 6 10 L in W33 A1 to 4.5 10 L in W33 Main. The total bolometric luminosity of the W33 complex is 5.5 10 L which is only slightly smaller than the revised value (8 10 L) of Stier et al. (1984). The spectral emissivity index quantifies the frequency-dependence of the emissivity in the Rayleigh-Jeans part of the spectrum (Dent et al., 1998). This parameter ranges from 1.2 to 1.9 and shows no clear trend with the evolutionary stage of the clump.
The masses and column densities estimated for the warm component have large uncertainties and their contribution to the total masses and column densities is only a couple percent, compared to the cold component. We thus neglected its contribution in the following calculations. Assuming no temperature gradient, the total mass of a clump is given by
In both formulas, is the grain size normalisation constant, the grain mass density, the gas-to-dust ratio, the flux density at 345 GHz integrated over the whole clump, the distance, the frequency of the observations (345 GHz), the spectral emissivity index, and the source solid angle at 345 GHz. These calculations correspond to a mass absorption coefficient of 0.852 ( = 1.8) 2.296 cm g ( = 1.2) at 870 m, depending on the value of the spectral emissivity index . The peak column density was estimated by substituting F with the peak flux density of each clump and with the beam solid angle of the APEX telescope at 870 m. To derive the molecular abundances in Sect. 7, we have to estimate the H column densities from the same area as the column densities of the APEX data, which are averaged over an area of 24 x 24. Thus, we integrated the flux density over this area and replaced with the solid angle of this area.
To determine the flux densities of the sources at 870 m, we integrated the continuum emission of each clump down to the 5 level (=0.35 Jy beam). The area over which the emission was integrated was then translated into the source solid angle and an equivalent radius r for each clump. For the gas-to-dust ratio, the grain size normalisation constant, and the grain mass density, we assumed typical values of 100, 0.1 m, and 3 g cm, respectively (e.g. Hildebrand, 1983; Kauffmann et al., 2008). The distance to the W33 complex is 2.4 kpc (Immer et al., 2013). Table 5 lists the source names (Column 1), the aperture radii (Column 2), equivalent radii (Column 3), the peak flux densities at 870 m (Column 4), the integrated flux densities at 870 m over an area of 24 x 24 (Column 5) and the whole source (Column 6), the dust temperatures of the cold component (Column 7), the luminosities of the clumps (Column 8), the spectral emissivity index (Column 9), the total masses of the clumps (Column 10), the peak column densities (Column 11), and the column densities averaged over an area of 24 x 24 around the peak position of each clump (Column 12) and over the whole source (Column 13). For the uncertainties of the flux densities integrated over an area of 24 x 24 and the whole source, and the peak flux densities, we assume a value of 15%.
|()/(pc)||()/(pc)||(Jy)||(Jy)||(Jy)||(K)||(10 L)||(10 M)||(10 cm)||(10 cm)||(10 cm)|
|W33 Main1||58/0.7||53/0.6||3.4||4.0||21.3||28.6 5.6||11||1.4 0.5||0.5 0.3||0.9 0.2||0.7 0.2||2.4 0.7|
|W33 A1||40/0.5||32/0.4||3.2||3.9||8.6||25.0 7.3||6||1.8 0.9||0.4 0.5||1.7 0.6||1.2 0.4||5.4 2.3|
|W33 B1||49/0.6||48/0.6||3.1||3.4||14.8||38.6 11.4||16||1.3 0.5||0.2 0.1||0.5 0.2||0.4 0.1||1.2 0.5|
|W33 B||75/0.9||86/1.0||5.4||6.6||60.7||26.5 3.9||22||1.6 0.4||1.9 1.1||2.1 0.5||1.6 0.4||3.7 0.9|
|W33 A||82/1.0||128/1.5||9.2||11.2||153.4||28.6 5.3||41||1.4 0.5||3.4 2.3||2.5 0.6||2.0 0.6||3.0 0.9|
||42.5 12.6||449||1.2 0.4||4.0 2.5||4.6 1.6||3.6 1.4||3.8 1.5|
Since W33 Main contains an H ii region, part of the emission at 345 GHz possibly originates in free-free emission. To approximate this fraction, we first obtained an estimate of the radio flux density of W33 Main. Summing the emission of compact components in W33 Main detected by Haschick & Ho (1983) yields a flux density of 23.9 Jy at 14.7 GHz. Assuming a typical spectral index of = 0.1 between 14.7 and 345 GHz, we estimate a flux density of 18 Jy at 345 GHz, originating from free-free emission, which corresponds to 5% of the total flux density at 345 GHz.
The total masses of the clumps range from 195 M for W33 B1 to 3965 M for W33 Main, yielding a total mass of the W33 complex of 10200 M. Overall, the sources follow the trend of increasing luminosity with increasing total mass except W33 B1, which shows a comparably small total mass that can partly be explained by the higher dust temperature. The source-averaged column densities range between 1.2 and 5.4 10 cm but do not show a trend with the evolutionary state of the clump, which indicates that we probe similar material in the sources as was also recently seen in Hoq et al. (2013). However, the peak column density is correlated with the evolutionary stage of the targets, being largest in the most evolved source W33 Main. Thus, the substructure with the highest peak column density is formed from the most massive clump. In addition, the most massive clump (W33 Main) cannot have formed very late compared to the other clumps since it is the most evolved source in the sample.
Kauffmann & Pillai (2010) recently proposed an empirical limit for high-mass star formation in molecular clumps, comparing the total mass of the clump with its radius :
Inserting the total mass and the radii from Table 5 in this formula, we conclude that all W33 clumps fulfill this criterion within the mass uncertainties and thus, in principle, have the potential to form high-mass stars.
5 Results of the APEX observations
The spectral lines in the APEX spectra (Figs. 3 and 4) were identified, using the Cologne Database for Molecular Spectroscopy catalog (CDMS, Müller et al., 2001), the Jet Propulsion Laboratory spectral line catalog (JPL, Pickett et al., 1998), and the splatalogue catalog (Remijan et al., 2007). In Table 7 in the online Appendix, the rest frequency (Column 1), the transition (Column 2), and the upper energy level E (Column 3) of each detected spectral line are listed. In total, we observed 27 transitions of the ten molecules CHOH, HCS, NH, OCS, HCO, HCO, HCN, CHCCH, CS, and CS. The upper energy levels E of these transitions range between 27 and 241 K. All detected spectral lines show Gaussian line profiles. We fitted them with single Gaussians to obtain the velocity integrated intensity F, the peak intensity F, the central velocity v, and the FWHM of each line in each source. The fitting results are shown in Table 7. We made moment 0 maps of each line in each source (Figs. 13 18 in the online appendix) to study the distribution of the line emission over the entire OTF maps and compare them to the location of the ATLASGAL continuum peaks at 870 m. The spectra and moment maps of the W33 sources are discussed in detail in online Appendix A. In the next paragraph, we will summarize the source-specific APEX results. In some of the APEX spectra, absorption features are present (see for example the spectra of W33 A1 in Fig. 3). These are not “real” features but are caused by poorly calibrated atmospheric absorption. We marked the atmospheric bands within our frequency range in the spectra of Figs. 3 and 4.
The transitions NH(32), HCO(43), HCO(43), HCO(43), HCO(43) and HCO(43) (which are blended), HCO(43), CHOH(6–5) and CHOH(6–5) (which are blended), CHOH(65), and CS(65) are detected in all sources. CS and NH trace cold and dense gas in the clumps. The strongest lines in all sources are the two low-excitation transitions of HCO at 35 and 46 K, NH(32), and CS(65). The least number of transitions (see above) are detected in W33 Main1 (Fig. 3). The spatial distribution of the spectral line emission hints to a cold interior of W33 Main1 and possibly an external heating source in the vicinity of W33 Main1. In W33 A1 and W33 B1, two additional CHOH transitions, compared to the lines detected in W33 Main1, are observed (Fig. 3). The spatial distribution of the emission of the high-excitation lines of HCO and CHOH indicate the presence of heating sources in W33 A1 and W33 B1. The object W33 A1, however, seems to be less developed than W33 B1. Besides the molecules detected in W33 A1 and W33 B1, we observe emission from HCS, CS, and OCS in W33 B and W33 A and additionally HCN and CHCCH in W33 A (Fig. 4). The detection of transitions at higher excitation energies and stronger spectral lines compared to W33 A1 and W33 B1 suggests that W33 B and W33 A are more evolved than W33 B1 and W33 A1. The spectra of W33 Main are the most line-rich of the six sources (Fig. 4). The emission of the cold gas tracers CS and NH peaks offset the continuum emission, indicating that the gas towards the center of W33 Main is not cold anymore.
Following these results, we sort the W33 sources along an evolutionary sequence: W33 Main1, W33 A1, W33 B1, W33 B, W33 A, and W33 Main. The more evolved sources emit transitions with higher excitation energies, which indicate that the temperature in our sources increases along this sequence. Furthermore, the detected lines tend to get stronger and broader along this sequence. Sanhueza et al. (2012) showed that the median values of the NH line widths for their four classes of objects increases from 2.7 to 3.4 km s along their established evolutionary sequence from IRDCs to H ii regions (also seen in Sakai et al., 2008; Vasyunina et al., 2011) due to the increase of turbulence during the star formation process. We see a similar trend in our observations, but the line widths of the NH transition are larger than the values of Sanhueza et al. (2012) ranging from 4.7 to 6.4 km s compared to 1.6 to 4.6 km s in the observations of Sanhueza et al. (2012).
Chemical clocks in the APEX data?
A total of 11 transitions of the molecules NH, CS, HCO, and CHOH are observed in all six W33 clumps. While the detection of single transitions does not yield information about the evolutionary state of a clump, abundance or integrated intensity ratios of molecules (e.g. SiO/CS, HCN/NH, or NH/NH, Fuente et al., 2005; Palau et al., 2007) have proven to be usable as “chemical clocks” for evolutionary stages. Since the emission of the above mentioned molecules has a similar spatial distribution in each of the six clumps, a comparison of the integrated intensity of the different transitions is reasonable. To test if a combination of the above mentioned molecules could be used as a tracer of evolutionary state, we calculated the integrated intensity ratios of all combinations of transitions that are detected towards all W33 clumps and checked their correlations with the evolutionary sequence that we established.
We found clear trends as a function of evolutionary stage in the ratios NH(32)/CS(65) and NH(32)/HCO(43) (Fig. (a)a). The NH and CS molecules both trace cold and dense gas in the clumps while the HCO molecule is released from the dust grains, once the protostars starts to warm up the material. However, to determine if these two integrated intensity ratios can be reliably used as chemical clocks, they have to be tested on a larger sample of star forming regions in different stages of evolution.
Both integrated intensity ratios are the largest in W33 Main1. Plotting the two integrated intensity ratios against the bolometric luminosities (Fig. (b)b), the total masses (Fig. (c)c), the bolometric luminosity to total mass ratio (Fig. (d)d), and the H peak column densities (Fig. (e)e) of our six targets, we see clear trends of first increasing and then decreasing integrated intensity ratios with increasing luminosity, luminosity to mass ratio, and peak column density. Especially for sources with total clump masses 500 M, the integrated intensity ratios consistently decrease with increasing luminosity, mass, and peak column density. Comparing Fig. (a)a with Fig. (e)e shows that sources with higher peak column densities also look more chemically and physically evolved. This supports the assumption that sources with high peak column densities form stars earlier (see Section 4). The clump W33 B1 is an exception; however, its evolutionary state may be influenced by the exterior illumination from the star cluster SC-1. In spite of its low luminosity, W33 A1 appears more chemically evolved than W33 Main1 and W33 B1, which may be explained by the higher peak column density of W33 A1 and thus a faster/earlier formation of OB stars in this clump.
6 Results of the SMA observations
6.1 230 GHz continuum emission
Figure 6 shows the 230 GHz continuum emission of the six W33 sources W33 Main1, W33 A1, W33 B1, W33 B, W33 A, and W33 Main, as observed with the SMA. Except for W33 A and W33 Main, the dust cores are single-peaked (at physical scales of 0.1 pc). The object W33 B1 is the only source that is nearly circular. The other sources are elongated along one axis. The cores have sizes of about 0.1 pc. The dust emission of W33 Main shows two peaks in the main core, which has a size of about 0.25 pc. Surrounding the main core, several smaller cores with weaker emission are observed. The image of W33 A was obtained from a combination of the SMA observations in compact and very extended configuration of Galván-Madrid et al. (2010). For a better comparison with our SMA observations, the image was cleaned with natural weighting, which yields a synthesised beam size of 2.6 x 2.0. The continuum emission shows two peaks within one core. The core has a size of 0.15 pc.
The left and right panels of Fig. 7 show the continuum emission of W33 Main at 230 and 345 GHz. The contours correspond to the dust emission at 230 GHz with the same levels as in the sixth panel of Fig. 6. Several emission peaks are detected in the main core of W33 Main in the 345 GHz map. Outside of the main core, three more cores are detected at both frequencies, which we name W33 Main-North, W33 Main-West, and W33 Main-South. In the following text, we refer to the main core as W33 Main-Central.
6.2 230 GHz line emission
We generated spectra of all six cores by integrating the emission over one synthesised beam at the 230 GHz continuum peak positions (Figs. 8 and 9). In W33 Main, we obtained the spectrum at the position of the stronger peak in W33 MainCentral. We again used the CDMS, JPL, and splatalogue catalogs for the spectral line identification. The detected transitions are listed in Table 8 in the online appendix. In total, we observed 52 transitions of the 16 molecules SiO, SO, 12CO and its isotopologues 13CO and C18O; the deuterated species DCN; the dense gas tracer 13CS; the dense and hot gas tracers CH3OH, H2CO and its isotopologue H213CO, CH3CN, HNCO, OCS; and HC3N, CH3OCHO, and CH3OCH3. The detected transitions have upper energy levels Eu between 16 and 579 K. Again, the lines with a Gaussian line profile are fitted with single Gaussians to obtain the same line parameters as in Sect. 5. Moment 0 maps (Figs. 19 23 in the online appendix) were generated for all transitions. Moment 1 maps, showing a velocity gradient, are presented in Fig. 24 in the online appendix.
As described in Section 1, accretion disks and outflows are found during a certain period of the star formation process. Since the spatial resolution of our observations is too coarse to resolve the accretion disk, we are looking for outflow signatures to characterise these evolutionary stages in our sample. Furthermore, velocity gradients, detected in the moment 1 maps of the spectral emission, can give hints to rotation, infall or expansion of material (Fig. 24). Since the emission of the CO lines is the most widespread, it is affected the most by the lack of short-spacing information. Thus, the identification and interpretation of outflows and velocity gradients in the moment 0 and 1 maps of the CO lines is complicated (Fig. 25).
Comparing the SMA and the IRAM30m+SMA data of W33 Main (see Fig. 26 and the associated discussion in Online-Appendix B), we estimated the fraction of the missing flux for the CO and CO molecules due to the spatial filtering of the interferometer. We integrated the moment 0 maps in Fig. 26 over one beam at the continuum peak position of W33 Main-Central and then took the ratio of the obtained values, yielding fractions of interferometer flux to total flux of 20% and 40% for CO and CO, respectively.
In the following paragraph, we summarise the source-specific SMA results. A detailed description of the detected molecules in the W33 sources is given in online Appendix B. The object W33 Main1 is again the source with the least number of detected spectral lines (Fig. 8). The lack of spectral lines besides CO and SO transitions either indicates low temperatures in the dust core or the emission of more complex molecules is not compact enough to be detected with the SMA, which both hint to a very early evolutionary age of W33 Main1. We conclude that W33 Main1 is probably in an early protostellar phase before the protostar strongly influences the surrounding material and strong emission of primary molecules like HCO and CHOH is detected. Besides CO and SO transitions, emission of HCO and CHOH is observed in W33 A1 and W33 B1 (Fig. 8). The higher-energy transitions of these two molecules hint to the presence of heating sources in both clumps. However, since we do not see the line-richness of hot cores in these cores, we conclude that both sources are young protostellar cores. The object W33 B is one of the most line-rich sources of the six W33 cores (Fig. 9). The detection of complex molecules like CHCN, HNCO, HCCN, CHOCHO or CHOCH indicates that W33 B is in the hot core stage. In W33 A, we observe CHOH, CHOCHO, and CHOCH transitions at higher excitation energies as in W33 B (Fig. 9), indicating that W33 A is more evolved than W33 B. The variety of detected molecules (including complex molecules) and the high temperature needed for the excitation of the high-energy transitions supports the identification of W33 A as a hot core. Compared to W33 B and W33 A, the spectrum of W33 Main shows significantly fewer spectral lines (Fig. 9). The object W33 Main is the only source in our SMA sample that shows emission of the radio recombination line H30, supporting the identification of W33 Main as a more evolved object where ionised emission of H ii regions(s) is observed.
7 Gas temperatures and column densities
In this section, we determine gas temperatures and column densities of molecules for which several transitions are detected in the six W33 clumps. We first determine these parameters with the rotational temperature diagram method and then test and refine the results by constructing synthetic spectra for the molecules and comparing them with the observed spectra.
7.1 Rotational temperature diagrams and Weeds modelling
From molecules for which multiple transitions can be observed, the rotational temperature and beam-averaged column density of the molecular material can be estimated using the rotational temperature diagram (RTD) method. Assuming optically thin emission and local thermodynamic equilibrium (LTE), the observed line intensities are proportional to the level populations and the level populations are determined by a single temperature . The upper level population is given by
where is the Einstein coefficient of the transition (see the detailed description of this method in Goldsmith & Langer, 1999).
where is the statistical weight of the upper level, the partition function, and the total number column density.
Weeds is an extension of the CLASS software, which belongs to the GILDAS package (Maret et al., 2011). It is mostly written in Python. If several transitions of a given species are detected, Weeds permits the computation of a synthetic spectrum to inspect if the relative intensities of the transitions agree with a single excitation temperature. The synthesised spectrum is constructed under the assumption of LTE conditions in the gas. The advantage of Weeds compared to the rotational temperature diagram method is that the modelling directly includes opacity effects and that the synthetic spectrum can directly be compared to the observed spectrum. To compute a synthetic spectrum, the user has to provide a text file including the name of the modeled species, the column density, the kinetic temperature, source size, and line width. In the optically thin case, the column density and the source size are degenerate.
If the source size is smaller than the beam, beam dilution occurs, which affects the line intensity and thus the estimated column densities. Since the transitions of the molecules for which we determined the column densities are detected at different frequencies, the beam size of the observations changes slightly (e.g. from 21.3 to 22.2 for the APEX observations of HCO). Thus, the column densities that are determined from the synthetic spectra are beam-averaged over the smallest observed beam size per molecule (21.3 for HCO and CHOH, 21.5 for CHCCH, 5 for the SMA observations). For the transitions that are observed with a larger beam, a beam dilution factor is taken into account. A smaller beam dilution factor results in a higher column density. Thus, the estimated column densities are only lower limits.
As initial parameters for the construction of the synthetic spectra, we used the temperatures and column densities, determined from the RTD fitting. The line width was determined from the average of the FWHMs of the detected transitions. If the synthetic spectra, computed from the RTD results, did not yield a good fit of the observed spectra, we changed the temperature and column density until we reached a good fit to the strongest transitions by eye. Since the column densities from the RTD fitting have larger uncertainties than the determined temperatures, we tried to keep the input temperature for the synthetic spectrum close to the RTD temperature. Due to uncertainties in the source size and possible temperature substructures, the synthetic spectra only give an estimate of the temperature and column density of the material but do not yield a perfect fit of the observed spectra. A detailed description of the Weeds modelling of the APEX and SMA spectra of the W33 sources is given in online Appendix C.
|(K)||(10 cm)||(10)||(K)||(10 cm)|
Since we observe the HCO transitions in the APEX spectra of all six W33 sources and they span a broad range of upper energy levels from 35 to 141 K, we first calculated the level populations for these transitions from the observed integrated intensities, using equation 1 and assuming that the beam filling factor for the APEX data is unity. Then, we plotted the results in RTDs (Fig. 10). We also tried to fit the CHOH transitions in RTDs but the level populations in W33 B, W33 B1, W33 A1, and W33 A did not fall along a line in the RTDs. This indicates that either the assumption of optically thin gas or LTE does not apply for CHOH or that the CHOH emission has a temperature substructure in these sources. In the CHOH-RTD of W33 Main (Fig. (g)g), the transition at 86 K was ignored in the fitting due to the strong difference of the level population compared to the other CHOH transitions. We also generated an RTD for the CHCCH transitions detected in W33 Main and fitted the level populations (Fig. (h)h).The temperatures (Column 3) and total column densities (Column 4) are listed in Table 6.
The Weeds modelling results (Columns 5, 6 in Table 6) show that we need a cold and a warm component to fit the HCO spectral lines well for all sources except W33 Main1. In all five sources, the warm component has a higher column density than the cold component, indicating that it is excited closer to the center of the core assuming a density gradient from the outer area to the center of the core. Since we estimate high temperatures for the warm component in W33 B1, W33 B, W33 A, and W33 Main, we expect the existence of a heating source in these cores. The temperatures and column densities of both components increase from W33 Main1 to W33 Main (see Table 6), supporting the sorting of the sources along the evolutionary sequence that we established in Sects. 5 and 6.
To determine the abundances of HCO in all sources as well as CHOH and CHCCH in W33 Main, we calculated the ratio of the molecular column densities and the H column densities over an area of 24 x 24 (N; see Sect. 4, Column 5 in Table 6). The obtained abundances for HCO are consistent with other chemical studies (e.g. Vasyunina et al., 2014; Gerner et al., 2014). The CHCCH and CHOH abundances in W33 Main are similar to the values determined towards this source (Miettinen et al., 2006) and towards other star forming regions (e.g. Alakoz et al., 2000; van der Tak et al., 2000; Vasyunina et al., 2014; Gerner et al., 2014). Except for W33 B1, the HCO abundances seem to increase along the evolutionary sequence, which would support an increasing release of this molecule from the dust grains during the evolution of the star forming region. A similar trend was seen in the chemical study of Gerner et al. (2014).
In the SMA spectra, HCO is the only molecule with multiple transitions that is detected towards all sources. However, two of these three transitions are at the same upper energy level, and we decided to use the RTD method only for molecules with transitions at more than two different upper energy levels. We tried to compute synthetic spectra from one component for the HCO transitions, but it was not possible to fit all transitions well, indicating that several components are needed for the modelling or that the assumption of LTE is not valid for the HCO transitions.
In W33 B, we detect multiple transitions of CHOH, HNCO, and CHCN, and we applied the RTD method for these lines. Figure 11 shows the spectrum of the K = 0…7 CHCN(1211) ladder in W33 B. The K = 0 and K = 1 transitions are blended together, and K = 6 and 7 are blended with emission from other lines. Since the K-transitions are so close in frequency, they can be fitted simultaneously. We assume that the K-components have the same line width. To estimate the line width, we first fitted the K-components 2, 3, 4, and 5 with Gaussian line profiles, yielding a line width of 7.0 0.5 km s. We then fitted all lines with Gaussian line profiles with fixed frequency spacings and a line width of 7 km s (see Fig. 11). The integrated intensities of the CHCN transitions are used to calculate the level populations of the different transitions, which are then plotted in an RTD (Fig. 12). The least-squares fit to the level populations yields a rotational temperature of 335 65 K and a CHCN column density of 8.3 1.2 10 cm.
The RTDs of CHOH and HNCO are also shown in Fig. 12. The rotational temperature and column density of HNCO are similar to the values of CHCN. The RTD of CHOH yields a rotational temperature that is much lower than for HNCO. However, the CHOH-RTD shows that a line is not a good fit to the level populations, especially for transitions at lower excitation energies, indicating that either the emission is not optically thin, the CHOH gas has a temperature substructure, or the assumption of LTE does not apply. In the optically thick case, the rotational temperature is overestimated, and the column density underestimated. If the emission is optically thin and the gas has a temperature substructure, the line intensities and, thus, the column densities might be affected by beam dilution and beam filling factors have to be applied (see discussion in Sect. 7.1). The synthetic spectrum of the CHOH transitions shows that at least two components are necessary to fit the observed spectrum. However, we do not find two combinations of temperatures and column densities that fit all transitions well. Since the opacities of the synthesised spectra are consistent with optically thin emission, the bad fits indicate that the CHOH gas has a more complex temperature substructure or is not in LTE. Comparing the RTD results for the APEX and SMA observations of W33 B, it is clear that the SMA observations trace a hotter and denser region in the source than the APEX data.
Galván-Madrid et al. (2010) produced an RTD of CHCN for W33 A, yielding a rotational temperature of 410 K and a column density of 3.4 10 cm. Although the rotational temperatures of W33 B and W33 A are comparable within the errors, the column density of CHCN in W33 A is a factor of 40 larger than the column density of CHCN in W33 B, which might be explained by a disk-like accretion flow in W33 A, revealed by subarcsecond resolution observations (Galván-Madrid et al., 2010).
8 Chemical diversity in the W33 complex
Studying the chemistry of high-mass star forming regions in a single star forming complex like W33 has several advantages. Since all star forming regions belong to the same complex and probably evolved from the same giant molecular cloud, the primary material of the birth clouds is similar (w.r.t. metallicity or initial abundance ratios, for example). Furthermore, the star forming regions are at very similar distances. Thus, the observations of each telescope cover the same spatial scales which makes the observations per telescope directly comparable for the different star forming regions within the complex. In addition, missing short spacings in the SMA observations have a similar effect on the data of all star forming regions, assuming the line emission is similarly extended in all the sources.
Due to the different resolutions and the filtering of the interferometer data, the APEX and SMA data sets are sensitive to different physical scales (APEX: > 0.2 pc, SMA: 0.050.2 pc). The APEX observations are sensitive to all the emission from the clump. However, if the emitting gas is confined to a small region, and, thus, the emission is very compact, the large APEX beam dilutes the emission and depending on the strength of the signal compared to the noise level of the observations the emission might be undetected. The SMA observations on the contrary are only sensitive to compact emission while the more extended emission is resolved out. Thus, with these two data sets, we are able to trace the chemical composition on different scales in the star forming regions.
In W33, the molecular clumps cover a range of bolometric luminosities from 6445 10 L, and they seem to be in different evolutionary stages of star formation. Thus, we can compare the observations for different bolometric luminosities and along an evolutionary sequence. We first discuss each of the W33 sources and then draw conclusions about the change of chemistry along the detected evolutionary sequence.
8.1 Single sources
W33 Main1 seems to be in a very early stage of star formation. On larger scales (> 0.2 pc), traced by the APEX data, transitions from HCO and CHOH up to an upper energy level of 141 K are detected. The Weeds modelling showed that only a “cold” component of 40 K is needed to fit the HCO transitions. However, HCO and CHOH are not detected on smaller scales, traced by the SMA data. Either the medium is too cold and the molecules are not released yet into the gas phase, or the emission is too diffuse to be detected with the SMA interferometer. If a heating source is present in W33 Main1, this suggests that it does not strongly influence the chemistry yet. The lack of molecules other than CO (and its isotopologues) and SO suggests that W33 Main1 is in the collapse phase during the formation of a protostar.
The object W33 A1 is the source with the lowest luminosity in our sample. The chemistry on larger scales looks similar to W33 Main1 except that two more CHOH transitions are observed. On smaller scales, we observe low-energy transitions of HCO and CHOH, indicating the presence of a heating source which evaporates these molecules off the dust grains. The necessity of a second warmer component in the LTE modelling supports the existence of a heating source in W33 A1. We also observe emission of the DCN molecule, which is a tracer of cold and dense gas. Although W33 A1 is a factor of two less luminous than W33 Main1, it is probably more evolved. We conclude that W33 A1 is in the protostellar phase but before the excitation of a hot core.
The object W33 B1 is the clump with the lowest mass in our sample. The APEX and SMA spectra of W33 B1 look very similar to the spectra of W33 A1 but the HCO gas in W33 B1 seems to have a slightly higher temperature and column density than in W33 A1. While the average temperature of W33 B1 measured by the dust SED is consistent with that of the most evolved region W33 Main (see Section 4), W33 B1 shows yet weak emission of hot core tracers, which may imply the dominant heating by the exterior star cluster rather than the (proto)stars embedded in this clump. Although the bolometric luminosity of W33 B1 is a factor of three larger than the luminosity of W33 A1, there are no obvious differences in the SMA or APEX observations between these two sources, except that the detected lines tend to be stronger and broader in W33 B1. We conclude that W33 B1 is also in the protostellar phase before the excitation of a hot core.
Observations of water, methanol, and hydroxyl masers in W33 B indicate that high-mass stars are forming in this clump. However, the APEX spectra of W33 B are comparable to the spectra of W33 B1 or W33 A1, except that we additionally observe transitions of OCS, HCS, and CS. The compactness of the OCS emission and the high energy needed to excite the detected transition suggest that the emission is excited closer to the forming star at temperatures that are higher than the temperatures traced by HCO and CHOH. The LTE modelling of the APEX data of W33 B shows that column density and temperature of the envelope are higher than for the previous sources with the temperature of the warm component reaching 100 K.
On smaller scales, W33 B shows a forest of lines. Especially, nitrogen-bearing molecules like HNCO, CHCN or HCN are detected in the SMA spectra, indicating that W33 B is already in the hot core phase. However, from more complex molecules, only one transition of CHOCHO and one of CHOCH are observed. Other complex molecules like CHCHCN, CHCHCN, or CHOH, as seen in typical hot cores like Orion-KL, G29.960.02, G33.92+0.11 or W49A (e.g. Beuther et al., 2009; Liu et al., 2012; Galván-Madrid et al., 2013) are not detected in W33 B.
The temperatures and column densities of W33 B on smaller scales, inferred from LTE modelling of the SMA data, are much higher than on larger scales, as deduced from the APEX data, indicating temperature and column density gradients in W33 B.
As in W33 B, methanol, water, and hydroxyl masers are detected in W33 A indicating that high-mass star formation is taking place in this clump. The high-energy transitions of HCN and CHCCH in the APEX data of W33 A reveal that more complex molecules are detected on larger scales. The LTE modelling shows that the temperatures of the two components are comparable to the temperatures in W33 B, but the column densities are a factor of three higher. In the SMA spectra, many transitions of a large number of simple and complex molecules are detected with evidence for W33 A being in the hot core phase. Compared to W33 B, several transitions of complex molecules like CHOCHO and CHOCH are observed. As in Gerner et al. (2014), CHOCHO is only detected in the hot core phase. However, also the spectra of W33 A lack emission of complex molecules that are observed in typical hot cores. Although W33 A and W33 B have very similar masses, W33 A is twice as luminous as W33 B. The object W33 A is probably more evolved than W33 B. Radio continuum observations of W33 A by Rengarajan & Ho (1996) and van der Tak & Menten (2005) with the VLA suggest that the faint emission either comes from an ionised wind or a hypercompact H ii region in W33 A. This is evidence for W33 A being more evolved than W33 B, perhaps in transition from the pure hot core phase to the more evolved H ii region phase.
The object W33 Main is the only source in the W33 complex that shows strong radio emission, indicating that this source is in the H ii region phase. Water and Class I methanol masers are observed in W33 Main. The mass and luminosity of W33 Main are a factor of three and ten higher than for W33 A, respectively. The APEX spectra of W33 Main are similar to the spectra of W33 A, except that we detect higher-energy transitions of CHCCH and emission of CS and HCO. In addition, the column density of the HCO gas is highest in W33 Main. However, at smaller scales, we do not detect emission of complex molecules such as in the hot core sources anymore. The SMA spectra of W33 Main are similar to the spectra of W33 A1 and W33 B1 plus emission of HCN and the radio recombination line H30, which traces ionised gas. The molecule HCN is the only complex molecule that is detected in W33 Main and it peaks at the edge of W33 Main-Central. Other complex molecules like CHCN, CHOCHO or CHOCH are either destroyed close to the heating source or their emission is extended without compact peaks and thus resolved out by the interferometer observations. We conclude that W33 Main is already in the H ii region phase.
8.2 Chemical complexity – evolutionary sequence
From our SMA and APEX observations, we infer an evolutionary sequence of star formation in W33. We sort the sources in different groups:
Early Protostellar Phase (W33 Main1): Cold interior that is probably still contracting with no strong heating source yet
Protostellar Phase (W33 A1, W33 B1): Heating source starts to warm up the surrounding material, releasing primary molecules from dust grains into gas phase
Hot Cores (W33 B, W33 A): Heating source strongly influences the chemistry of the surrounding material with release of primary molecules from dust grains and synthesis of complex secondary molecules in gas phase
H ii regions (W33 Main): Heating source ionises the surrounding material, strong radio emission is detectable, and complex molecules are probably dissociated
Our observations show that the chemistry changes dramatically along this evolutionary sequence, especially on smaller spatial scales. The detected transitions tend to get stronger and broader along this sequence in both the SMA and APEX data sets. The trend of increasing detection rates for different molecules up to the hot core stage and then decreasing detection rates in the H ii region phase is also seen in the IRAM 30m line survey of Gerner et al. (2014).
Our SMA observations suggest that emission of CO and its isotopologues dominates in early phases of star formation. Once a heating source is present, HCO and CHOH are evaporated off dust grains. When the temperature in the core rises, more complex molecules are evaporated off the dust grains or synthesised in the gas phase. Once an H ii region emerges, the more complex molecules seem to be destroyed by the ionisation or their emission is too diffuse to be detected by the interferometer. On larger scales, traced by the APEX observations, the chemical diversity and complexity increases with the evolution of the star forming region and complex molecules are still detected in the H ii region phase. Bisschop et al. (2007) observed a set of complex molecules in seven different hot cores and showed that the molecules can be classified as either “hot” (e.g. CHOH, HCO, CHCN, …, T > 100 K) or “cold” (e.g. CHCHO, T < 100 K), depending on their rotational temperatures. Our APEX and SMA observations of the hot cores W33 B and W33 A support these results for the molecules HCO, CHOH, HNCO, and CHCN. Bisschop et al. (2007) concluded that both types of molecules are probably formed on dust grains, but the cold molecules tend to be dissociated at higher temperatures. Furthermore, CHCCH abundances are well-modeled with gas-phase chemistry only (Bisschop et al., 2007), supporting the identification of this molecule as a tracer for more evolved stages as seen in our APEX observations.
We show the importance of combining spectral information on different scales. While the APEX data show emission of more complex molecules for more evolved star forming regions, the SMA spectra show an increase in chemical complexity up to the hot core stage but then a decrease in detected molecules in the H ii region phase. Thus, the sources W33 B and W33 Main would probably have been classified differently if only one of the data sets would have been considered.
Infrared, submillimeter, and radio continuum and maser observations of the high-mass star forming complex W33 show that it contains star forming regions at different stages of formation from quiescent clumps to developed H ii regions. The star forming regions are located at the same distance of 2.4 kpc and probably consist of similar birth material, making a comparative chemical study along the evolutionary sequence feasible. We conducted SMA and APEX observations of six molecular clumps in the W33 complex at 230 and 280 GHz, respectively. In the APEX and SMA data, 27 transitions of ten different molecules and 52 transitions of 16 different molecules, respectively, were detected from simple molecules, like CO with widespread emission, to complex molecules, like CHCCH, CHOCHO or CHOCH with compact emission. The two data sets probe different physical scales. While the APEX data are sensitive to emission on scales of > 0.2 pc, the SMA data trace compact emission on smaller scales (0.050.2 pc), allowing us to compare the chemical compositions with different resolutions. We established an evolutionary sequence for the observed clumps: W33 Main1, W33 A1/W33 B1, W33 B, W33 A, and W33 Main, where W33 Main is the most evolved clump.
We constructed SEDs for the six clumps W33 Main1, W33 A1, W33 B1, W33 B, W33 A, and W33 Main, and determined dust temperatures, bolometric luminosities, and spectral emissivity indices, and inferred the total masses of the clumps. Except for W33 B1, the sources follow the trend of increasing luminosity with increasing total mass. The H peak column density is correlated with the evolutionary stage of the six clumps, being the largest in the most evolved source W33 Main.
We plotted the integrated intensity ratios NH(32)/CS(65) and NH(32)/HCO(43) against the evolutionary state, the luminosity, the total mass, the luminosity to mass ratio, and the H peak column density of the clouds. These two ratios are the largest in W33 Main1 and decrease during the evolution of the star forming regions. With increasing luminosity and peak column density, the ratios first increase and then decrease again. Our plots indicate that sources with higher peak column densities look more chemically and physically evolved.
Generating rotational temperature diagrams and constructing synthetic spectra with the Weeds software, we estimated gas rotational temperatures, column densities, and abundances of the HCO, CHOH, and CHCCH molecules from our APEX observations and HNCO, CHCN, and CHOH from the SMA observations. The synthetic spectra of the HCO transitions required a warm and a cold component in the construction for all clumps except W33 Main1. The temperatures and column densities of the two components increase along the evolutionary sequence.
In the early protostellar phase (W33 Main1), the protostar starts to release primary molecules like HCO and CHOH from the dust grains, which are observed in the APEX spectra. However, in the SMA data, only low-excitation transitions of CO, its isotopologues, and SO are detected. Thus, the emission of the more complex molecules is probably still too diffuse to be detected by the interferometer. Once the protostar becomes more powerful, it releases more HCO and CHOH into the gas phase, whose emission can then also be detected on small scales. However, the APEX spectra of the sources in the protostellar phase (W33 A1, W33 B1) did not change significantly compared to the spectra of W33 Main1. In the hot core phase (W33 A, W33 B), the diversity and complexity of the chemical composition in the SMA spectra changes strongly. The chemistry on larger scales in the APEX spectra of W33 B and W33 A is more evolved than in the protostellar phase but does not show the chemical complexity observed on smaller scales in the SMA data. The object W33 Main is in the H ii region phase. We detected the radio recombination line H30 in W33 Main, which traces ionised gas. The SMA spectra of W33 Main are similar to the spectra of the sources in the protostellar phase, except for the detection of the radio recombination line and a transition of HCN. This indicates that the complex molecules that are observed in the hot core phase are either destroyed by the H ii region or their emission is too diffuse to be detected by the SMA. The APEX data of W33 Main show transitions of complex molecules, which indicates that the destruction of complex molecules has not reached the larger scales yet.
A study of the kinematics of the W33 complex shows that W33 A and W33 B are not gravitationally bound to W33 Main and thus, the larger clumps in the W33 complex will probably drift apart with time.
Appendix A Results of the APEX observations
W33 Main1 The detected transitions of W33 Main1 are common to all six sources and are listed in Sect. 5 (Fig. 3). The upper energy levels E of the observed transitions range from 27 to 141 K. The average central velocity is 36.4 km s and the average line width is 3.2 km s. The detection of high-energy transitions of HCO at 82 and 141 K and CHOH at 64 and 75 K hints to the existence of a heating source within or near W33 Main1. The moment 0 maps of these lines (Fig. 13) show only extended emission at the position of the continuum peak, while the peak of the line emission is located close to the edge of the maps, which point to an external rather than an internal heating source. The moment 0 maps of the two low-temperature transitions of HCO at 35 and 46 K, and the NH and the CS transitions show strong compact emission, which peaks within 6 of the continuum peak, indicating that the interior of W33 Main1 is still cold (Fig. 13).
W33 A1 and W33 B1 In W33 A1 and W33 B1 (Fig. 3), we observe the same transitions (CHOH(98) and CHOH(65), in addition to the spectral lines detected in W33 Main1). The upper energy levels E of all detected spectral lines range between 27 and 141 K. The average central velocity is 33.3 km s and 36.7 km s for W33 B1 and W33 A1, respectively. The spectral lines have an average line width of 5.4 km s and 3.9 km s in W33 B1 and W33 A1, respectively. In general, the detected spectral lines tend to be stronger and broader in W33 B1 compared to W33 A1. The peaks of the compact emission of the four strongest lines, as seen in the moment 0 maps, are located within 6 of the continuum peaks in both sources (Figs. 14 and 15). In W33 B1, the emission of the high-excitation transitions of HCO and CHOH is also compact and peaks close to the continuum peak (Fig. 15). This suggests that a heating source is present in W33 B1. The moment 0 maps of these high-temperature lines in W33 A1 show more extended emission and less isolated peaks (Fig. 14), which indicates that W33 A1 already contains a heating source but is probably less developed than W33 B1.
W33 B Besides the spectral lines detected in W33 B1 and W33 A1, we observe emission from HCS(87), CHOH(65), CHOH(34), CS(65), and OCS(2423) in W33 B (Fig. 4). The spectral lines have upper energy levels E between 27 and 175 K. The average central velocity and line width of W33 B are 55.4 km s and 5.3 km s, respectively. Although the radial velocity of W33 B differs by 20 km s from the radial velocities of the other clumps in W33, Immer et al. (2013) have shown that this clump is located at a similar distance as the other clumps. However, it is still unclear what the reason for this large radial velocity difference is. While the integrated emission of CS and the two low-excitation transitions of HCO is compact and peaks close to the continuum peak, the emission of NH is extended in south-east direction and peaks 12 east of the continuum peak (Fig. 16). The moment 0 map of HCO(43) shows extended emission in the north-south direction. The peak of the emission is offset by 12 in north-west direction from the continuum peak (Fig. 16). The integrated emission of CS(65) is extended to the west, but its maximum is located close to the continuum peak (Fig. 16). The emission of the remaining lines is mostly compact and peaks within 6 of the continuum peak (Fig. 16). The stronger lines and the detection of transitions at higher excitation energies compared to W33 B1 and W33 A1 suggests that W33 B is even more evolved than W33 B1 and W33 A1.
W33 A In addition to the lines found in W33 B, we also detect emission of OCS(2322), HCN(3130), HCN(3231), and CHCCH(1716) in W33 A (Fig. 4). However, we do not observe emission of CS(65) or CHOH(34). The upper energy levels of the detected lines are between 27 and 231 K. The average central velocity of all transitions is 37.6 km s, which is close to the systemic velocity of 38.5 km s, determined by Galván-Madrid et al. (2010) from their SMA observations of W33 A. The average line width is 5.4 km s. The integrated emission of all lines in W33 A is compact and their maxima are located close to the continuum peak within 612 (Fig. 17). The object W33 A is probably more evolved than W33 B.
W33 Main Besides the transitions that we detect in W33 A and W33 B, we observe the higher-excitation transitions of CH3CCH (CH3CCH(171161), CH3CCH(172162), CH3CCH(173163), CH3CCH(174164)), and H213CO(41,331,2) in W33 Main (Fig. 4). The transition with the highest upper energy level Eu = 241 K is detected in this source. The average central velocity and line width of W33 Main are 35.6 km s1 and 6.0 km s1, respectively. Except for the N2H+, CS, and OCS transitions, the emission of all spectral lines peaks close to the continuum peak (Fig. 18). The N2H+ emission is strongest at the northwestern edge of the map. At the center of W33 Main, the N2H+ emission is much weaker (Fig. 18). This shows that N2H+ is not a good tracer of the dust continuum in evolved sources anymore (Reiter et al., 2011). The CS emission is spread from the center of the map to the north and peaks about 24 from the continuum peak to the north (Fig. 18). The emission of C33S, CH3CCH (except CH3CCH(174164)), CH3OH (except CH3OH(32,141,4) and CH3OH(62,452,3)), H2CO, and H2CS is also extended to the north but peaks close to the continuum peak (Fig. 18). The OCS emission is extended and the peak close to the center of the map is not very pronounced (Fig. 18). The extended emission hints to the existence of another source in the north of the map. Since CS and N2H+ trace cold gas, the line peak offsets of the CS and N2H+ emission from the continuum peak indicate that the gas towards the center of the W33 Main clump is not cold anymore. We conclude that W33 Main is not in an early stage of star formation anymore.
|W33 Main1||W33 A1||W33 B1|
|(GHz)||(K)||(K km s)||(K)||(km s)||(km s)||(K km s)||(K)||(km s)||(km s)||(K km s)||(K)||(km s)||(km s)|
Appendix B Results of the SMA line observations
W33 Main1 Besides the two CO lines CO and CO, we only observe emission of SO(65) in the spectrum of W33 Main1 (Fig. 8). CO is not detected at the position of the dust continuum peak, but extended emission of CO is observed in the W33 Main1 mosaic (Fig. 19). The upper energy levels E of the observed transitions are 1635 K. The average central velocity and the average line width are 35.9 km s and 4.0 km s, which are similar to the results of the APEX observations.
The blueshifted and redshifted CO(21) emission of W33 Main1 shows several peaks at and around the dust continuum peak (Fig. (a)a). The distribution of the emission does not look ordered and might be excited by turbulences in this source.
The moment 0 map of the SO transition shows compact emission, whose peak is offset by 2 from the dust continuum peak (Fig. 19). The moment 1 map of the SO transition shows a velocity gradient over the central part of the source (Fig. 24).
The lack of spectral lines besides the CO and SO transitions either indicates low temperatures in the dust core or the emission of more complex molecules is not compact enough to be detected with the SMA. Both hint to a very early evolutionary age of W33 Main1. We conclude that W33 Main1 is probably in an early protostellar phase before the protostar strongly influences the surrounding material, and strong emission of primary molecules like HCO and CHOH is detected.
W33 B1 In the spectrum of W33 B1, we detect the three transitions of HCO, CHOH(43), SO(65), and CO (Fig. 8). Extended emission of CO and C