Applications and non-idealities of submicron Al-AlOx-Nb tunnel junctions

Applications and non-idealities of submicron Al-AlOx-Nb tunnel junctions

J. K. Julin and I. J. Maasilta Nanoscience Center, Department of Physics, University of Jyvaskyla, P. O. Box 35, FIN-40014 Jyvaskyla, Finland maasilta@jyu.fi
August 28, 2019
Abstract

We have developed a technique to fabricate sub-micron, mm Al-AlOx-Nb tunnel junctions using a standard e-beam resist, angle evaporation and double oxidation of the tunneling barrier, resulting in high quality niobium, as determined by the the high measured values of the critical temperature K and the gap meV. The devices show great promise for local nanoscale thermometry in the temperature range 1 - 7.5 K. Electrical characterization of the junctions was performed at sub-Kelvin temperatures both with and without an external magnetic field, which was used to suppress superconductivity in Al and thus bring the junction into a normal-metal-insulator-superconductor (NIS) configuration. We observed excess sub-gap current, which could not be explained by the standard tunneling theory. Evidence points towards materials science issues of the barrier or Nb/AlOx interface as the culprit.

Keywords: superconducting tunnel junction, niobium, NIS junction, thermometry, sub-gap current

pacs:
74.55.+v, 74.70.-b, 74.78.Na, 81.15.Dj, 85.25.-j
: Supercond. Sci. Technol.\ioptwocol

1 Introduction

Superconducting tunnel junctions have proven to be valuable devices widely used in quantum bits, [1] sensitive magnetometers [2], metrological applications, [3], sensitive thermometers [4] and radiation detectors[5], and even electronic coolers [6]. Most devices so far have used either aluminum or niobium as the superconductor, due to the ease of fabrication and extensive know-how of their processing. Aluminum is particularly widely used, as its thermal oxide is of high quality, and thus simple room temperature oxidation of an Al film will produce a high quality tunnel barrier. For some applications, however, the critical temperature and the superconducting gap of Al are too low (typically K and meV, respectively) so that niobium is desired. However, it does not have the luxury of a good thermal oxide, so most Nb superconductor-insulator-superconductor (SIS) junctions are fabricated with a trilayer process [7], where a thin ( nm) Al layer must be deposited for the barrier formation.

The trilayer process for Nb junctions is well suited for devices where the junction size is above the sub-micron length scale. For smaller devices, it becomes easier to use the angle evaporation technique [8], which avoids multilayer lithography, deposition of insulators, and possible damage problems during the plasma etching in the trilayer process. A downside of the angle evaporation is that an e-beam sensitive polymer resist mask is used. This does not cause problems for Al based junctions, but is not as staightforward for Nb, as the quality of evaporated Nb is quite sensitive to the chamber and substrate conditions, such as vacuum level, evaporation speed, substrate to Nb crucible distance, and especially the type of resist used [9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15]. Problems with standard polymer resists such as poly-methyl-methacrylate (PMMA) are typically attributed to the decomposition and outgassing of the resist during Nb evaporation, leading to suppression of and [9, 10, 11, 12, 15] from the bulk values K and meV.

Here, we have successfully fabricated sub-micron Al/AlOx/Nb tunnel junctions using angle evaporation and standard PMMA/P(MMA-MAA) double layer resists, obtaining a high K and a high meV. Typically, such high quality sub-micron Nb tunnel junctions are fabricated with a special resist capable of withstanding higher thermal loads [16, 17], and only one other report of such high-quality Al/AlOx/Nb junction fabrication with PMMA exists [18], with device applications as superconducting single-electron transistors [19] in the ultra-small junction size (m) scale. In fact, Refs. [18, 19] used the same exact evaporator as here. In contrast to Refs. [18, 19], we use a different geometry allowing also a combination of smaller and larger junction sizes to be fabricated, and mostly focus on the junction properties in the normal-metal-insulator-superconductor (NIS) state, by either using temperatures above the Al 1.3 K, or by applying an appropriate external magnetic field () to suppress the superconductivity in Al, but not in Nb. The interest in the NIS geometry stems from thermometry [4], cooling [6], and metrological applications [3].

We find that although the Nb quality is high right at the junction as judged by the high , we observe excess sub-gap current in the NIS state which cannot be explained by the simplest theories of broadening of the superconducting density of states [20, 21, 22]. This result is in agreement with previous studies in Al/AlOx/Nb [19] and in Al/AlOx/V [23] junctions, but in contrast with our previous work with Nb-Al-AlOx-Cu [24] or other similarly fabricated NIS junctions of NbN [25] or TaN [26], where the simple Dynes broadening [20, 21] does explain the data. We comment at the end on the possible explanations for this difference.

2 Sample fabrication

If the goal is to fabricate a Nb-based NIS junction, there are two possibilities with angle evaporation: either the Nb is evaporated first or last. Let’s discuss the pros and cons of the two options. If Nb is evaporated first, the high evaporation temperature will not damage other films and especially the tunneling barrier. However, Nb can form several oxides [27], out of which only one, NbO, is a good insulator, so that thermal oxidation of Nb produces bad quality junctions. That’s why typically one has to evaporate a thin Al layer on top of the Nb, and oxidize the Al instead of the Nb [7]. For tri-layers, this works well, but with angle evaporation an added difficulty is that the Al layer must cover the Nb electrode well everywhere to prevent a direct leakage path from the Nb layer.

In our previous work [24], this coverage problem was solved with a special geometric electrode design. However, this approach leads to issues with the proximity effect of the Al layer, which degrades the superconducting properties of the Nb, by reducing and possibly also broadening the gap. It was also difficult to prevent the formation of an Al gap feature in the data, which was believed to be caused by parallel tunneling paths from purely Al areas of the tunnel junction [24]. The highest gap we observed in Nb-Al-AlOx-Cu junctions fabricated this way was meV, with a Dynes broadening [20, 21] parameter .

The second option is to evaporate the normal metal electrode first. Typically, the same barrier formation problem then exists, unless the normal metal is Al or its alloy [28]. The proximity effect problem is solved, but the question remains, does the hot, evaporated Nb cause damage or degradation of the underlying tunneling barrier? We decided to study this second option here by fabricating Al-AlOx-Nb junctions, as some preliminary success was reported before [18].

Figure 1: (a) A scanning electron microscope (SEM) image of an Al-AlOx-Nb tunnel junction. (b) A measured transition of a 600 nm wide Nb wire. (c) The measured resistance of a Al-AlOx-Nb tunnel junction around the Nb transition temperatures, showing three separate drops at 7.5 K, 8.2 K and 9.0 K, due to three different width regions of the sample.

The sample fabrication was done by electron beam lithography, by exposing a dual resist layer [PMMA and copolymer P(MMA-MAA)] on a surface of an oxidized silicon chip. This bi-layer forms the desired undercut structure, allowing angle evaporation. The junction geometry was such that the barrier is formed between the two metal layers crossing at 90 degree angle [Fig. 1(a)]. This way, different size junctions can be formed on the same normal metal island, facilitating different functionalities. In particular, for NIS thermometry and bolometry, one typically wants small area junctions to minimize self-heating, whereas larger area junctions operate much better as NIS coolers [6]. This is in contrast with hybrid NIS or fully superconducting single electron transistors, where for all junctions the size is minimized to increase charging energy [3, 19, 17]. To simplify matters here, we concentrate only on the properties of single junctions. The linewidth for both electrodes was measured to be about 600 nm, as can be seen from the SEM image in Fig. 1 (a).

Prior to any metal deposition, the chip was cleaned in a reactive ion etcher with an O plasma at 30-40 W power for 30 seconds, with a pressure of 40 mtorr and 50 sccm flow rate, to reduce the effect of PMMA resist contamination on the exposed areas. All evaporations were done in an electron-beam evaporator with a chamber in ultra high vacuum ( mbar), the Al oxidation was done in pure oxygen at room temperature in a separate loading chamber.

The first aluminium layer was deposited to a thickness 45 nm from a large 65 degree angle, and then oxidized for 5 minutes in 1 bar pressure of pure oxygen. After that, we tried depositing 80 nm of niobium on top at zero degrees from normal, with an evaporation speed of 0.5 nm/s. Note that this thickness is a factor of two more than in previous work on SET Al/AlOx/Nb junctions [18, 19, 17] and a factor of four more than in our own Cu-Nb NIS work [24]. This is important especially if we consider cooling applications, as thicker superconducting leads suffer less from non-equilibrium quasiparticle poisoning and back-tunneling [29, 6], both of which deteriorate the cooler performance. However, in all trials, this standard technique led to a short between the electrodes, indicating that the hot Nb caused significant damage to the tunneling barrier. This failure, as compared to previous work, may have resulted in our larger junction sizes and thicker films, causing higher thermal load on the junction.

The solution to this problem was to use a second, nm aluminum layer, deposited after the oxidation of the first layer, and also thermally oxidize it for 20 minutes in 1 bar, to form a double oxide barrier [30, 31]. After such a step, the evaporated Nb did not short the barriers anymore, leading to functioning Al/AlOx/Nb tunnel junctions.

3 Electrical characterization

To check the quality of the Nb, we also fabricated simple wires of the same width (600 nm) as the junction samples, and measured the superconducting transition, shown in Fig. 1 (b). A relatively high of 7.9 K is seen, and sometimes with similar conditions and widths as high as 8.6 K was observed. This is in stark contrast to narrow Nb wires made by several other groups using PMMA resists, where such width typically lead to suppression down to K [14, 11, 15], but in agreement with earlier work using the same evaporator [9]. We conclude that although clearly PMMA outgassing is detrimental for Nb, the use of PMMA is still possible, with the strength of the outgassing effect depending on the particular evaporator conditions, such as the distance between source and sample, for example.

The critical temperature of niobium used in the actual tunnel junction samples cannot be detected by searching for a sudden resistance drop to zero, since a high 50 kOhm tunneling resistance dominates over a much smaller wire resistance, thus making it more challenging to detect the small resistance change due to a superconducting transition. However, when accurately examined, it is possible to see three sharp and clear drops in the differential resistance measurement plot, superimposed over a general increase of the tunneling resistance with lowering temperature, see Fig.1 (c).These drops represent three different parts of the niobium leads having different widths, and thus slightly different critical temperatures. This is the most accurate data to measure the transition temperature of the niobium right at the tunnel junction region, which in the case of Fig. 1 (c) was 7.5 Kelvin (the smallest temperature corresponds the narrowest width structures in the sample).

For the rest of the measurements, a compact 3He-4He dilution refrigerator was used to measure the current-voltage characteristics of a single Al-AlOx-Nb tunnel junction at temperatures between 90 mK and 6.5 K. The sample was measured in a four probe configuration, with Thermocoax cables and copper powder filters providing microwave filtering in the cryostat lines, to prevent overheating by noise and excessive photon-assisted tunneling. The I-V measurements were performed with Ithaco 1201 voltage and 1211 current preamplifiers, and the voltage/current source was battery powered to reduce interference and noise. The refrigerator had a superconducting coil in the 4.2 K vacuum jacket, which was used to create a magnetic field perpendicular to the sample substrate plane, and thus perpendicular to the tunnel junctions. With the external magnetic field, the superconductivity in aluminum can be suppressed, thus changing the sample configuration from SIS’ to NIS even at the lowest temperatures.

Fig. 2 shows the measured response of the junction, plotted as differential conductance vs bias voltage, with varying external magnetic field strength, at a refrigerator temperature of mK. Concentrating first at the zero field data, one observes a clear supercurrent feature at zero bias, and another clear quasiparticle density of states (DOS) peak at around 1.5 mV. The position of the DOS peak is at the sum-gap in the SIS’ configuration. Clearly, the application of the field starts to suppress the supercurrent and shifts the DOS peak to a lower bias, as superconductivity in the Al electrode is gradually destroyed. At around 300 G, the shift of the peak stops, at which point Al has turned normal, and the peak position reflects only the size of the Nb gap meV. The amount of shift gives us then the value of the Al gap meV. No extra Al gap feature at is seen, in contrast to our earlier devices where Nb was deposited first [24].

Figure 2: Measured data at different magnetic fields at 140 mK temperature. Above G, when aluminum has turned normal, the Nb DOS does not change appreciably.

Niobium would require a much higher field to suppress its superconductivity. This is also confirmed by the data, as at fields higher than 300 G very little change is seen in the curves of Fig. 2. The conclusion is that the strengths of the external field used here do not directly influence superconductivity in the Nb lead. As the differential conductance is proportional to the quasiparticle DOS, no extra broadening or reduction of the gap due to pair-breaking caused by the magnetic field [32] is yet seen in Nb.

Figure 3: ((a) I-V measurements at mK with zero magnetic field (SIS’) and 450 G (NIS) in linear scale. (b) I-V curves at log-linear scales, where SIS’ data is shown at two different mK and 580 mK. Dotted lines show the simplest theoretical curves based on Eqs. 1-3 with the parameters shown.

Next, in Fig. 3 we compare the measured low-temperature characteristics with theory both in the SIS’ and NIS states, both in linear [Fig. 3 (a)] and log-linear [Fig. 3 (b)] scales. The measured - curves show the expected strong non-linearities due to the gap(s), clearly seen in Fig. 3 (a).

Theoretical plots are based on single-particle tunneling, which for the case of an NIS junction can be written in the symmetrized form [4] as

(1)

where is the tunneling resistance, the Fermi function in the normal metal wire, and is the normalized broadened superconducting quasiparticle DOS in the Dynes model [20]

(2)

with the broadening (Dynes) parameter and the temperature-dependent Nb gap. The above equation stresses the fact that in an NIS junction, current depends directly only on the temperature of the normal metal, not on the temperature of the superconductor (the temperature dependence of the gap does influence indirectly).

For an SIS’ junction, the current depends on the densities of states of both superconductors and and both Fermi-functions:

(3)

where each superconductor has its own Dynes parameter and .

The theoretical curves in Fig. 3 were calculated with Eqs. 1 - 3, using the known values of zero temperature gaps and and the known value of the bath temperature (assumed to be equal to the normal metal and the superconductor temperature), and only varying the unknown Dynes parameters. The Dynes parameters are well constrained above by the data, as increasing will increase the current close to zero bias.

We clearly observe in Fig. 3 that the theoretical curves only fit the data close to the zero bias and above the gap edge at mV, but cannot explain the data at an intermediate bias voltage range. A larger Dynes parameter for Nb cannot improve the fit, it would only lead to a stronger deviation, namely a too high current at bias close to zero and still a too low current at an intermediate range. On the other hand, overheating, i.e. an effective temperature higher than the bath temperature is not realistic either. This can be seen by looking at the SIS’ data in Fig. 3 (b) at voltages below the step feature at 0.225 mV (Al gap), where the fits are actually good using the known bath temperatures. We thus believe that the excess current at around 0.5 - 1.5 mV has some other unknown origin. Note that the Al gap feature in the SIS’ case is fully predicted by the single-particle tunneling theory, and evoking higher-order Andreev processes [17] is not required. In general, higher-order processes are very much suppressed in junctions with such high tunneling resistances as here ( k).

Let us now focus on the NIS data, where Al superconductivity is fully suppressed by the magnetic field. A set of measured characteristics with varying bath temperature, and some corresponding curves, are shown in Fig. 4. We observe that there is a clear temperature dependence, but only above K. It appears that the excess broadening saturates the response at temperatures below 1 K. The examples of theoretical curves shown in Fig. 4 confirm that fits are not satisfactory at any temperature, there is always excess current in the experimental data, even at the highest temperatures. This is consistent with physical additional sub-gap states within the Nb gap.

Figure 4: (a) Measured temperature dependence of the (a) characteristics and (b) characteristics in the NIS state, when external field G is applied. Lines show theoretical results based on Eqs. 1-2, with parameters meV, and temperatures , 2.48 and 5.38 K. Note that apparent good fit of the 5.38 K theory is to the 4.14 K data.

4 Thermometry applications

Although the simplest theories could not be used to fit the electrical characteristics in the NIS state, there was still a clear temperature dependence observed. This means that sensitive nanoscale thermometry is still possible with these type of junctions. We also checked the thermometric responsivity, see Fig.5, by constant current biasing the Al-AlOx-Nb device just below the Nb gap value at 0.9 nA, and by measuring the bath temperature dependent voltage across the junction, as the refrigerator temperature was varied between 100 mK and 6.5 K. Fig.5 shows both NIS (finite ) and SIS’ () data, in addition to the theory curve for the NIS case based on Eqs. 1-2, with the same parameters that were used in the - fits. As expected, the NIS and SIS’ data are identical at temperatures above the aluminum K. The measured responsivity mV/K is good and comparable to the responsivity of the Nb-AlOx-Cu NIS junctions[24]. Moreover, the responsivity is clearly enhanced by about a factor of two in the SIS’ state at temperatures 1.0 K - 1.3 K. The simplest theory, as in the case of the curves, cannot describe the experiment well, except for the saturation caused by the Dynes broadening at K.

Figure 5: Voltage vs. Temperature dependence of both NIS and SIS’ junctions when constant current biased to 0.9 nA. A simple NIS theory is shown as the solid line, with the same parameters as the - theory.

We conclude that Al-AlOx-Nb junctions fabricated in the way described here are actually quite promising for thermometry and bolometry [33, 34] applications in the temperature range 1 K - 7.5 K. This is quite useful as (i) standard NIS thermometers with Al as the superconductor are limited to work below 1K, and (ii) previous NIS devices with Nb [24], NbN [25] and TaN [26] as the superconductor require much more difficult sample fabrication techniques, making it much harder to integrate those devices with some other structures, for example for thermal transport measurements [35]. We believe Al-AlOx-Nb junctions are poised to do that in the near future, extending the temperature range of, for example, the phonon transport studies [35] by almost an order of magnitude. On the other hand, NIS cooling with the observed broadening of the DOS is not currently feasible.

5 Discussion and Conclusions

We have developed here a way to successfully fabricate sub-micron Al-AlOx-Nb tunnel junctions using standard e-beam resists and angle evaporation, with high quality Nb as determined by the measured values of the critical temperature and niobium gap meV, with the help of double oxidized tunneling barrier. The devices show great promise for local nanoscale thermometry in the temperature range 1 K - 7.5 K.

The simplest theories for single particle tunneling did not, however, manage to describe the experimental data well, neither in in the NIS state where magnetic field was used to suppress superconductivity in Al, nor in the SIS’ state. The experiment showed excess current, which could be interpreted as arising from additional quasiparticle states in the gap of Nb. We showed that these states cannot be described by the Dynes model [20], which quite often can be used to describe the broadening of the density of states, either due to enivronmentally induced photon-assisted tunneling [21], or due to quasiparticle lifetime effects [20]. We also showed that the pair-breaking by the applied magnetic field was not responsible for the broadening either, nor could higher-order (Andreev) tunneling [36] be responsible because of the high value of tunneling resistance in our samples. So we are currently left with an unsatisfying conclusion that full understanding is lacking.

Similar conclusions have been reached by other groups, either for somewhat similar Al-AlOx-Nb devices as here [19] or for Al-AlOx-V devices [23]. In both those cases, as in this study, the higher material (Nb or V) was evaporated on top of the tunneling barrier. In Ref. [19], a model of gap fluctuations within the tunneling barrier was developed to explain the additional broadening, whereas in Ref. [23] detailed interpretation was not attempted. An important point we want to make in this regard here is that we did not see these extra states in the Nb-Al-AlOx-Cu samples [24], where the lithography and Nb evaporation conditions (same evaporator) were practically identical. We thus have to conclude that material properties intrinsic to Nb, such as gap fluctuations, bulk impurity states etc. cannot explain the extra states in our experiment, and it may be quite relevant that in the experiments of Ref. [24], Nb was evaporated first and is not in direct contact with the barrier. It is possible that non-idealities are generated in the barrier itself if Nb is deposited on top, or that the interface of Nb with AlOx forms interfacial states that are responsible for the gap states, for example by the mechanism of magnetic scattering (Shiba-theory) [37]. Further studies on this issue are needed.

We acknowledge help in the experiments by A. Torgovkin, and help in the computational work by S. Chaudhuri and Z. Geng. This study was supported by the Academy of Finland project number 260880 and the Finnish Cultural Foundation.

References

References

  • [1] J. Clarke and F. K. Wilhelm. Nature, 453:1031, 2008.
  • [2] J. Clarke and A. I. Braginski, editors. The SQUID handbook. Wiley-VCH, Weinheim, 2004.
  • [3] Jukka P. Pekola, Olli-Pentti Saira, Ville F. Maisi, Antti Kemppinen, Mikko Möttönen, Yuri A. Pashkin, and Dmitri V. Averin. Single-electron current sources: Toward a refined definition of the ampere. Rev. Mod. Phys., 85:1421–1472, Oct 2013.
  • [4] F. Giazotto, T. T. Heikkilä, A. Luukanen, A. M. Savin, and J. P. Pekola. Rev. Mod. Phys., 78:217, 2006.
  • [5] P. Lerch and A. Zehnder. Cryogenic Particle Detection. Topics in Applied Physics. Springer, Berlin, 2005.
  • [6] Juha T Muhonen, Matthias Meschke, and Jukka P Pekola. Micrometre-scale refrigerators. Reports on Progress in Physics, 75(4):046501, 2012.
  • [7] M. Gurvitch, M. A. Washington, and H. A. Huggins. High quality refractory josephson tunnel junctions utilizing thin aluminum layers. Applied Physics Letters, 42(5), 1983.
  • [8] G. J. Dolan. Offset masks for lift-off photoprocessing. Applied Physics Letters, 31(5), 1977.
  • [9] Nam Kim, Klavs Hansen, Jussi Toppari, Tarmo Suppula, and Jukka Pekola. Fabrication of mesoscopic superconducting nb wires using conventional electron-beam lithographic techniques. Journal of Vacuum Science & Technology B, 20(1), 2002.
  • [10] J.P Pekola, J.M Kyynäräinen, M.M Leivo, and A.J Manninen. Nis chip refrigeration. Cryogenics, 39(8):653 – 657, 1999.
  • [11] R. Dolata, H. Scherer, A. B. Zorin, and J. Niemeyer. Single electron transistors with nb/alox/nb junctions. Journal of Vacuum Science & Technology B, 21(2), 2003.
  • [12] Y. Harada, D. B. Haviland, P. Delsing, C. D. Chen, and T. Claeson. Fabrication and measurement of a nb based superconducting single electron transistor. Applied Physics Letters, 65(5), 1994.
  • [13] P. Dubos, P. Charlat, Th. Crozes, P. Paniez, and B. Pannetier. Thermostable trilayer resist for niobium lift-off. Journal of Vacuum Science & Technology B, 18(1), 2000.
  • [14] T. Hoss, C. Strunk, and C. Sch nenberger. Nonorganic evaporation mask for superconducting nanodevices. Microelectronic Engineering, 46(1 4):149 – 152, 1999. International Conference on Micro- and Nanofabrication.
  • [15] Hyunsik Im, Yu. A. Pashkin, T. Yamamoto, O. Astafiev, Y. Nakamura, and J.-S. Tsai. Characterization of all-nb nanodevices fabricated by electron beam lithography and ion beam oxidation. Journal of Vacuum Science & Technology B, 25(2), 2007.
  • [16] R. Dolata, H. Scherer, A. B. Zorin, and J. Niemeyer. Single electron transistors with high-quality superconducting niobium islands. Applied Physics Letters, 80(15), 2002.
  • [17] Yu. A. Pashkin, H. Im, J. Leppäkangas, T. F. Li, O. Astafiev, A. A. Abdumalikov, E. Thuneberg, and J. S. Tsai. Charge transport through ultrasmall single and double josephson junctions coupled to resonant modes of the electromagnetic environment. Phys. Rev. B, 83:020502, Jan 2011.
  • [18] G. S. Paraoanu and Halvari A. Fabrication and measurement of superconducting nb-based junctions. Rev. Adv. Mater. Sci., 5:292–295, 2003.
  • [19] J. J. Toppari, T. Kühn, A. P. Halvari, J. Kinnunen, M. Leskinen, and G. S. Paraoanu. Cooper-pair resonances and subgap coulomb blockade in a superconducting single-electron transistor. Phys. Rev. B, 76:172505, Nov 2007.
  • [20] R. C. Dynes, J. P. Garno, G. B. Hertel, and T. P. Orlando. Tunneling study of superconductivity near the metal-insulator transition. Phys. Rev. Lett., 53:2437–2440, Dec 1984.
  • [21] J. P. Pekola, V. F. Maisi, S. Kafanov, N. Chekurov, A. Kemppinen, Yu. A. Pashkin, O.-P. Saira, M. Möttönen, and J. S. Tsai. Environment-assisted tunneling as an origin of the dynes density of states. Phys. Rev. Lett., 105:026803, Jul 2010.
  • [22] Bozidar Mitrovic and Lee A Rozema. On the correct formula for the lifetime broadened superconducting density of states. Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, 20(1):015215, 2008.
  • [23] Hiroshi Shimada, Kenji Miyawaki, Ayano Hagiwara, Kouichi Takeda, and Yoshinao Mizugaki. Characterization of superconducting single-electron transistors with small al/alox/v josephson junctions. Superconductor Science and Technology, 27(11):115015, 2014.
  • [24] M. R. Nevala, S. Chaudhuri, J. Halkosaari, J. T. Karvonen, and I. J. Maasilta. Sub-micron normal-metal/insulator/superconductor tunnel junction thermometer and cooler using nb. Applied Physics Letters, 101(11), 2012.
  • [25] S. Chaudhuri, M. R. Nevala, and I. J. Maasilta. Niobium nitride-based normal metal-insulator-superconductor tunnel junction microthermometer. Applied Physics Letters, 102(13), 2013.
  • [26] S. Chaudhuri and I. J. Maasilta. Superconducting tantalum nitride-based normal metal-insulator-superconductor tunnel junctions. Applied Physics Letters, 104(12), 2014.
  • [27] J. Halbritter. On the oxidation and on the superconductivity of niobium. Applied Physics A, 43(1):1–28, 1987.
  • [28] S. T. Ruggiero, A. Williams, W. H. Rippard, A. Clark, S. W. Deiker, L. R. Vale, and J. N. Ullom. Dilute al-mn alloys for low-temperature device applications. Journal of Low Temperature Physics, 134(3):973–984, 2004.
  • [29] A. M. Clark, A. Williams, S. T. Ruggiero, M. L. van den Berg, and J. N. Ullom. Practical electron-tunneling refrigerator. Applied Physics Letters, 84(4):625–627, 2004.
  • [30] E. P. Houwman, D. Veldhuis, J. Flokstra, and H. Rogalla. Fabrication and properties of nb/al, alox/nb josephson tunnel junctions with a double-oxide barrier. Journal of Applied Physics, 67(4), 1990.
  • [31] T. Holmqvist, M. Meschke, and J. P. Pekola. Double oxidation scheme for tunnel junction fabrication. Journal of Vacuum Science & Technology B, 26(1):28–31, 2008.
  • [32] A. Anthore, H. Pothier, and D. Esteve. Density of states in a superconductor carrying a supercurrent. Phys. Rev. Lett., 90:127001, Mar 2003.
  • [33] D. R. Schmidt, K. W. Lehnert, A. M. Clark, W. D. Duncan, K. D. Irwin, N. Miller, and J. N. Ullom. A superconductor insulator normal metal bolometer with microwave readout suitable for large-format arrays. Applied Physics Letters, 86(5), 2005.
  • [34] S. Gasparinetti, K. L. Viisanen, O.-P. Saira, T. Faivre, M. Arzeo, M. Meschke, and J. P. Pekola. Fast electron thermometry for ultrasensitive calorimetric detection. Phys. Rev. Applied, 3:014007, Jan 2015.
  • [35] Nobuyuki Zen, Tuomas A. Puurtinen, Tero J. Isotalo, Saumyadip Chaudhuri, and Ilari J. Maasilta. Engineering thermal conductance using a two-dimensional phononic crystal. Nat. Comm., 5:3435, 2014.
  • [36] Sukumar Rajauria, P. Gandit, T. Fournier, F. W. J. Hekking, B. Pannetier, and H. Courtois. Andreev current-induced dissipation in a hybrid superconducting tunnel junction. Phys. Rev. Lett., 100:207002, May 2008.
  • [37] T. Proslier, J. F. Zasadzinski, L. Cooley, C. Antoine, J. Moore, J. Norem, M. Pellin, and K. E. Gray. Tunneling study of cavity grade nb: Possible magnetic scattering at the surface. Applied Physics Letters, 92(21), 2008.
Comments 0
Request Comment
You are adding the first comment!
How to quickly get a good reply:
  • Give credit where it’s due by listing out the positive aspects of a paper before getting into which changes should be made.
  • Be specific in your critique, and provide supporting evidence with appropriate references to substantiate general statements.
  • Your comment should inspire ideas to flow and help the author improves the paper.

The better we are at sharing our knowledge with each other, the faster we move forward.
""
The feedback must be of minimum 40 characters and the title a minimum of 5 characters
   
Add comment
Cancel
Loading ...
180752
This is a comment super asjknd jkasnjk adsnkj
Upvote
Downvote
""
The feedback must be of minumum 40 characters
The feedback must be of minumum 40 characters
Submit
Cancel

You are asking your first question!
How to quickly get a good answer:
  • Keep your question short and to the point
  • Check for grammar or spelling errors.
  • Phrase it like a question
Test
Test description