Ab initio calculations of reactions with light nuclei
Abstract
An ab initio (i.e., from first principles) theoretical framework capable of providing a unified description of the structure and low-energy reaction properties of light nuclei is desirable to further our understanding of the fundamental interactions among nucleons, and provide accurate predictions of crucial reaction rates for nuclear astrophysics, fusion-energy research, and other applications. In this contribution we review ab initio calculations for nucleon and deuterium scattering on light nuclei starting from chiral two- and three-body Hamiltonians, obtained within the framework of the ab initio no-core shell model with continuum. This is a unified approach to nuclear bound and scattering states, in which square-integrable energy eigenstates of the -nucleon system are coupled to target-plus-projectile wave functions in the spirit of the resonating group method to obtain an efficient description of the many-body nuclear dynamics both at short and medium distances and at long ranges.
21st International Conference on Few-Body Problems in Physics
1 Introduction
Understanding the structure and the dynamics of nuclei as many-body systems of protons and neutrons interacting through the strong force is one of the central goals of nuclear physics. As systems that are amenable for accurate first-principle or ab initio calculations, light nuclei represent an excellent testing ground in such an effort. Until about eight years ago, with the exception of studies involving nucleons or less, most of the progress in this direction has been achieved through ab initio calculations of well-bound nuclear states and their properties. However, efforts to generalize ab initio many-body techniques to also encompass nuclei that are weakly bound, or that only exist as low-energy resonances, as well as to explain light-nucleus scattering and low-energy reactions have been growing, driven by new ideas, the rising availability of data on exotic nuclei, and increased access to high-performance computing. At the same time, effective field theory (EFT) and renormalization group transformations are providing nuclear theorists with a systematic approach to, and a much-improved understanding of the nuclear forces, and are yielding increasingly precise interactions and theoretical uncertainties, which are the basis for accurate predictions. The combination of these developments is opening the exciting prospect of a predictive and quantified theory of light-nucleus reactions important for applications, e.g.: scattering processes widely used in material science to probe thin films, or analyze the surface of artworks and archeological artifacts; thermonuclear fusion reactions crucial for big-bang and stellar nucleosyntesis; or those that power research facilities directed toward developing fusion energy. For the success of such a program it is essential to properly understand three key elements and their interplay: the role of nucleon-nucleon (NN) and three-nucleon (3N) forces; the influence of open channels and continuum degrees of freedom; and the propagation of the uncertainties in interaction models into error bars on computed observables. In this contribution we will review recent progress in addressing the first two of these elements by means of ab initio calculations of light-nucleus structure and dynamics carried out within the no-core shell model with continuum (NCSMC) approach. In particular, in Sec. 2 we will briefly outline the main aspects of the NCSMC formalism, while results for nucleon- and deuterium-nucleus dynamics employing chiral EFT NN+3N forces will be discussed in Sec. 3. Concluding remarks and future prospects will be presented in Sec. 4.
2 Formalism
To achieve a unified ab initio description of structural and reaction properties of light nuclei, we work within the theoretical framework of the NCSMC, introduced in Refs. [1] and [2]. In this approach, the translational-invariant ansatz for the many-body wave function in each partial wave of total angular momentum , parity and isospin , is given by a superposition of square-integrable energy eigenstates of the compound -nucleon system and continuous cluster states according to:
(1) |
Here represent antisymmetric, translation-invariant discrete eigenstates of the -nucleon Hamiltonian, labelled by the energy index . They are obtained ahead of time by means of the ab initio no-core shell model (NCSM) [3] through the diagonalization of the -nucleon microscopic Hamiltonian within a model space spanned by many-body harmonic oscillator (HO) wave functions with up to HO excitations above the unperturbed configuration and frequency . Further
(2) |
are continuous resonating-group method (RGM) [4, 5] basis states, representing an -nucleon target and -nucleon projectile (with ), whose centers of mass are separated by the relative coordinate , traveling in a wave of relative motion (with the channel spin, and the relative momentum of the system). The eigenstates and of each cluster of nucleons are obtained analogously to, and consistently with those of the -nucleon system and are characterized by total angular momentum , parity , isospin , and energy index . The index collects all quantum numbers associated with this continuous basis, and its full antisymmetrization is recovered by introducing an appropriate inter-cluster antisymmetrizer , which accounts for exchanges of nucleons between target and projectile. The unknown discrete and continuous variational amplitudes, are the solutions of the orthogonalized coupled-channel equations
(3) |
which follow from the many-body Schrödinger equation when using the ansatz (1) for the many-body wave function and projecting over the model space spanned by the and basis states. In Eq. (3), denotes the total energy of the system and the two by two block-matrices on the left- and right-hand side of the equation represent, respectively, the NCSMC Hamiltonian and norm (or overlap) kernels. The upper diagonal blocks are given by the Hamiltonian (overlap) matrix elements over the square-integrable part of the basis. In particular, as the basis states are NCSM eigenstates of the -nucleon Hamiltonian, these are trivially given by the diagonal matrix of the eigenergies (the identity matrix). Similarly, those over the orthonormalized continuous portion of the basis appear in the lower diagonal block and are obtained from the norm (or overlap) RGM kernel and Hamiltonian kernel [6, 7]. The off diagonal blocks contain the couplings between the two sectors of the basis, with and . The scattering matrix (and from it any scattering observable) follows from matching the solutions of Eq. (3) with the known asymptotic behavior of the wave function at large distances by means of the microscopic -matrix method [8, 9].
3 Unified description of structure and reaction observables with chiral two- and three-nucleon forces
The ab initio NCSMC was initially developed to compute nucleon-nucleus collisions starting from a two-body Hamiltonian and applied to the description of the unbound He nucleus [1, 2]. The approach was later extended to include explicit 3N forces, which are necessary to obtain a truly accurate and quantitative description of light-nucleus scattering process [10, 11]. In the following we review applications of such an extended approach, using an Hamiltonian based on the chiral NLO NN interaction of Ref. [12] and NLO 3N force of Ref. [13], constrained to provide an accurate description of the and [14] systems and unitarily softened via the similarity-renormalization-group (SRG) method [15, 16, 17, 18, 19] to minimize the influence of momenta higher than a low-momentum resolution scale of fm. In particular, Sec. 3.1 discusses predictions of elastic scattering and recoil of protons off He [20], as well as a study of continuum and -force effects on the energy levels of Be [21]. In Sec. 3.2 we review the first application to describe more challenging deuterium-nucleus dynamics [22], and discuss our ongoing effort to describe deuteron-induced nucleon transfer reactions.
3.1 Nucleon-nucleus scattering
The recent NCSMC study of low-energy cross sections for elastic scattering and recoil of protons from He of Ref. [20] is an excellent example of how the combination of efficient ab initio approaches, accurate nuclear interactions and high-performance computing capabilities can lead to a predictive theory of light-nucleus reactions important for applications. In this case, accurate HeHe and HHe angular differential cross sections for a variety of proton/He incident energies and detection angles are key to the feasibility and quality of ion-beam analysis applications aimed at determining the concentrations and depth profiles of helium and hydrogen, respectively, at the surface of materials or in thin films. Starting from SRG-evolved chiral NN+3N forces with fm, accurate results for He scattering were obtained by employing an , MeV HO model space, proton-He binary-cluster basis states including up to the first seven ( 00, 00, 00, 20, 21, 11 and 10) He eigenstates, and the first fourteen (of which three and two ) square-integrable eigenstates of the Li compound nucleus.
As can be seen from Fig. 1 the computed NCSMC angular differential cross sections agree very well with data both for HeHe and HHe processes. For comparison, in panels (a) and (b) we also show as black dashed lines the results [36] obtained within a model space spanned by He cluster states alone, that is by retaining only the second term of Eq. (1) and solving . While the high-energy tail of the cross section can already be described well working within such more limited model space, the inclusion of square-integrable eigenstates of the compound Li system is essential at lower energy, where it efficiently compensates for missing higher excitations of the He core.
At the same time, a proper treatment of continuum degrees of freedom is also indispensable to draw reliable conclusions on the influence of 3N forces in the low-lying spectra of loosely bound systems, such as Be, for which all excited states lie above the +Be threshold. The positive parity resonances of this nucleus are in general found too high in energy compared to experiment, in ab initio calculations that treat them as bound states such in the NCSM study of Ref. [37]. In the same setting, counter to expectations, the splitting between the lowest and resonances tends to be overestimated when effects are included. A recent NCSMC study of Be as a linear combination of 9-body square-integrable eigenstates and Be+ binary-cluster states with the Be in its ground and states [21] helped shed some light on the interplay of continuum degrees of freedom and 3N force effects in this nucleus. As can be seen in Fig. 2, for all energy levels the inclusion of the continuum significantly improves the agreement with experiment. In particular, the splitting between the and levels is substantially reduced when the continuum is included due to a shift towards lower energies of the resonance. However, the most dramatic continuum effects were found in the positive-parity resonances, shown in Fig. 2(b). The and the -wave resonances are several MeV lower in the NCSMC, close to their experimental value.
3.2 Deuterium-induced reactions
One of the most challenging and notable applications of the NCSMC accomplished so far is the simultaneous study of the Li ground state and He elastic scattering using NN+3N forces from chiral effective field theory (softened – as in the previous section – by means of an SRG transformation with fm) [22]. Unless otherwise stated, all calculations were carried out using the ansatz of Eq. (1) with fifteen discrete eigenstates of the Li system and continuous -He(g.s.) binary-cluster states with up to seven deuteron pseudostates in the , and channels. Convergence in the HO expansions was approached at at , using a frequency of MeV, around which the Li g.s. energy calculated within the square-integrable basis of the NCSM becomes nearly insensitive to [39].
Similar to the proton-He scattering discussed earlier, also in this case the square-integrable eigenstates of the compound (here Li) system play a crucial role in achieving an accurate description of the dynamic process. Besides helping to account for the polarization of the He, of which we can (computationally) afford to include only the g.s., here they also contribute to the description of the projectile distortion. This is exemplified by the fairly rapid convergence, shown in the left panel of Fig. 3, of the He scattering phase shifts with respect to the number of deuterium pseudostates. The high quality of the results obtained with the chiral NN+3N forces is corroborated by the good agreement with experiment of Fig. 3 (right panel), presenting HeHe angular distributions in the MeV interval of incident energies.
At the same time, the inclusion of continuum degrees of freedom is essential to reach a true understanding of a nucleus with low breakup threshold such as Li, the ground state of which lies only 1.47 MeV (compared to its absolute energy of nearly 32 MeV) below the He separation energy. As shown in Fig. 5, combined with the inclusion of the force, the NCSMC yields a rather good agreement with the observed spectrum. As one should expect, for the ground state and the narrow resonance the NCSMC energy levels are also in good agreement with those obtained from an extrapolation to of a traditional NCSM calculation. This is a strong indication that the slight overestimation of the first excited state is likely due to remaining deficiencies in the adopted 3N force model, particularly concerning the strength of the spin-orbit interaction. However, only within the NCSMC do the computed wave functions present the correct asymptotic, which for the g.s. are Whittaker functions. This is essential for the extraction of the asymptotic normalization constants. The present calculation reproduces the empirical binding energy of Li, yielding an asymptotic D- to S-state ratio of the Li wave function in configuration of in agreement with a determination from Li-He elastic scattering [40]. Contrary to the lighter nuclei, this ratio was still uncertain for Li, with different determinations disagreeing even as to its sign [41].
The above accurate studies of nucleon- and deuterium-He elastic scattering with chiral NN+3N interactions set the stage for the most advanced ab initio calculation of the HHe fusion, currently under way. This study is being carried out within an over-complete NCSMC model space including He(g.s.) and H(g.s.) continuous basis states, as well as square-integrable discrete eigenstates of the compound He nucleus. Figure 5 shows preliminary results for the He scattering phase shifts from zero to 24 MeV in the center-of-mass energy. Despite the fairly small size of the harmonic oscillator basis, the calculation is in close agreement with experiment. In particular, besides a slight shift of the -wave resonances to lower energies, the inclusion of H channels leads to the appearance of a resonance in the partial wave, just above the H threshold. This is the exit channel of the deuterium-tritium fusion.
4 Conclusions and future prospects
A unified ab initio description of light-nucleus structure and reaction properties starting from accurate NN+3N forces is now becoming possible, thanks in part to the NCSMC approach. This is an ab initio theory including the continuum which combines the efficient description of short- and medium-range correlations of the NCSM with the ability of the RGM of describing the scattering physics of a system. In this contribution, we reviewed recent applications of the approach to the description of elastic scattering and recoil of protons from He, continuum and 3N-force effects on the energy levels of the Be, and Li structure and He dynamics using chiral NN+3N forces. Building on this work, we are now pursuing several new applications to light-nucleus structure and reaction properties with chiral NN+3N forces. The obtained accurate nucleon-He scattering wave functions are currently being used as input for the study of the HeHe and HeHe bremsstrahlung, the radiative process by which a photon is emitted as a result of the nuclear collision between a nucleon and a He nucleus. The former is one of the few measured light-nucleus bremsstrahlung cross sections, while the latter is a necessary preliminary step for the study of the more complicated HHe bremsstrahlung cross section, which could be used to diagnose plasmas in fusion experiments but is not known well enough. The general NCSMC framework applicable to targets heavier than He is now being applied to study continuum and 3N force effects on the low-lying spectrum of the Be one-neutron halo nucleus and its photodissociation into Be. The obtained accurate Li ground state and He scattering wave functions set the stage for the first ab initio study of the HLi radiative capture, responsible for the big-bang nucleosynthesis of Li, as well as the calculation of Li g.s. properties including the effect of the continuum degrees of freedom. Finally, we are in the process of carrying out the first ab initio calculation of the HHe fusion using chiral NN+3N forces.
Prepared in part by LLNL under Contract DE-AC52-07NA27344. This material is based upon work supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Nuclear Physics, under Work Proposal Number SCW1158, the NSERC Grant Number 401945-2011, the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft through Contract SFB 634, the Helmholtz International Center for FAIR within the framework of the LOEWE program launched by the State of Hesse, and the BMBF through Contract No. 06DA7074I. TRIUMF receives funding via a contribution through the Canadian National Research Council. Computing support for this work came from the LLNL institutional Computing Grand Challenge program, the National Energy Research Scientific Computing Center (edison) supported by the Office of Science of the U.S. Department of Energy under Contract No. DE-AC02-05CH11231, the LOEWE-CSC Frankfurt, the computing center of the TU Darmstadt (lichtenberg), and from an INCITE Award on the Titan supercomputer of the Oak Ridge Leadership Computing Facility (OLCF) at ORNL.
References
- S. Baroni, P. Navrátil, S. Quaglioni, Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 022505 (2013)
- S. Baroni, P. Navrátil, S. Quaglioni, Phys. Rev. C 87, 034326 (2013)
- P. Navrátil, J.P. Vary, B.R. Barrett, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 5728 (2000)
- Y.C. Tang, M. LeMere, D.R. Thompsom, Phys. Rep. 47, 167 (1978)
- K. Langanke, H. Friedrich, Advances in Nuclear Physics (Plenum, New York, 1987)
- S. Quaglioni, P. Navrátil, Phys. Rev. Lett. 101, 092501 (2008)
- S. Quaglioni, P. Navrátil, Phys. Rev. C 79, 044606 (2009)
- M. Hesse, J.M. Sparenberg, F. Van Raemdonck, D. Baye, Nucl. Phys. A 640, 37 (1998)
- M. Hesse, J. Roland, D. Baye, Nucl. Phys. A 709, 184 (2002)
- K.M. Nollett, S.C. Pieper, R.B. Wiringa, J. Carlson, G.M. Hale, Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 022502 (2007)
- M. Viviani, L. Girlanda, A. Kievsky, L.E. Marcucci, Few-Body Syst. 54, 885 (2013)
- D.R. Entem, R. Machleidt, Phys. Rev. C 68, 041001 (2003)
- P. Navrátil, Few-Body Syst. 41, 117 (2007)
- D. Gazit, S. Quaglioni, P. Navrátil, Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 102502 (2009)
- S.D. GÅazek, K.G. Wilson, Phys. Rev. D 48, 5863 (1993)
- F. Wegner, Ann. Phys. 506, 77 (1994)
- S.K. Bogner, R.J. Furnstahl, R.J. Perry, Phys. Rev. C 75, 061001 (2007)
- H. Hergert, R. Roth, Phys. Rev. C 75, 051001 (2007)
- E.D. Jurgenson, P. Navrátil, R.J. Furnstahl, Phys. Rev. Lett. 103, 082501 (2009)
- G. Hupin, S. Quaglioni, P. Navrátil, Phys. Rev. C 90, 061601 (2014)
- J. Langhammer, P. Navrátil, S. Quaglioni, G. Hupin, A. Calci, R. Roth, Phys. Rev. C 91, 021301 (2015)
- G. Hupin, S. Quaglioni, P. Navrátil, Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 212502 (2015)
- G. Freier, E. Lampi, W. Sleator, J.H. Williams, Phys. Rev. 75, 1345 (1949)
- W.E. Kreger, W. Jentschke, P.G. Kruger, Phys. Rev. 93, 837 (1954)
- P. Miller, G.C. Phillips, Phys. Rev. 112, 2043 (1958)
- A.C.L. Barnard, C.M. Jones, J.L. Weil, Nucl. Phys. 50, 604 (1964)
- A. Nurmela, E. Rauhala, J. Räisänen, J. Appl. Phys. 82, 1983 (1997)
- S. Nagata, S. Yamaguchi, Y. Fujino, Y. Hori, N. Sugiyama, K. Kamada, Nucl. Instr. and Meth. B 6, 533 (1985)
- J.E.E. Baglin, A.J. Kellock, M.A. Crockett, A.H. Shih, Nucl. Instr. and Meth. B 64, 469 (1992)
- Y. Wang, J. Chen, F. Huang, Nucl. Instr. and Meth. B 17, 11 (1986)
- I. Bogdanović Radović, O. Benka, Nucl. Instr. and Meth. B 174, 25 (2001)
- S.K. Kim, H.D. Choi, Nucl. Instr. and Meth. B 174, 33 (2001)
- J.C. Keay, D.C. Ingram, Nucl. Instr. and Meth. B 211, 305 (2003)
- P. Pusa, E. Rauhala, A. Gurbich, A. Nurmela, Nucl. Instr. and Meth. B 222, 686 (2004)
- J.F. Browning, J.C. Banks, W.R. Wampler, B.L. Doyle, Nucl. Instr. and Meth. B 219-220, 317 (2004)
- G. Hupin, J. Langhammer, P. Navrátil, S. Quaglioni, A. Calci, R. Roth, Phys. Rev. C 88, 054622 (2013)
- C. Forssén, P. Navrátil, W.E. Ormand, E. Caurier, Phys. Rev. C 71, 044312 (2005)
- R. Roth, S. Binder, K. Vobig, A. Calci, J. Langhammer, P. Navrátil, Phys. Rev. Lett. 109, 052501 (2012)
- E.D. Jurgenson, P. Navrátil, R.J. Furnstahl, Phys. Rev. C 83, 034301 (2011)
- E.A. George, L.D. Knutson, Phys. Rev. C 59, 598 (1999)
- D. Tilley, C. Cheves, J. Godwin, G. Hale, H. Hofmann, J. Kelley, C. Sheu, H. Weller, Nucl. Phys. A 708, 3 (2002)
- J.H. Jett, J.L. Detch, N. Jarmie, Phys. Rev. C 3, 1769 (1971)
- L.S. Senhouse, T.A. Tombrello, Nucl. Phys. 57, 624 (1964)